Live data from Hacker News

A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

stefanjudis.com

21–30 of 114 posts

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#21
The first thing I do when I work in an editor with a mini-map is -- turn it off. I find it mostly the most useless feature for coding, and for sites it seems to be equally useless. Why?

1. Stuff is too small to really make out where I'm going or navigating.

2. Short or long pages, both don't really benefit from the loss of screen real-estate. Or the distraction really.

3. Other tools like a proper index with descriptive headers, or the search function work so much better to navigate the page.

Where mini-maps could be awesome are large images, or maps. They tend to visual in nature, and when zoomed in you can look at the mini-map to see where you are in the whole. Which is useful.

So, cool future, but this doesn't really seem like a great implementation.

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#22
I can see the use, but this is also kind of wild. It's live-updating if you select text, it's almost literally a separate viewport into the same content.

I'm trying to figure out the use-cases and implications of this. You can do offscreen/overflow:hidden tricks to make it work with hidden elements. But... as far as I know there's still no way without a library to convert that element to an image (for privacy reasons I suspect).

I'm sorry for kind of being all over the place, but the MDN page is pretty short and I have a lot more questions. I guess I could always apply CSS filters and distortion directly to elements, does this being treated like a background open up possibilities there? It's the first time I'm hearing about this even though it's been around for a while, and I wouldn't have suspected this would be a CSS feature even on the table. How useful is this beyond just cloning viewports (assuming I'm only targeting Firefox and don't care about Chrome)?

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#23

It's impressive how well the minimap works for bigger articles, I clicked around randomly and ended up at https://www.stefanjudis.com/notes/should-responsive-images-w... and the minimap feels slightly magical since it appears instantly and updates synchronously if I do things like select text. It feels kind of disappointing that I can't interact with it to scroll around like in i.e. Sublime Text, but I imagine that's…

Weirdly enough I can't see it on this article but it's showing just fine on the OP. Maybe my extensions?

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#24
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I exclusively use firefox, have a pretty normal browsing pattern, and that almost never happens to me! Much less that once a month, maybe once every 3 months

Finding one once every few months sound about right but usually the bugs impacting Firefox users are major PITA. Some I’ve had over the past few years: * myADP had some kind of bug preventing firefox authentication that lasted months. * Elan financial redid their credit card site for fidelity visa and had a CSS bug that hid the card total balance. This lasted for about a month. * bitbucket (work required) had this bu…

Opening fastmail in Firefox crashes the whole browser. I don't know why. I stopped my subscription due to that.

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#27

What am I supposed to see here? I’m using Firefox on Linux. All I see is a normal blog article about something called a minimap, but I fail to see any such minimap. Disabling the ad blocker didn’t help. What am I missing?

Not working for me on macos.

otoh firefox has been really weird since the 115 update - rock solid before that, but now all kinds of weird graphic glitches and hangs.

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#28

The first thing I do when I work in an editor with a mini-map is -- turn it off. I find it mostly the most useless feature for coding, and for sites it seems to be equally useless. Why? 1. Stuff is too small to really make out where I'm going or navigating. 2. Short or long pages, both don't really benefit from the loss of screen real-estate. Or the distraction really. 3. Other tools like a proper index with descript…

I do the exact opposite.

I use the minimap a lot, as a much better scrollbar. I tend to work on long files and even if I am rarely looking directly at the minimap, it is in my field of view and I often subconsciously glance at it.

This kind of feature is clearly no one-size0-fits-all, but it would be a mistake to consider it is useless because you don't like it.

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#29

Every day I hit sites that literally only work in Chrome.. it’s time to fight back :)

I exclusively use firefox, have a pretty normal browsing pattern, and that almost never happens to me! Much less that once a month, maybe once every 3 months

I simply refuse to use websites if they require Chrome. I find some other way to do whatever it is I'm trying.

Re: A Firefox-only minimap (2021)

#30

What am I supposed to see here? I’m using Firefox on Linux. All I see is a normal blog article about something called a minimap, but I fail to see any such minimap. Disabling the ad blocker didn’t help. What am I missing?

There should be a picture of what you are supposed to see on the article[1]. It works on this page for me but some of the other articles do not show it. Seems weird because I'm not changing browsers in between.

[1] https://images.ctfassets.net/f20lfrunubsq/2FuQMHycwersLjIf4d...

Post reply on HN