Live data from Hacker News

Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

threads.net

61–70 of 204 posts

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#61
I didn't have any expectations and still left unimpressed.

All of the dark patterns are already there. No timeline control, no web UI, everything is aimed at data harvesting and it brings absolutely zero new innovation.

It's kinda sad that we can't make a better Twitter. Is that really it?

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#62
post #10

Seems like it might be starting to fall over, trying to load https://www.threads.net/@zuck times out.

Surely this is due to Zuckerberg’s poor leadership and inevitable upcoming demise. I say this sarcastically because that was the narrative whenever Twitter has had load issues.

As if performance issues at launch time were comparable to a 17-year old service that started having issues after his new CEO decided to fire 80% of the staff…

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#63
post #50

Has anyone tried using it in browser? Does it work well or they force app download onto you like they do with Instagram? I think Meta felt the pressure, seeing people might move to Mastodon (happy user from today) and wanted their piece of cake

Browser only allows to view posts and preview user profiles (shows first 10 posts and replies and basic user info). It's bad.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#64
post #58

I'm not going to download this because there's no web application. It's clear that they intentionally did not release a web application in order to maximize app installs and thus maximum control over their users (eg. scrape your contacts, push notifications, and most importantly to show you ads). In 2023 nobody wants to install yet another app, so this is a clever strategy to optimize for app installs. Not going to w…

Deny access to contacts and push notifications, use DNS based ad blocker should take care of those problems. Are people actually typing thought provoking, in-depth analysis into Twitter?

Twitter is full of interesting niche people talking about their favorite subjects. For example, there is no better way to follow the war in Ukraine.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#65
post #10

Seems like it might be starting to fall over, trying to load https://www.threads.net/@zuck times out.

Surely this is due to Zuckerberg’s poor leadership and inevitable upcoming demise. I say this sarcastically because that was the narrative whenever Twitter has had load issues.

That's a valid comparison iff you ignore everything else Musk did during and after the Twitter takeover.

Not saying people saying that where correct but it wasn't just people randomly blaming the CEO for no reason.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#66
post #58

I'm not going to download this because there's no web application. It's clear that they intentionally did not release a web application in order to maximize app installs and thus maximum control over their users (eg. scrape your contacts, push notifications, and most importantly to show you ads). In 2023 nobody wants to install yet another app, so this is a clever strategy to optimize for app installs. Not going to w…

Deny access to contacts and push notifications, use DNS based ad blocker should take care of those problems. Are people actually typing thought provoking, in-depth analysis into Twitter?

The moment you want to upload a simple screenshot, they will demand access to all your files. That's how today's OS security works.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#67
post #59

To put the numbers into perspective, 0.2% of Meta's users signed up for Threads. Meta has 3.59 billion active users: https://www.investing.com/academy/statistics/facebook-meta-f...

user =/= user account. One user can have multiple accounts.

True, theoretically it might have been one user creating 10M accounts.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#68

I'm not going to download this because there's no web application. It's clear that they intentionally did not release a web application in order to maximize app installs and thus maximum control over their users (eg. scrape your contacts, push notifications, and most importantly to show you ads). In 2023 nobody wants to install yet another app, so this is a clever strategy to optimize for app installs. Not going to w…

It doesn’t ask for contacts. It pulls everything from Instagram

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#69
post #28

I am unlikely to join. So, I ask from a distance: Have meta defined any public interest oversight What are they doing about hate speech, CSA and crime Do they have a penalty box or exclusions policy for politicians and political hacks and what appellate process exists Do they recognise the force of national laws in any specific jurisdictions beyond the USA How does meta intend dealing with Iran and china

I suspect they will reuse moderation fromFB and Insta on Threads so more of what they have been doing. They are a known quantity at this point.

It's pretty much impossible for them to be WORSE than Musk, although I am sure this is a perverse challenge in some sense.

Re: Threads has 10M sign ups in seven hours

#70
post #9

Given that Threads requires an app, and the app requires obscene permissions (health, etc) ... its hard not to think that Meta can't escape their set ways and this app is doomed to fail. The app serves Meta more than it does the public.

Where does Threads require access to health? I installed it on iPhone and it never mentioned anything about that. That is not required at all.
Post reply on HN