Live data from Hacker News

TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

tsaoutofourpants.wordpress.com

31–40 of 156 posts

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#31
post #16

Overlay a thin layer of material over the metal plate (the dark/black region in the images) that has a regular repeating pattern (think checkerboard) that shows objects suspended beyond the body's silhouette. Problem solved.

Why do you think it is black in the first place? Think physics and X-rays, not computer screen...

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#32

The term "security theater" has been tossed around a lot, but I think it's pretty clearly coming to that. Asking the mainstream media not to cover something like this is completely indefensible from a security standpoint - what, terrorists only learn about security flaws from TV?. It's pretty patently only about keeping their budget. Also, just going to throw this out there, but it is fairly possible that the email i…

I think they are betting on security through absurdity (I initially meant to spell obscurity but this makes more sense).

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you ask the journalist in question to forward you the entire e-mail as well?

He doesn't want to ruin his relationship with the source by doing so, but again, it should be a public record releasable under FOIA

How long does an FOIA request of that sort usually take? If there are multiple steps, could you give us a timeline?

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you ask the journalist in question to forward you the entire e-mail as well?

He doesn't want to ruin his relationship with the source by doing so, but again, it should be a public record releasable under FOIA

It's supposed to take a month. But, the TSA ignored my last FOIA request, so I had to sue them for it.

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#36

The term "security theater" has been tossed around a lot, but I think it's pretty clearly coming to that. Asking the mainstream media not to cover something like this is completely indefensible from a security standpoint - what, terrorists only learn about security flaws from TV?. It's pretty patently only about keeping their budget. Also, just going to throw this out there, but it is fairly possible that the email i…

Then again, this is arguably censorship theater. I thought the original post was blogspammy in the extreme, and this is more of the same.

This does not make me a cheerleader for the TSA.

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#37
The TSA probably views its own mission as largely a propaganda mission. It's just creepy when we realize that it is trying to silence public debate.

The biggest oddity to me is that it's been over 10 years and this debate hasn't actually happened in the mainstream media.

I think one aspect of most orgs that have entrenched power is that they are always very deferent toward government. NPR is a great example... there is lots of coverage of various wall street schemes, mention of greed as a problem in the private sector, etc., but the underlying message in most of the stories is that government is beyond reproach.

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#38
post #22

This is insanity. I try to avoid flying as much as possible. However, the whole controversy also seems to lack common sense. An easy "solution" to this whole problem is to ask people to go into the machine and do a 360 degree rotation before emerging on the other side. I'll call this the "Airport Dance" :-) What? It's not like we aren't made to dance already!

The current arrangement subjects you to one short burst of radiation to take a static image, and it's enough energy to have some doctors worried. Multiply that up by however many frames you want to capture, and I don't think it would be "some doctors" any more.

Besides, I've got no idea if the machines in place have microwave units that can withstand a high duty cycle like that. I wouldn't be surprised if they can't.

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#39

I hope the email is fake. Yet I would not be surprised if it wasn't. Most government employees I have met are not really that intelligent. Add that to a bit of power and little to no accountability and you have an instant recipe for disaster.

Sari Koshetz is the name of a TSA representative. Google her.

So?

Edit: Seriously, what does that prove? Someone faking an email can Google for TSA spokeswomen just as easily as someone trying to verify it.

Re: TSA Pressures Mainstream Media Not To Cover Story

#40
post #29
post #16

Overlay a thin layer of material over the metal plate (the dark/black region in the images) that has a regular repeating pattern (think checkerboard) that shows objects suspended beyond the body's silhouette. Problem solved.

The problem isn't that this one particular technique exists. The problem is that the TSA's decision making process led them to spend billions of dollars a year against the advisement of the top security experts in the world. For an organization who's sole purpose is the security of the American people, they're awfully bad at doing things that ensure the security of the American people.

A big problem with that procurement was the very close ties between former TSA director, Michael Chertoff, and the company that makes the full body scanners.
Post reply on HN