Live data from Hacker News

Threads users down by more than a half

bbc.com

321–330 of 566 posts

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#321

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What’s X?

The X Window System allows applications to present bitmap images on a display, and receive mouse and keyboard input. The main implementation is X.Org, shepherded by the X.Org Foundation: https://x.org/ . Originally for Unix-like systems, it is now available on many other architectures, such as Microsoft Windows: I find ssh's X forwarding feature especially useful there.

So does twitter redirect to x.org now?

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm, not for me. I’m a pretty casual IG user, but I am following 500+ accounts, all of which I enjoy. My first experience with Threads (despite importing my IG profile) was a feed full of accounts I had never heard of before, and almost nothing from the accounts I follow. Granted, that’s probably because the accounts I follow weren’t posting Threads yet, but but even now things haven’t changed much in that regard. Ad…

> I’m sure if I put a little effort into it I could find more interesting accounts to follow Plenty of good developer-focused content now, and they implemented a following-only feed. Worth having, for me so far.

Curious about this: any developers focused account you’d recommend?

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#323

Earlier quoted context omitted.

By this logic Twitter should also be growing, as it’s even better than threads in terms of content. Yet not only is Twitter not growing but it’s shrinking. I think your expectations for success in this vertical are off.

> Yet not only is Twitter not growing but it’s shrinking. Source? Musk just tweeted about a new all-time monthly user record. It's not impossible that he would lie, but my impression is not at all that Twitter is shrinking. There's a whole lot of discussion about Twitter shrinking and high profile people leaving, but they don't. Stephen king comes to mind as a big critic that threatened over and over to leave, but he…

> new all-time monthly user record

I have been using Twitter almost since the beginning.

Never have I ever seen this many bots and fake accounts on the platform.

So I would be highly dubious of that user record count.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#324
We already have a thing where everyone on the internet can congregate, then split off and find sub-communities of interest (such as this excellent one right here) to participate in.

It's called The Internet.

I don't see the attraction of turning that into a massive, homogenised, centralised commercial product under private control. Never have.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#325
Not surprised the app really doesn’t seem to have a purpose.

Cannot search by hashtag. Not sorted by time … cannot post on news / politics.

It’s really just a generated text / pic thread for content consumption featuring mostly ads and payed celebrity marketing.

I used it for a few days and honestly cannot think of any upside.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#326
post #319

It's pretty common that after a peak of new signups, most do not convert to long term active users. This doesn't even take into account that most "active users" tend to never post anything, they just leech. They still count as MAU. I'm sure that Meta has plenty of ways to boost that number in the long term but overall I find the entire thing underwhelming. Threads is text-based Instagram. But not even that as you can…

It’s hard to say. What I see is a lot of people in my network really scaling back or dropping Twitter and maybe playing with the alternatives but not really embracing them. I suspect that for many it will be a case of “Social media was nice while it lasted.”

Sounds like Musk did them a favor.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#327
post #319

It's pretty common that after a peak of new signups, most do not convert to long term active users. This doesn't even take into account that most "active users" tend to never post anything, they just leech. They still count as MAU. I'm sure that Meta has plenty of ways to boost that number in the long term but overall I find the entire thing underwhelming. Threads is text-based Instagram. But not even that as you can…

It’s hard to say. What I see is a lot of people in my network really scaling back or dropping Twitter and maybe playing with the alternatives but not really embracing them. I suspect that for many it will be a case of “Social media was nice while it lasted.”

I think that's an excellent point. Social media fatigue seems at its peak in this time of transition, further accelerated by the COVID era.

People are becoming aware of their over-usage and the largely minimal or even negative benefits that come from social media altogether. Or just bored and indifferent about it. The fatigue is further strengthened when they soon learn that the alternatives are worse or at best just moving the problem.

I'd advocate for people to stop rather than cheer for any new potential winner. Just uninstall the app and walk away. It was all a lie anyway. You're not in a "community". You do not actually have followers. You did not learn anything new that you couldn't learn elsewhere.

They are lies we tell ourselves as we play the slot machine. Throw it in the trash.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#328

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Absolutely this is failure. Twitter/threads is (or should be) a highly viral application. New users should find themselves compelled to use the product and compelled to encourage others to use it. With a 100 million user head start, if they were succeeding this shoukd have immediately resulted in the viral loop being triggered into explosive growth. It’s a huge failure. Not necessarily unrecoverable, but absolutely a…

People in here are emotionally invested in seeing Musk fail, no amount of reasoning can make them see the forrest from the trees.

Oh no no, in my reading of the sentiments here they are emotionally invested in seeing the whole xthreads things crash and burn. I’m buying popcorn.

For all it’s faults I quite enjoyed pre-musky Twitter, but I completely abandoned the s...show even before the insane rename. I was an early FB user but left that many years ago around the time of the CA scandal.

Mastrodon is too quirky and challenging to go mainstream which is why I think it will remain great and I’m loving it there.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#329

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The next time Twitter goes down, and it will any day now People have been saying this since the day Elon took over... but has it really gone down that much? More than other tech products? E.g. how many outages have the big cloud providers had in the last year? When I hear people say 'any day now' it reads like they are looking for any excuse to say 'mars man bad'.

I don't know about outages, but Twitter's website has become completely erratic for me. Sometime it will load replies, sometimes it won't. Sometimes it will login-wall content, sometimes it won't. Sometimes I just get an error page. Clicking on a Twitter link today is like rolling the dice on whether you'll actually see anything or not.

You should check your internet connection. It's much more likely that it's you who are having problems.

Re: Threads users down by more than a half

#330
post #319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s hard to say. What I see is a lot of people in my network really scaling back or dropping Twitter and maybe playing with the alternatives but not really embracing them. I suspect that for many it will be a case of “Social media was nice while it lasted.”

Sounds like Musk did them a favor.

Lots of people used Twitter to keep in touch with professional peers and other non-outrage communities of interest. So that’s a cheap lazy take.

But I do think there’s some regret that is similar in nature to the Eternal September. Things were “fine” before the plebes and political interests found the platform.

Post reply on HN