Live data from Hacker News

So where are we all supposed to go now?

theverge.com

41–50 of 107 posts

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#41
post #9

I've been enjoying Metafilter again after many years, and also Tildes. There are well established forums for my interests that were always bigger than they were on reddit. I have some Tildes invites if anyone wants them.

If you have any extras I would love one! - tildesinvite.yx13z@simplelogin.com

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#42

The article is supposed to be about the "downfall of social networks" but somehow manages to ignore the fact that Facebook, Instagram and Tik Tok are all still thriving with no end in sight. It's basically trying to say that because Reddit is struggling with profitability and Twitter is struggling with being bought by a petty jackass, social networks are in precipitous decline? But I barely think of Reddit or Twitter…

Facebook instagram and tiktok, as you say, do not have the same searchable level of useful information in super niche subjects, which turns out to be the crucial difference afaic, the rest is noise.

While you are right, I believe searchability is not a criterion for earning to be be called a "social network".

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#43
This article was a culture shock. Did people actually used to believe places like Reddit or Twitter were "healthy good places" to spend your time? I thought we were all on the same page for once, in recognizing that while social networks have some benefits for the most part they are deeply unhealthy places due to how every one of them is built around ad views or subscriptions.

This is partially why I don't really care about the downfall of any of these platforms, they were always replaceable and never all that beneficial. Rather than tightly weave my identity to a platform, I'll just do what I've been doing which is browsing different platforms and posting what I want to them. More should adopt this viewpoint, so the next time a platform collapses on itself as they usually do they don't feel so... lost.

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#45
post #9

I've been enjoying Metafilter again after many years, and also Tildes. There are well established forums for my interests that were always bigger than they were on reddit. I have some Tildes invites if anyone wants them.

I'd appreciate an invite if you have any left, my email is on my HN profile.

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#47

I still enjoy twitter, I find its death greatly exaggerated.

I could say the same about reddit except for the "enjoy" part. I imagine that in a while people will give up on finding alternatives and go back to reddit. Unless reddit keeps doing more stupid stuff it's not going away anytime soon.

This is the story of Reddit for years.

The best case trajectory for Reddit is Facebook's: a highly populated corporate cesspool of low quality leftovers.

But that really is the best case, as Reddit doesn't have the "my family and my boss are on Facebook, so I have to be there" effect that Facebook has. It really does rely on some threshold of quality posts.

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#48

The article is supposed to be about the "downfall of social networks" but somehow manages to ignore the fact that Facebook, Instagram and Tik Tok are all still thriving with no end in sight. It's basically trying to say that because Reddit is struggling with profitability and Twitter is struggling with being bought by a petty jackass, social networks are in precipitous decline? But I barely think of Reddit or Twitter…

I don't see Facebook (the core, original product) thriving. At least when it comes to actual engagement, I haven't seen any in years. None of my hundreds of "friends" posts anything anymore and we've been there since the Stanford days.

Re: So where are we all supposed to go now?

#49
The lesson I'm taking from this is that companies are good at building a public commons, but absolutely terrible stewards of it over the long run.

It sort of makes sense, if a local government, or a university wants to build a physical commons, they hire out to companies to design, build, etc. the space, but then ownership transfers over to the organizer of interest such as the government who then manage it in perpetuity.

Post reply on HN