Live data from Hacker News

The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

arxiv.org

371–380 of 906 posts

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#371

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The recipe in the paper is so simple that it's giving me Pons-Fleischmann vibes. It reads more like an entry from an alchemist's journal, reproducible with chemicals and equipment you could buy on eBay or Amazon. So, yeah: big if true.

Silicon is one of the most abundant elements on Earth and for thousands of years humans had no idea what would be possible with very controlled etching of it.

Mildly-topical Terry Pratchett amusement quote, since it involves a society that has overlooked the power of silicon plus the potential of superconductivity:

> Detritus blinked. There was a tinkle of falling ice. Odd things were happening in his skull. Thoughts that normally ambulated sluggishly around his brain were suddenly springing into vibrant, coruscating life. And there seemed to be more and more of them.

> 'My goodness,' he said, to no-one in particular.

> This was a sufficiently un-troll-like comment that even Cuddy, whose extremities were already going numb, stared at him.

> 'I do believe,' said Detritus, 'that I am genuinely cogitating. How very interesting!'

> 'What do you mean?'

> More ice cascaded off Detritus as he rubbed his head.

> 'Of course!' he said, holding up a giant finger. 'Superconductivity!'

> 'Wha'?'

> 'You see? Brain of impure silicon. Problem of heat dissipation. Daytime temperature too hot, processing speed slows down, weather gets hotter, brain stops completely, trolls turn to stone until nightfall, ie, colder-temperature,however,lowertemperatureenough,brain operatesfasterand—'

> [...] Detritus sat down again. Life was so simple, when you really thought about it. And he was really thinking. He was seventy-six per cent sure he was going to get at least seven degrees colder.

-- Men At Arms by Terry Pratchett

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#372
post #305

- Please check out my paper, we just found a new superconductor, it has a critical temperature of 127 degrees. - Look, I'm a bit busy right now - Celsius

I don't understand, I assume it's a dialogue? What is the meaning of the punchline being Celsius? Does the first sentence intend to include "room-temperature"?

The joke is, the second person heard 127 degrees, assumed that was Kelvin, and dismissed it as unimpressive. Then they realized it was 127 degrees Celsius, which is MUCH more impressive.

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#373

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't this how copper already works without superconductivity? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sENgdSF8ppA

Only temporarily. After a fraction of a second the dampening isn't strong enough anymore to prevent the two from entering into contact.

And I think that's what we are seeing in the video. The eddy current effect isn't permanent like in superconductivity. They have to keep moving the magnet around.

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#375
post #322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One catch would be the use of lead would restrict the use cases fairly heavily

Lead is used everywhere. Not in paint anymore but you can buy lead weights at hardware stores. Don't grind it up and put it in your muni water supply, but it's a household substance that is harmful if ingested, like many others.

another example, you can still buy lead based solder, even at a local hardware store.

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#377

The method to produce this material as described in the related paper [1] is fairly simple and could be done at home with a $200 home metal melting furnace from amazon and the precursors (which also seem to be fairly standard easy to obtain metals). If this is real, I'd expect some smart people from hackaday / youtube to reproduce this within weeks if not days. If this is real, it'll change society quickly and perman…

Does anyone in the twin cities area want to pair up and try to make this? Might be a fun group project.

I’d be down. Shoot me an email: hn@valine.io

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#378

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the biggest scientific discovery of the last hundred years I would say that electronic computers would take take the first spot for me, but I don't deny that room-temperature superconductors would be pretty close to the top.

I’d say electronic computers were the biggest invention of the last 100 years. But it wasn’t one discovery, that built upon many, many discoveries and breakthroughs. As a singular discovery goes, it’s hard to think of something that tops this. Of course, even if this is true, bringing it to market in a practical way will probably look a lot more like the invention of electronic computers.

Hmm, maybe the atomic bomb? The wright brothers's first flight took place about 120 years ago, so it doesn't qualify. However, in both cases, people knew it was a matter of time before someone figured the proper recipe. Room temperature/pressure semiconductors? That was still science fiction yesterday.

In short, you are probably right, with the sibling commenting on (BJT) transistors.

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#379

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> more about producing toxic waste Compared to refining traditional conductors and recycling/disposing of used electronics? > you still have to use lead-free solder One, fumes. Two, people touch their solder and then grab a cookie. We're premature. The results need to be proven. But the benefits of RTP superconductors is mindblowingly high enough that risks from lead contamination (far from a novel problem, I might a…

It's like fundamental best practice to always wash your hands thoroughly with soap if you handle leaded solder. You might want to read more in the links I shared about the harmful effects of lead before "whatabouting" to other problems of electronics recycling/waste. and yes, it's entirely possible this application would get an exemption from usual restrictions on lead. For example in the EU directive, one of the exe…

> fundamental best practice to always wash your hands thoroughly with soap if you handle leaded solder

But people don't, particularly students, and sometimes they also let their irons run too hot at which point fumes become an issue. Also, there is an easy alternative, so why not.

If the choice is lead superconductor or not, nobody is going to pause on a use case because there is lead. If they do, and if this is real, please let me know--I'd love to have them as competition.

> might want to read more in the links I shared about the harmful effects of lead before "whatabouting" to other problems of electronics recycling/waste

The point is, whether a RTP superconductor does or doesn't contain lead is irrelevant to its adoption. The advantages are too large. What current directives say are, similarly, irrelevant.

Re: The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor?

#380

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much is latex used for papers outside of computer science? Medical researchers I know generally used word for their papers.

It's a red flag for a physics paper. It's a coffin for a mathematics paper.

As a physicist, it's not a red flag... It's a red klaxon blaring out an alarm.

I have only met a few physicists who don't write papers in latex. They are all 65+ and generally work with younger scientists/grad students who prepare the paper in latex for final drafts and submissions.

Post reply on HN