Live data from Hacker News

Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

youtube.com

101–110 of 235 posts

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#101
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has there ever been an example of an industry standard tool losing out to FOSS alternatives? Ever? There are reasons for that.

linux, git, ffmpeg, arguably postgres and sqlite, blender may get there someday. old school statistical/scientific software offerings like SPSS, Stata, Matlab have been mostly buried by R and Python. and when was the last time you used a proprietary compiler other than MSVC?

> and when was the last time you used a proprietary compiler other than MSVC?

Yesterday, because embedded firmware development is pain writ large

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#102
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Solidworks is good but not affordable.

Of note: they have made their user forum completely useless and it looks like they will soon adopt a cloud-based, subscription model about which their users are quite unhappy.

I honestly hope their cloud based push causes their downfall. It's different enough that I think it will open the door for millions of users to look around for other options for their CAD software. It's going to be a perfect opportunity for a cheaper (open source??) software to step in and eat their lunch.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#103
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've had an easy install and daily use with Mint.

I've had plenty of problems with Mint on my work laptop. For example: * Regularly swapped itself into a screen freeze. Possibly because it defaulted the swap partition to 1 GB. * Default boot partition was too small, so it ran out of space for new kernels. I have to manually remove kernels because the auto-remove is too slow to stay below the limit. * Hibernate doesn't work out of the box. I managed to figure out tha…

Following here from my thread.

Odd that you have partition woes, to me. That said, I have defaulted, for a long time, to not have fancy partition schemes. Where fancy is embarrassingly vague, of course; but the general idea is that extra partitions are largely solving problems from decades past. Worse, it leads to the swap and kernel space problems rather quickly. Though, swap into freezes is new to me.

Hibernate is one that I have heard a ton of troubles with. Largely with laptops. Good luck getting past it.

I am surprised you have had issues with the steam deck. That thing has been rock solid for me. Almost certainly my luck on the games I prefer.

Edit: I do want to underline my point about luck on my part. And good luck to you! I don't claim to have a panacea here. I also don't think it is some failing of anyone that some folks would stick with Windows or other.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#104
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Solidworks is good but not affordable.

Of note: they have made their user forum completely useless and it looks like they will soon adopt a cloud-based, subscription model about which their users are quite unhappy.

Please, no!

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#105

Just a reminder that Autodesk is the oracle/adobe of the CAD world, and this is just the way they always operated.

  > Autodesk is the oracle/adobe of the CAD world
So many things come to mind with that one sentence, it's mesmerizing. I don't have a lot of direct exposure to Oracle, but I remember grief with Adobe and Autodesk products dating back to the 80s.

My dad's company was light manufacturing. They used AutoCAD for various things and my dad became proficient enough that he started wanting to use it for various projects at home. They used Aldus (eventually Adobe) PageMaker to design their catalogues. Both were ridiculously expensive large applications with a pretty solid lock on their respective industries. For the kind of catalogues they printed, they were required to provide the files in some format only PageMaker could produce and for their plays -- .DWG files.

I'm not sure how AutoCAD was actually licensed[0]. But much like Adobe's products, AutoCAD was somewhere in the neighborhood of $1,000-$1,500 and because a price tag like that means "a lot of people will pirate it", they required attaching a special device to the parallel port (a "License Dongle") in order to start the application. Before I was old enough to "step in and solve the problem", my Dad would just take the dongle home with him on the weekends.

Generally speaking I don't think a single piece of software generated more profanity in my home than AutoCAD did. It started when he brought it home the first time. He'd dropped $4,000 on an 8088 clone (built by a local shop) with a 10MB hard drive. We lacked the free space and he'd come home with a full height 20MB drive. I remember my Dad with a screwdriver trying to get the old drive out / new drive into this tight, steel case[1] about every 2-4 minutes -- yelling some brief 4-letter word-combo. I don't remember what it was that I needed in the office at that moment but my mom intercepted me on my way and said "you'll want to stay out of there for a little bit."[2]

I remember he had to install/remove the drive twice because he had forgotten to install the 8087 co-processor before he put the drive back in.

The dongle was a source of constant grief. In this era, the parallel port was almost always used for printing. The dongle had a pass-through. It sometimes let you print when the pass-through was used but for whatever reason, it failed enough that it was often removed to print. The license dongle remained unplugged most of the time because the computer was used to print things more than it was used to draft things. Worse, I think this was one of two license dongles that was required by software my Dad used. These dongles appeared to be designed to fail -- kind of makes sense if their license model really is "per seat/per user" -- maybe they wanted it to fail if it's traded between machines too frequently? But suffice it to say, it broke. Around this time, thankfully, I'd discovered BBSes and software cracking. I fixed the problem and we lost the dongle.

[0] I'm going to guess that it was actually "per install/per user" and forgive the remainder of the details ... I'm going from poorly Google-enhanced memory from when I was under age ten. Anecdotally, my Dad and all of the businesses that he worked with -- outside of "taking home a dongle" -- were all properly licensed despite the common wisdom at the time being "small shops are mostly pirates."

[1] Google image search 8088 clone and look for the ones with the two 5.12" floppies, beige plastic front, all metal otherwise. We had two 5.12" floppies in the right full height drive slot and one MFM full-height HDD in the left.

[2] I'm making my Dad sound like an angry hot-head -- in reality, he was never like this except for the handful of times he had to fight with this box. Had I walked into the office, my Dad probably would have been embarrassed ... my mom was simply trying to keep me out of his hair while he was stressed out.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#106
post #71

What is the best (affordable!) CAD software for a hobbyist with no experience? I was recently looking into this and the leading software was like 6,000 USD a year per seat.

FreeCAD. Free and open source. I use it all of the time for 3D modelling and 3D printing. One of my clients has recently switched to BricsCAD. Cheaper than AutoDesk but not super cheap.

I switched to FreeCAD after Fusion360s license and price changed.

It’s definitely not as advanced as Fusion, but for my needs it’s good enough.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#108
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not wise to use cracked software for business. Someone might talk, and your office could get raided by the cops. Yes - that happens in places like Eastern Europe too - some people that I know found this out the hard way.

Where in Eastern Europe? Pretty sure in Romania police have better things to do than raid you for using pirated software at work.

There is nowhere in the world that police don’t have better things to do than to raid a shop using pirated software.

Re: Louis Rossmann: Autodesk turns lifetime licenses into subscriptions [video]

#110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has there ever been an example of an industry standard tool losing out to FOSS alternatives? Ever? There are reasons for that.

20 years ago if you were serious about a system with an rdbms is was sybase or oracle. Now almost everything is postgres.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN