Live data from Hacker News

All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

masto.ai

51–60 of 105 posts

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very few sites die entirely. Usenet, BBS, AOL, nethack.alt.org, AskJeeves, MySpace, and Facebook all still exist. That doesn’t mean they remain culturally relevant.

> AskJeeves dogpile too

Ah, Dogpile. The search connoisseur's choice before Google.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#53

I suspect that this is going to deter news sites from using tweets in articles. Imo this is probably a good thing, but what twitter thinks it well get out of this isn't clear to me.

I've recently noticed a few places screen-grabbing tweets rather than embedding them. Presumably for this reason.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#55

This effectively breaks 15 years of links to tweets posted all over the Internet. Just another reason to keep the web open. This takes Twitter to the same level as Facebook, a website that only lives of its internal posts, where no young people open accounts, and where eventually the only ones who post are the ones who opened an account in its time.

It's already having some effects on my googling, just like the reddit blackout.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#56
I still have a few accounts I glance at from time to time. Hockey, Game Devs, Artists, etc. who haven't migrated away despite everything, so this is kinda obnoxious.

I created some Redirector (https://einaregilsson.com/redirector/) rules to redirect Tweet and Twitter Profile URLs to their HTML embed equivalents.

Should be able to just import the rules and it seems to work alright with some caveats.

  * I have no idea if this will continue to function.
  * I've only tested some random links from my Discord and Slack groups.
  * Profile links only show the most recent 20 tweets.
  * Tweets will show quote-tweets, but no replies (though maybe that's a good thing).
  * Obviously won't work for mobile.
https://gist.github.com/robotblake/a0f020381c1a919cf9720f9ae...

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#59
post #7

Login wall for me. I'll give it a day and then delete the dozen or so remaining twitter accounts I had bookmarked and checked in occasionally. I did delete my account a few months before Elon took over, guess we are watching its final days.

What in the world gives you the impression Twitter is in its final days? Naysayers have been saying Twitter fill fail any day now for about 8 or 9 months now.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#60
post #7

Login wall for me. I'll give it a day and then delete the dozen or so remaining twitter accounts I had bookmarked and checked in occasionally. I did delete my account a few months before Elon took over, guess we are watching its final days.

It isn’t final until people actually leave there. As long as there’re users. Otherwise not gonna happen :(

Well, depends how you're defining 'final', really. Like, one way of looking at it is that Livejournal hasn't had its final day yet; there are still people on Livejournal. Another is that it had its final day in 2006 or so; from that point on (at least in the English-speaking world; I think it stayed relevant in Russia for longer) it was kind of a legacy semi-zombie social network.

Twitter's whole thing is its outsized cultural relevance for a rather small user base. If that goes, well, arguably, it's had its final day. This particular change seems like it might go a long way towards ending its relevance; an awful lot of people used twitter only via clicking links from news articles etc, and never actually had an account.

Post reply on HN