Live data from Hacker News

Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

techcrunch.com

91–100 of 371 posts

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#91

Meta will nuke your Instagram account for basically anything, including for no reason at all. I have like 50 followers, 10 photos, and check my IG once every week or two - haven't posted anything in months. Meta has banned me twice for unspecified policy violations (both times I had to send them a selfie and got reinstated, and there was no way to ask a human what these policies were). I suspect they'll ban/unban me…

I had the same experience. I barely use it but somewhat active mostly follow friends. Post a picture of food mainly. And one day banned/blocked for no reason other than some vague violation. Stupid selfie to unlock.

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#92
post #4

Glad I made a separate IG account just for Threads

You're still giving users and money to Meta, which is probably gonna try use threads to do an EEE (embrace, extend, extinguish) on the Fediverse (Group of server software like Mastodon and Lemmy which are able to talk between each other, mastodon is probably the better twitter alternative, just try not to join the biggest instances and join a smaller one, experience is better)

True, I'm not sure if I'll stick with it, I just wanted to see what it was like. I used one of the apple hide-my-emails just in case I didn't want anything to do anything with it. From what I can see, threads doesn't use hashtags, which is a little confusing.

I did give mastodon a go, but I found it confusing, when I make account is that for that specific instance? If I choose one instance, can I see things from a different instance?

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see it Meta will delete Threads profile only if you nuke your Instagram account and Meta will nuke your Instagram account if you delete Threads profile mean exactly the same. In fact they are logically the same. It's like A iff B, means the same as B iff A.

The distinction is around intent. The parent's phrasing makes it seem as if its done for technical reasons (e.g. your threads profile and Instagram profile are actually the same thing) while the headline makes it seem like a business choice.

Obviously if there was a business choice that you should be able to do this the supposed technical obstacles could be worked around.

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#94
post #68

I guess I'm safe since I live in a literal hell for Meta (GDPR-compliant country).

Arguably, Mastodon is also problematic from a GDPR perspective as ActivityPub doesn't offer a way to control data once it has left the instance (which is the entire point of federation). But something tells me Meta didn't have to hold off on publishing Threads in the EU because it uses ActivityPub. And this account merging may indeed also be in violation.

> ActivityPub doesn't offer a way to control data once it has left the instance

Nothing offers a way to control data once you post it publicly though? You could host a public mastodon with federation off and the amount of data exposed is not really going to be different than if you federate.

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#96

Meta will nuke your Instagram account for basically anything, including for no reason at all. I have like 50 followers, 10 photos, and check my IG once every week or two - haven't posted anything in months. Meta has banned me twice for unspecified policy violations (both times I had to send them a selfie and got reinstated, and there was no way to ask a human what these policies were). I suspect they'll ban/unban me…

> Meta will nuke your Instagram account for basically anything Opened the app last week and had to click through an accept gate warning me if I keep using "Scraping tools" I'll lose my account. The only "scraping" I've been doing is copying the direct image links and posting them to slack and my bookmarking service a few times a month. Insane to me that they're red in the face threatening me to lose my account over h…

Your bookmarking service isn't like Raindrop.io or anything? Because that one might be seen as a "scraper".

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#97
Since FB this spring deleted my account since 16 years for no reason (that they would say) I have to my surprise experienced a kind of freedom, a calm serenity. After the initial feeling of being insulted and shut out from my circle of friends and family through no fault of mine I have gradually come to realize a few things:

1. there are other, better ways to stay in contact with with people I care about than through group messages and posts (which is actually an insidious sort of indirect messaging when you think about it).

2. as users of these mega-services we are largely like puppets on a string, victims of the latest fads among governments and advertisers.

3. Meta is, and always was, an unethical service that profits off the wide dissemination of our most private information. And profiting off pure scams, for example those that target poor and naive people with promises of untold riches through crypto schemes as testified by various celebrities (that have had their pictures stolen). [0]

We are nearing the point where we can, nay should, en masse desert these manipulative megaservices like Meta, Twitter, Youtube et al. They represented a certain phase in the history of internet, and as all things, their hegemonies must come to an end. We can for example willfully trigger the algorithms that shut our accounts down, as it is just about the only statement we are left with.

For the sake of our own serene peace of mind if nothing else.

[0] https://www.smh.com.au/technology/facebook-pulls-out-all-sto...

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#98
post #66

Completely tangential to the article itself, TechCrunch's privacy controls are also extremely user hostile. First it prompts you with the usual consent banner but of course doesn't provide a button to refuse all unless you click through to a second screen (this is in violation of the GDPR and ePrivacy guidelines btw, the "reject all" button needs to be front and center and must be given as much weight as an "accept a…

> I'm not pointing out that these are in violation because I think US companies should be beholden to EU law

US companies doing business in the EU should be and are beholden to the EU law.

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They want your selfies for facial recognition in order to track you better across the web and possibly resell that information to third parties. Also a great dataset for "AI" training, so your face can appear in modified form in laundered pictures.

I think they want selfies to enforce a one-account-per-person policy, to limit scraping. They already enforce phone verification, but there's plenty of ways around that (e.g. services that redirect verification SMS from hacked phones, or just buy phone-verified accounts from someone else). Facial recognition raises the bar and gives them extra confidence that two accounts are unrelated even if they have similar IPs/a…

Guessing that'd really suck for anyone who seems to be a lookalike for someone else. :/

Re: Threads profile can only be deleted by deleting Instagram account, Meta says

#100

Meta will nuke your Instagram account for basically anything, including for no reason at all. I have like 50 followers, 10 photos, and check my IG once every week or two - haven't posted anything in months. Meta has banned me twice for unspecified policy violations (both times I had to send them a selfie and got reinstated, and there was no way to ask a human what these policies were). I suspect they'll ban/unban me…

> Meta will nuke your Instagram account for basically anything Opened the app last week and had to click through an accept gate warning me if I keep using "Scraping tools" I'll lose my account. The only "scraping" I've been doing is copying the direct image links and posting them to slack and my bookmarking service a few times a month. Insane to me that they're red in the face threatening me to lose my account over h…

> if I keep using "Scraping tools" I'll lose my account.

But you are using scraping tools? Why the quotes?

Or maybe I misunderstood and you are manually copying?

Post reply on HN