Live data from Hacker News

Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

github.com

171–180 of 220 posts

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#171

My major problem with Joplin is the lack of a native client for Apple Silicon, otherwise it's great. I know you can run it with Rosetta but it's performance and load time is terrible.

Recently started using Joplin. I find myself reformatting everything I paste into it from the browser. I thought the long load time was just the program. Didn't realize it wasn't native. I find myself not using it because it does feel clunky and slow and just easier to take screenshots.

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#172
I've used Obsidian, Logseq, Apple Notes, and Joplin recently.

I really like Obsidian for how performant it feels for handling really long md files with outline.

But the best capturing experience is Logseq. I just record everything I do in the journal (daily) page and just tag them (tag can have hierarchy and spaces too) . I don't have to think about directory structure or which file the info should go into. Logseq sucks for handling long form md files tho, so I keep Obsidian for that.

Joplin I tried to use it until it started having sync conflicts, and the sync corruption error cannot be dismissed. Google solutions suggests exporting JEX and delete everything and re-import. I give up after that.

Apple Notes is really nice too but lack coding highlight.

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#173
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Just give me an app that can handle nicely markdown files You know what does that well? The filesystem. I've tested pretty much all note-taking software out there. What ended up working for me is a bunch of markdown files inside folders, synced using Github. I have search, formatting and preview thanks to VSCode, and I can access my notes on any machine that syncs with Github.

If you want to leave all your notes unencrypted on github, then sure that’s an option.

You can use something like git-crypt[0] to e2e encrypt it.

[0]: https://github.com/AGWA/git-crypt

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#175
post #51

Big no-no to Joplin for me is that it is using some custom data format (sqlite I think). Why bother? Just give me an app that can handle nicely markdown files, syncing I can do myself e.g. (Synology, rsync) or use some file syncing service (Dropbox, OneDrive, whatever). Zettlr does the trick for me without interfering with what I write.

I wrote my own note-keeping system[0] and very much wanted all of the notes to just be markdown files on the disk. It turns out that there are trade-offs to this. If you want plaintext markdown files on disk AND want fancy features like file versioning, a search index, tags, etc then you need to store all of that metadata somewhere and you're down writing a half-assed implementation of a DBMS.

Now, you can certainly bite the bullet and full-ass the implementation like Dokuwiki did, but that is really quite a lot of work and effort against simply `import sqlite` and writing a couple of tutorial-level queries. And it turns out that exporting all of your documents to plaintext, if you should so choose, is a one-line command away.

[0]: https://github.com/cu/silicon

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#176
I use Joplin and it... it basically works! Bit ugly at times but I really enjoy having a thing that works on my computers and my phone. Sometimes I end up in Drafts instead on iOS because of how Drafts is really "just open and go", but even then I'll copy-paste it later.

Joplin is great at being a place to put a lot of ... simple rich text documents in a random manner, and have access to them. Wordpad with sync, and it does its job.

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#178
Like that Joplin is open source and love the extensibility (plugins, API): In my workflow, I have it set up to store my transcribed speech notes and todos (with accurate offline speech recognition): https://github.com/QuantiusBenignus/NoteWhispers

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#179
I've used Joplin for a few years, had a few hundred notes on it and even sponsored it on GitHub. Then I've changed my smartphone which also brought with it an updated version of Android. The new Android version had some changes regarding how an app can manage a filesystem, which ultimately broke Joplin. I've waited a few weeks for an update (couldn't read my notes on a phone then) and even when it finally arrived, the process of synchronization was so slow and buggy I couldn't do it. That (together with other sync bugs I've been reporting earlier) was the reason I've lost patience and switched to Obsidian. Either way, I'm thankful for developers for those few years, that was a really great tool

Re: Joplin – An open-source note taking and to-do application with synchronisation

#180

I am pretty happy with Obsidian.

Same here. I only use note taking apps on my Mac, so syncing isn’t something I am interested in. For me the interface of Obsidian is really top notch. Typing headers and code block quotes doesn’t feel like it gets in your way. My only complaint is that embedded images are saved at the root level by default. Would be nice if I could hide those or move them to an /Images folder,

> embedded images are saved at the root level by default.

I'm not sure if I understand your complaint, which is something that can easily be changed.

Open Settings (cmd-,) > Files & Links, and look for Attachment folder path and change to whatever path you like.

Post reply on HN