Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#1

Post by mellow » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:03 PM UTC

You know, it is amazing how fast we change.

Only 7 years ago I was reading about about the Singularity and thinking 'Yeah, maybe in twenty-fifty - things don't change that quickly!' Now, I'm not so sure. I have posted some questions/comments to this site in the last few days which were intentionally naive - and would have be recognised as such by the smarter individuals here. Would have been recognised as such, by most, 2 years ago. Today, I was quite shocked at some of the replies and horrified that one of my Submissions was censored! Things do change more quickly than you can ever imagine!

Ok, today might be a bad day for the censor and the posters, but come on guys... I ask about aliens and the next President of the USA and I get crappy comments that don't even address the original question? Are you a cult or are you shipping cargo? I plan to do the latter.

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#2

Post by [deleted] » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:13 PM UTC

[deleted]

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#3

Post by ram1024 » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:21 PM UTC

isn't the first rule of HN: "No Drama" ?

you'd certainly get a better response about aliens if you posted it on a niche site dedicated to discussing that topic.

i don't go to KFC and order whoppers

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#4

Post by Raphael » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:22 PM UTC

If you find yourself clashing with the majority on topics and tone, then your best bet would be to find or make a different community, one more palatable to your tastes.

People don't always agree with me either, but I like that because it encourages me to write better and think more analytically. Possibly the least popular thing to do is complain.

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#5

Post by mellow » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:33 PM UTC

Raphael wrote: post #4

If you find yourself clashing with the majority on topics and tone, then your best bet would be to find or make a different community, one more palatable to your tastes. People don't always agree with me either, but I like that because it encourages me to write better and think more analytically. Possibly the least popular thing to do is complain.

Really? So you have blinkers on when it comes to new ideas? Like, tell Edison to go somewhere else - somewhere they go to bed early and get up early 'cos that is what the sun does?

Actually, I like the 'tone' aspect of your argument. Can I steal it?

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#6

Post by mellow » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:35 PM UTC

ram1024 wrote: post #3

isn't the first rule of HN: "No Drama" ? you'd certainly get a better response about aliens if you posted it on a niche site dedicated to discussing that topic. i don't go to KFC and order whoppers

The first rule for smart people is intellectual honesty. The medium is not relevant.

What the feck has KFC got to do with it?

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#7

Post by bloch » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:38 PM UTC

Is it time for you to stop trolling?

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#8

Post by robertgaal » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:41 PM UTC

Fuck no. You're overreacting. Cut the drama and go find a forum to hang out on.

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#9

Post by mstefff » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:41 PM UTC

mellow wrote: post #6

ram1024 wrote: post #3

isn't the first rule of HN: "No Drama" ? you'd certainly get a better response about aliens if you posted it on a niche site dedicated to discussing that topic. i don't go to KFC and order whoppers

The first rule for smart people is intellectual honesty. The medium is not relevant. What the feck has KFC got to do with it?

How'd you not understand that reference? It's Hacker News. Meaning hacker-related news. Meaning don't bring other nonsense to this site. Why are you surprised that people only want to talk about hacker-related news?

Re: Ask YC: Is it time to shut down this site?

#10

Post by mstefff » Sun, Nov 16, 2008, 8:43 PM UTC

mellow wrote: post #5

Raphael wrote: post #4

If you find yourself clashing with the majority on topics and tone, then your best bet would be to find or make a different community, one more palatable to your tastes. People don't always agree with me either, but I like that because it encourages me to write better and think more analytically. Possibly the least popular thing to do is complain.

Really? So you have blinkers on when it comes to new ideas? Like, tell Edison to go somewhere else - somewhere they go to bed early and get up early 'cos that is what the sun does? Actually, I like the 'tone' aspect of your argument. Can I steal it?

What...?