Live data from Hacker News

NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

blog.google

61–70 of 148 posts

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#61

This is amazing! I can't wait to post about this on Google Wave, Google Currents, Orkut, Jaiku, Google Friend Connect, and Google+, read all about it on Google Reader and Google FastFlip, chat about it with friends on Buzz, Duo, Google Talk, Hangouts, and also blog on my website made with Google Page Creator or Web Hosting on Google Drive or Google Sites. It's just so reassuring to know I can depend on the Google eco…

[deleted]

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#64
post #12
post #9

This seems like a good alternative to all the "ask a PDF a question" GPT wrappers that have sprung up.

Having implemented my own "ask a PDF a question" GPT wrapper, there's a lot of design decisions / complexity that can make it better/worse and I'm not sure how much a "one-size fits all" google approach will work for google. Convenient that it plugs in directly to your gdrive though.

Google will be leveraging the millions of people using google docs that will never go out of their way to use an ask a PDF tool. I know I haven’t bothered even though I am technically skilled enough to do so.

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#65
post #47

Do any of the "chat with your documents" type applications have Google Drive integration? Because it's unlikely that Google will take away the API for Drive. But an experimental project like this could easily go up in a puff of red mist.

Danswer, MIT licenses. Discussed a few days back in HN

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36667374

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#66

Doesn’t this take away the important part of doing notes? The writing? A good AI should foster a discussion with the student, not write notes.

I mean I would take AI autocomplete in the style of copilot. That feels conversational enough already, it would be even better if it’s optimised for prose instead of code. The MS word autocomplete is getting pretty good and I would love more of it personally.

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#68

This is amazing! I can't wait to post about this on Google Wave, Google Currents, Orkut, Jaiku, Google Friend Connect, and Google+, read all about it on Google Reader and Google FastFlip, chat about it with friends on Buzz, Duo, Google Talk, Hangouts, and also blog on my website made with Google Page Creator or Web Hosting on Google Drive or Google Sites. It's just so reassuring to know I can depend on the Google eco…

I get it. Google has a lot of killed/closed products. But that’s kind of their MO. They try a lot of things. Sometimes they work (Gmail was an experiment at one point), but they often don’t.

Making fun of their killed products is a favorite HN past time, but what would you have them do? Just sit back and not try to make new things? Or keep zombie projects alive, but unmaintained just because a few of us find it really helpful?

Those are the projects I find the saddest. The ones that would have been a good product for a smaller company (or was a smaller company that was acquired), but that isn’t profitable enough at “Google scale” to keep throwing money at.

I get it. Google kills a lot of products that early adopters like. Google Reader was painful to lose at the time. But how many RSS feeds do you now follow?

Let’s just evaluate this new project on its own merits. Do you find it helpful or not — without thinking too much about Googles track record. If this way of using AI is helpful (and I’m very hopeful), then either Google will keep it, or this is the POC a small startup will use to keep something like this around. If it fails, then at least we’ll all have learned something.

Re: NotebookLM: An AI Notebook

#69
Google Docs has been going strong for almost 2 decades, longer than the iPhone. NotebookLM is another way to read your Google Docs, with LLM assistance. If NotebookLM gets killed off, you still have your Google Docs and can read them with your eyeballs or some other LLM.

HN loves to shit on Google for their loose trail-and-error approach to product releases, but Google Docs is evidently not one of those loose products.

Post reply on HN