Live data from Hacker News

GPT-4 API General Availability

openai.com

91–100 of 562 posts

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#92
post #89

Practical report: the OpenAI API is a bad joke. If you think you can build a production app against it, think again. I've been trying to use it for the past 6 weeks or so. If you use tiny prompts, you'll generally be fine (that's why you always get people commenting that it works for them), but just try to get closer to the limits, especially with GPT-4. The API will make you wait up to 10 minutes, and then time out.…

I’m only using them as a stop-gap / for prototyping with the intent to move to a locally hosted fine-tuned (and ideally 7B parameter) model further down the road.

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#93

It's funny how OpenAI just shattered Google's PR stunts. Google wanted everyone to believe they are leading in AI by winning some children's games. Everyone thought that was the peak of AI. Enter OpenAI and Micorsoft. Microsoft and OpenAI have showed the humanity what true AI looks like. Like most people on HN I cannot wait to see the end of Google, the end of evil.

Is Microsoft less evil than Google?

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#94
The difference between 4 and 3.5 is really big for creative use cases. I am running an app with significant traffic and the retention of users on GPT-4 is much higher.

Unfortunately it's still too expensive and the completion speed is not as high as GPT-3.5 but I hope both problems will improve over time.

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#95
post #57

They didn't mention gpt-4-32k. Does anybody know if it will be generally available in the same timeframe? There's still no news about the multi-modal gpt-4. I guess the image input is just too expensive to run or it's actually not as great as they hyped it.

> We are not currently granting access to GPT-4-32K API at this time, but it will be made available at a later date.

https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7102672-how-can-i-access...

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#96

I imagine the API quality isnt nerfed on a given day like ChatGPT can be. There was no question something happened in January with ChatGPT, weirdly would refuse to answer questions that were harmless but difficult(Give me a daily schedule of a stoic hedonist) Every once in a while, I see redditors complain of it being nerfed. Sometimes I go back to gpt3.5 and am mind boggled how much worse it is. Makes me wonder if t…

Instead of the model changing, it’s equally likely that this is a cognitive illusion. A new model is initially mind-blowing and enjoys a halo effect. Over time, this fades and we become frustrated with the limitations that were there all along.

Check out this post from a round table dialogue with Greg Brockman from OpenAI. The GPT models that were in existence / in use in early 2023 were not the performance-degraded quantized versions that are in production now: https://www.reddit.com/r/mlscaling/comments/146rgq2/chatgpt_...

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#97

Not a lot of talk of Whisper being available here. From using voice in the ChatGPT iOS app, I surmise that Whisper is very good at working out what you've actually said. But it's really annoying to have to say my whole bit before getting any feedback about what it's gonna think I said. Even if it's getting it right at an impressive rate. Given this is how OpenAI themselves use it (say your whole thing before getting…

Echoing this - saying the whole text at once in one shot is very challenging for long batches of text.

Using built-in text input showed quite good results since ChatGPT is still understanding the ask quite well

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#98

I imagine the API quality isnt nerfed on a given day like ChatGPT can be. There was no question something happened in January with ChatGPT, weirdly would refuse to answer questions that were harmless but difficult(Give me a daily schedule of a stoic hedonist) Every once in a while, I see redditors complain of it being nerfed. Sometimes I go back to gpt3.5 and am mind boggled how much worse it is. Makes me wonder if t…

Instead of the model changing, it’s equally likely that this is a cognitive illusion. A new model is initially mind-blowing and enjoys a halo effect. Over time, this fades and we become frustrated with the limitations that were there all along.

No it's definitely changed a lot. The speedups have been massive (GPT 4 runs faster now than 3.5-turbo did at launch) and they can't be explained with just them rolling out H100s since that's just a 2x inference boost. Some unknown in-house optimization method aside, they've probably quantized the models down to a few bits of precision which increases perplexity quite a bit. They've also continued to RHLF tune to make them more in-line with their guidelines and that process has been shown to decrease overall performance before GPT 4 even launched.

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#99

I imagine the API quality isnt nerfed on a given day like ChatGPT can be. There was no question something happened in January with ChatGPT, weirdly would refuse to answer questions that were harmless but difficult(Give me a daily schedule of a stoic hedonist) Every once in a while, I see redditors complain of it being nerfed. Sometimes I go back to gpt3.5 and am mind boggled how much worse it is. Makes me wonder if t…

I keep reading “GPT4 got nerfed” but I have been using from day 1, and while it definitely gives bad answers, I cannot say that it was nerfed for sure. Is there any actual evidences other than some user subjective experiences?

See my comment elsewhere on this post. Greg Brockman, head of strategic initiatives at OpenAI, was talking at a round table discussion in Korea a few weeks ago about how they had to start using the quantized (smaller, cheaper) model earlier in 2023. I noticed a switch in March 2023, with GPT-4 performance being severely degraded after that for both English-language tasks as well as code-related tasks (reading and writing).

Re: GPT-4 API General Availability

#100
post #89

Practical report: the OpenAI API is a bad joke. If you think you can build a production app against it, think again. I've been trying to use it for the past 6 weeks or so. If you use tiny prompts, you'll generally be fine (that's why you always get people commenting that it works for them), but just try to get closer to the limits, especially with GPT-4. The API will make you wait up to 10 minutes, and then time out.…

if you want to use it in prod, go with Azure
Post reply on HN