Live data from Hacker News

I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

internettalk.substack.com

141–150 of 256 posts

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#141
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m not commenting on your theory, but what I love about HN is that, for the most part, people comment purely to talk about a topic. There’s very little self promotion. It’s very nice.

[flagged]

The thing I absolutely love the most about HN is that political discourse is generally discouraged. I genuinely believe people who like talking about politics are miserable humans.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#142

Slight twist on dead internet theory. It's not that the internet is full of bots, it's that the internet is full of self promotion. Finding real people to have real conversations is more difficult because so many want your engagement/attention for their "brand". Similar to the Black Mirror episode about social credit score.

At the risk of sounding mean, Threads really is the dumbest place on the Internet. It’s vapid beyond anything I’ve ever experienced.

Is it worse than LinkedIn?

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#143

Slight twist on dead internet theory. It's not that the internet is full of bots, it's that the internet is full of self promotion. Finding real people to have real conversations is more difficult because so many want your engagement/attention for their "brand". Similar to the Black Mirror episode about social credit score.

> Finding real people to have real conversations is more difficult because so many want your engagement/attention for their "brand". Humanity breaks into three groups: originators, amplifiers, mimics. Probably 95-97% of humanity or more are mimics. They will never produce much of anything original, that includes writing long-form blog posts or original media content (eg YouTube). They have little to no interest. This…

Hm, I doubt that not actively contributing on a forum makes you a "mimic". Perhaps your wording is a bit too strong?

I agree with you that these people may lack the energy or creativity, but there could be dozens of other valid reasons for not contributing. For one, I think most people who ignore social media are quite wise. A lot of time is lost here on more important matters.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#144
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, I used threads for a few minutes and quickly discovered that’s it’s just not a product that caters to me… yet. Right now I think it’s probably only great if you’re really into the e-celeb scene. But this is Meta/IG we’re talking about, I’m sure they’ll get their near-freaky level of algorithmic content targeting precision in there soon enough and my feed will become full of stuff I care about. I’ll check back i…

> But this is Meta/IG we’re talking about, I’m sure they’ll get their near-freaky level of algorithmic content targeting precision in there soon enough I keep hearing this. "Oh! The Algorithm gets me so well! It's so freaky!" about TikTok, IG, everything really... But let me tell you how my IG feed goes: I get 3 posts at the top, posted by my friends. I like all of them – even if I didn't like it. I'm just pleading t…

I’ve stopped using the algorithm on IG. Instead I use the “Following” feed (tap the Instagram logo in the top left on the home pane) which is a reverse chronological feed of only the people I follow.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I saw some posts urging people to “get in on the beginning” in order to take advantage of the primitive ranking and go viral. Everyone wants a chance at that. Just like the promise of pump and dump crypto’s or the still private startups that told me “you just don’t understand how equity works, we are about to IPO soon, take our lowball offer”

It’s 2023, and people are still grasping for Internet Points?

[deleted]

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#146

Slight twist on dead internet theory. It's not that the internet is full of bots, it's that the internet is full of self promotion. Finding real people to have real conversations is more difficult because so many want your engagement/attention for their "brand". Similar to the Black Mirror episode about social credit score.

[dead]

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#147

Sounds just like Twitter. Just more garbage. The only thing I ever found useful on Twitter was notifications from government agencies. Mostly recently, changes in ferry schedules in NC. I feel like I need a “Twitter for governments and public services”. Verified accounts and none of the influencer garbage.

Threads may end up being the best place for exactly that. Uncontroversial content on a stable platform.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#148
post #141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

The thing I absolutely love the most about HN is that political discourse is generally discouraged. I genuinely believe people who like talking about politics are miserable humans.

> I genuinely believe people who like talking about politics are miserable humans.

I dunno, maybe they're just in a place where talking and acting politically is important and useful to them? Perhaps that does make them miserable, if I was a white and rich guy in the US I probably wouldn't have to ever talk about politics.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#149

Slight twist on dead internet theory. It's not that the internet is full of bots, it's that the internet is full of self promotion. Finding real people to have real conversations is more difficult because so many want your engagement/attention for their "brand". Similar to the Black Mirror episode about social credit score.

The internet is full of monopolies.

They stifle innovation. They lock up funding. They buy anything that looks remotely competitive then stick it inside their walled garden. They demand 30% of your revenue for simply being middlemen.

Of course, in this environment, all that's left for people is to constantly self aggrandize in the hopes that one of these monopolies will hire them and give them a decent salary.

Re: I am drowning in mutes: The current Threads experience

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the phrasing is what’s objectionable here. Sure most users are lurkers, but does that mean they’ll never produce anything original? Give me a break. This is just a roundabout way of calling other people “NPCs”

I disagree with their term “mimic”, as if anything mimics would be their own social class (see for instance clickbait/“prank” channels on YT, content creators on TikTok), but the underlying principle is correct. He is not stating they will never produce anything original ever, that’s simply absurd. However he is saying consistent content creation is few and far between compared to the masses who lurk. And that it’s u…

All three terms are a bit odd to me, but I think the theory is valid. In the advertising and fashion worlds don't these map to "trendsetters", "influencers", and "followers"?

Fashion companies look for trendsetters to see what may be coming next, and pay influencers to advertise to everyone else (followers).

Post reply on HN