Live data from Hacker News

FDA says aspartame is safe, disagreeing with WHO finding

cnbc.com

151–156 of 156 posts

Re: FDA says aspartame is safe, disagreeing with WHO finding

#151
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

all the bad parts of sugar are from the sugar part of it, not some magic poison added by "refining"

That is not evidence. That is assertion

In that case, they can't prove a negative. There is no reason to believe that a molecule is different depending on where it came from. If there is evidence to the contrary, that would be interesting.

Re: FDA says aspartame is safe, disagreeing with WHO finding

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, but as much as the news is going to pick up this story and blow it out of proportion, I think people should kind of know they are being played with here.

WHO can't be held responsible for headlines put out by newspapers. WHO declared aspartame possibly carcinogenic, putting it in the same class as mobile phone usage That means there is some limited evidence pointing in that direction, but that further studies are needed to confirm this. I don't think this statement is incorrect. In the end is all about the daily dosis, and the possibly increase in cancer (is it 0.005%…

Yup, and yet the thousands who will read the CNN article (ok let’s be serious, they just skim the headline) about the WHO version will “tsk tsk” at me and say “You know that stuff gives you cancer,” while ingesting dozens of supplements that haven’t even been tested for safety because they’re unregulated.

Re: FDA says aspartame is safe, disagreeing with WHO finding

#156
post #53

Diet soda and sweeteners behind them are still a scam even if they don’t “cause cancer.” They’re a scam because they still cause insulin response. Pancreas cranks out insulin after tasting the soda, and there no blood sugar to react with. My uncle drank tons of Diet Coke and got pancreatic cancer. Doesn’t mean diet soda caused his pancreatic cancer, but he definitely didn’t loose weight by drinking the stuff.

Update: hmm. I might be mistaken. There are articles that measure insulin levels after drinking the soda. These show no connection for diet soda.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5118762/ https://www.oatext.com/Blood-glucose-and-insulin-response-to...

But there are also articles that describe what’s called “anticipatory response” to food/drink. I didn’t see an article connecting diet soda in particular to insulin response, but possibly it’s the same for things that only taste sweet.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3056926/

Post reply on HN