Live data from Hacker News

Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

youtube.com

151–160 of 235 posts

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#151
post #124
post #6

Time to invest the comparable amount of money in FOSS alternatives? FreeCAD, LibreCAD, BRL-CAD, and so on.

There is also a new competitor written in Lazarus/FPC - ZCAD[1]. Looks barebones for now, but nevertheless interesting. [1] https://github.com/zamtmn/zcad

That's unfortunately closely named to zwcad/zw3d, which is a commercial product but extremely excellent.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#152

Just a reminder that Autodesk is the oracle/adobe of the CAD world, and this is just the way they always operated.

I just got into 3d printing as a hobby a few months ago and this has been my take away from their offerings as well. I use TinkerCad for most things; I'd like to get into Fusion 360, but I'd be a little afraid of learning a bunch about that software only to have more and more of it become out of reach behind licenses that don't make a lot of sense to buy as a hobbyist. That said, the products look great and seem to have everything a creator might want, so it definitely makes sense for pro shops to license and use.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel same about salaries. Paying monthly salary is a scam. Can I buy your time for life for a 1 time payment? But seriously, calling subscription a "scam" is very delusional. It seems like you have not released a product/saas. I support your effort in supporting and contributing to opensource though.

I feel as you do, except about all durable goods. It's absurdly unfair that I get to buy a door, a handgun, wire shelving, plumbing fixtures, etc, etc, for a 1 time payment. It's wild to see all this churn in the markets as players bloom, ship product, and die within the year. It's so sad that they're evergreen (never before having released a product) and are leaving money on the table, dooming themselves to failure.…

it says a lot about the state of society when I actually cannot tell if you're being sarcastic or not. I think it's sarcasm, I'm almost convinced it is, but at the same time it's an argument that I'd expect Big Tech companies to make.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Not that I disagree with you entirely, but please, Russia is killing and disfiguring men, women and children with rocket artillery, kidnapping kids, tearing families and human lives to pieces. The impact on Ukraine, now AND in the long run, is an will be enormous and absolutely incomparable to corporations screwing people up with subscriptions.

And it’s unbelievably tone deaf and ridiculously offensive to those who actually suffer. A reminder that a total loss of human perspective is woefully easy.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> Corporations are doing that to us, but way more subtly, but with no less of an impact in the long run Corporations generally don't send a missile into a pizza shop to kill two 15 year old twins, or send conscripts into battle and shoot at them if they retreat.

Honestly, Nestle has done worse. Like promoting detrimental baby formula to women in poor countries leading to poisoning and malnutrition of infants. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Nestl%C3%A9_boycott

I'm honestly convinced the only reason a lot of companies don't torpedo teenagers is because they can't.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where in Eastern Europe? Pretty sure in Romania police have better things to do than raid you for using pirated software at work.

There is nowhere in the world that police don’t have better things to do than to raid a shop using pirated software.

The more likely scenario, at least in the US, is that if your business is already using some legit licensed software from the same publisher, the publisher invokes a contractual right to audit licenses at your business. They find a bunch of unlicensed copies, and send you a huge bill. No police, just a civil matter, but potentially very expensive for the business.

When I still did systems engineering work (2001-2011), I personally saw Microsoft conduct a license audit. No one in the organization was using pirated software, but we still got a big bill because the reseller we bought licenses from misrepresented what some of those licenses covered. In that case, MS was willing to chalk it up to an honest mistake as long as we uninstalled the software from the systems that the licenses didn't cover. I doubt they'd have been willing to do that if we'd been running actual cracked versions of their products.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#157
post #152

Just a reminder that Autodesk is the oracle/adobe of the CAD world, and this is just the way they always operated.

I just got into 3d printing as a hobby a few months ago and this has been my take away from their offerings as well. I use TinkerCad for most things; I'd like to get into Fusion 360, but I'd be a little afraid of learning a bunch about that software only to have more and more of it become out of reach behind licenses that don't make a lot of sense to buy as a hobbyist. That said, the products look great and seem to h…

The F360 businesses strategy is to sell subscriptions to companies. The free and cheap tiers are a lure for their target market which they're gradually reeling in. Don't get personally invested in it for fun unless you can sustain the financial investment.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I try to use freeCAD whenever possible. I'm not a professional level, and assemblies are a bit scary, but its overall a nice tool. Just the other day I cloned one of these[1] in freecad using the image importing and scaling, quickly made a trace, added a pad and some chamfers, and had it on the 3d printer in about 25 minutes. I'd love if FreeCAD got a benefactor like you mention. [1] https://www.amazon.com/TILISMA-Bo…

The beauty of 3D printing, and the community is that you could have saved yourself some time and downloaded one of the many, many versions of this available online already. I want to love FreeCAD, but it is hard to work with for complex designs compared to other tools; topological naming has been an absolute nightmare, but I persevere, it's improving slowly. At least now I'm less likely to have to throw away hours/da…

> you could have saved yourself some time and downloaded one of the many, many versions of this available online already.

I enjoy the act of technical drawing and 3d design. Downloading pre-existing models doesn't have the same "I did that" feeling. Especially after a long day at the coding mines, doing some shape manipulation is like brain yoga.

The biggest reason why I love freeCAD is how it's just there. All other cad software has long user agreements, log-ins, subscription tiers. The fact I can just install it and open and get to work somewhat makes up for the odd workflow. I learned AutoDesk Inventor when I was practically a child so I always reached for it when I could get a student license, but after that expired and the cad market started moving fast, I just went to freeCAD.

I don't want to do real work in a browser, I hate browsers. So on Linux its either freeCAD or wine+fusion360.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I try to use freeCAD whenever possible. I'm not a professional level, and assemblies are a bit scary, but its overall a nice tool. Just the other day I cloned one of these[1] in freecad using the image importing and scaling, quickly made a trace, added a pad and some chamfers, and had it on the 3d printer in about 25 minutes. I'd love if FreeCAD got a benefactor like you mention. [1] https://www.amazon.com/TILISMA-Bo…

I tried FreeCAD but all versions crash within minutes of using it, making it unusable.

Weird, I don't think I've ever had freeCAD crash on me except maybe if I was being a real jerk to it.

I typically just use the latest version from the arch repos and it's been smooth sailing.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#160
post #149

Fusion 360 was the greatest bait and switch I’ve seen in a long time. Went from free for personal use to $300/mo to make it useful at all… right after everyone built their library of parts on the free version

it's ~$500/year not $300/month. For me it's worth it.

Seimens Solid Edge is free and fantastic

https://solidedge.siemens.com/en/free-software/overview/

Post reply on HN