Live data from Hacker News

Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

cnbc.com

71–80 of 187 posts

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#71
post #32

The business philosophy of "maximize shareholder value above all else" is going to eviscerate our society until there's nothing of quality left. Hollywood has always been a dirty and money-focused business, but it seems like the latest crop of execs are hellbent on entirely divorcing the creative enterprise from its human elements. Now studios are just exotic financial instruments that seek to turn "content" into sto…

> The business philosophy of "maximize shareholder value above all else" is going to eviscerate our society until there's nothing of quality left. Well no, because there are literally an entire industry (luxury goods) where the main selling point is quality, and I don't see any sign that's going to disappear anytime soon.

If you think all LVMH workers have good working conditions, or that materials are sourced ethically, I have bad news for you.

Quality doesn't prevent the search of profit maximization. Hell, luxury goods aren't even about quality. The price/quality ratio on your Vuitton Bag or your Ferrari is down in the gutter. You're buying a social status, not quality.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#72
post #34

The business philosophy of "maximize shareholder value above all else" is going to eviscerate our society until there's nothing of quality left. Hollywood has always been a dirty and money-focused business, but it seems like the latest crop of execs are hellbent on entirely divorcing the creative enterprise from its human elements. Now studios are just exotic financial instruments that seek to turn "content" into sto…

Everything measured and optimised for shallow goals goes into the gutter. As the analytics overtook decision making, the quality of everything declined sharply. IMHO, it's happening because we the humans optimize for proxy metrics which once were good as a proxy to the real thing but with the computer age they turned into shallow goals that end up destroying the real thing as the optimisation became too robust. Remov…

"As the analytics overtook decision making, the quality of everything declined sharply."

Pretty much. I'm sure Hollywood execs have always wanted to make as much money as they could, but they also (formerly) didn't want to be known as guys who only made terrible movies. Prestige, vanity, relationships, reputation...unanalyzable human factors are really important for the production of human-centric products like art and entertainment.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It probably won't be long before algorithms can mocap just from the recorded footage and then transpose those movements to arbitrary 3D models :/ That doesn't take away from the beauty of martial arts though. You can have an exact definition of all the moves you'll ever do, but still spend decades refining them. For actors though... yeah I can see why they're worried

It's already very possible with off-the-shelf OpenPose. I can only imagine that the proprietary systems are more powerful and have better performance.

Good to know. Thanks for sharing!

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#74
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The visual effects people and animators in Hollywood should absolutely be organizing for one, because their work is the soonest to be blown up with AI stuff. There's already a ton of stuff for small productivity improvements that reduce editing or grading tasks that used to take days into minutes.

There's the Animation Guild for collective bargaining, and ASIFA (which is like the Academy of cartoons). https://animationguild.org/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASIFA-Hollywood

ASIFA is not a labor union in any way and local 839 is not really a VFX union, nor does representation function like SAG or WGA do. VFX is a mess.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#75
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Jet Li famously turned down The Matrix because he was worried about what they might do with his motion capture in the future. Previous discussion of the topic right here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27852017

It probably won't be long before algorithms can mocap just from the recorded footage and then transpose those movements to arbitrary 3D models :/ That doesn't take away from the beauty of martial arts though. You can have an exact definition of all the moves you'll ever do, but still spend decades refining them. For actors though... yeah I can see why they're worried

They can do that today

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been doing that for a long time not because of the strike, but because 90% of the content is garbage, and the few shows that have found interesting they cancel after 1 season.... I think the situation with the Witcher will be the last straw with me and Netflix.. I am probably one of the few people that still have Prime because of the shipping but as they keep increasing costs to add a bunch of things I have no…

The Witcher wasn't really Netflix's fault though? I thought Cavill was lured by the Amazon deal to do Warhammer. Gotta love a company like Amazon producing shows and selling toilet paper all in one shop.

Isn't that the Japanese model? You can get your motorcycle and your baby grand piano from the same company. It looks like it works pretty well for them so maybe there's something to it.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#77
post #32

The business philosophy of "maximize shareholder value above all else" is going to eviscerate our society until there's nothing of quality left. Hollywood has always been a dirty and money-focused business, but it seems like the latest crop of execs are hellbent on entirely divorcing the creative enterprise from its human elements. Now studios are just exotic financial instruments that seek to turn "content" into sto…

> The business philosophy of "maximize shareholder value above all else" is going to eviscerate our society until there's nothing of quality left. Well no, because there are literally an entire industry (luxury goods) where the main selling point is quality, and I don't see any sign that's going to disappear anytime soon.

I’m not sure how familiar you are with luxury goods, but there are lots of YouTube channels and analyses of the quality of luxury products, and it’s not what you think it is. They’re maximizing shareholder value too, they’re just going after people narcissistic and wealthy enough to not notice that they’re buying junk that’s dressed up because the brand name means something to them.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#78
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is where the broadcasters and streamers opt for more unscripted TV and foreign dubbed content.

Consumers are savvier than ever about that stuff. People already demonstrate a strong willingness to hop on and off subscriptions for different services based on specific shows they want to watch. I can imagine a ton of people canceling their subscriptions if all the providers put out is that crap “filler content.”

One thing we all can do is to be less entertained. But I guess this would be considered extreme measure, specially in US.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#79
post #54

Given the explicit "we'll just wait for them to lose their housing" messaging from the Hollywood executives... Good on SAG-AFTRA. This can only increase the bargaining power of both groups.

> Given the explicit "we'll just wait for them to lose their housing" messaging from the Hollywood executives... Yeah, that was fuckin disgusting. Its tar and feather territory if you ask me. I'm in full support of this strike and I applaud the actors for getting in on it. Bring the studios to their knees if that's what it takes.

What's to stop the actors or writers from simply making their own content?

It made sense to me when you had terrestrial television stations with actual monopolies over broadcast rights.

But now with the internet they have many vectors to share and market their content.

So you won't be on NBC or Netflix or whatever, so what, post it on Twitter and YouTube. If they move to alternative distribution platforms and the studios don't do anything then the studios will lose their audience and thus their revenues.

Re: Actors union will join writers on strike, shutting down Hollywood

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not being the worst tactic used by companies to break strikes doesn't make it good or even OK . Nor should it lessen the condemnation faced by these companies. EDIT: To be clear, I expect a company's executive team in the 21st century to act ethically and with even the smallest bit of compassion for their coworkers. I do not expect them to act like some entitled plantation owner in the late 19th century. And if that'…

This not some dirty tactic, it is specifically how all breakdowns in employer/union negotiations go. Union withdraws their labour until their demands are met, employer doesn't agree until their demands are met. As time goes on, both lose money, both parties are betting the other party will compromise in a beneficial way before their side does. If you don't approve of this, you don't approve of unionization. Because t…

You seem to misunderstand what unionisation is. The current state of things has been reached as kind of a gentleman's agreement. If employers want to revert to life threatening solutions, unions will revert to life threatening solutions too. Sequestration, destruction, tarring, and other fun things.

But then again, defenestration of a bunch of execs might just be the exact thing the world needs to put some fear back into these ghouls again.

Post reply on HN