Live data from Hacker News

All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

masto.ai

31–40 of 105 posts

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#31
post #15
post #4

Hmm, I wonder if this is just an experiment, a bug, or something permanent. Posting twitter links to places like HN will be a no-no, since a good portion of the people can't view the content. Will that stop people from using Twitter to inform?

Unfortunately, many things posted to HN are not on the Internet. Paywalled links, links to articles where the publisher does the idiotic IP-based regionalization and denies access to those not in his "region", etc. I believe HN should make a rule that only links to things on the Internet are allowed. If it's not readable by anyone with an IP address, it shouldn't be on HN.

Agreed; clicking on a paywall link is such an unedifying experience. Direct links to paywalled content should almost always be avoided, not just on HN!

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#32

Bad move on Elon's part. Many people deleted their accounts when he took over, but some portion of them are still "addicted" to twitter and browse it anonymously. Thus still generating views and revenue for the company. Once the login wall comes up, most of them are leaving for good, as their egos will not allow them to create another account.

I hope you realize the login wall was something that came up before musk aquired twitter. one of the first things he did was remove it.

I am not a prolific twitter user. I am one of the "anonymous lurkers" I mentioned in my original comment. But your observation makes sense, as I only started visiting Twitter after Elon's takeover. The removal of the login wall must have been the reason.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#33

This is a hard stretch. That login wall is easily dismissible. Haven't come across any tweet, even content that could be considered "premium" like Tucker's long form video commentaries, that is not available behind the login wall. EDIT: I was wrong. This was the behavior not so long ago, seems like any link now redirects to homepage.

not for me, it redirects to another page entirely

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#34

Bad move on Elon's part. Many people deleted their accounts when he took over, but some portion of them are still "addicted" to twitter and browse it anonymously. Thus still generating views and revenue for the company. Once the login wall comes up, most of them are leaving for good, as their egos will not allow them to create another account.

I hope you realize the login wall was something that came up before musk aquired twitter. one of the first things he did was remove it.

That's little consolation now that he's, apparently, put it back (possibly 'worse' than before).

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#35

This is a hard stretch. That login wall is easily dismissible. Haven't come across any tweet, even content that could be considered "premium" like Tucker's long form video commentaries, that is not available behind the login wall. EDIT: I was wrong. This was the behavior not so long ago, seems like any link now redirects to homepage.

How do you dismiss it? I just get redirected to /home from everything. Even if I click the "X", I just end up on the frontpage instead of the page I wanted to see.

(It's different from the "please login" in-page popup that came up before occasionally. That one indeed was easily dismissable)

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#36

This is a hard stretch. That login wall is easily dismissible. Haven't come across any tweet, even content that could be considered "premium" like Tucker's long form video commentaries, that is not available behind the login wall. EDIT: I was wrong. This was the behavior not so long ago, seems like any link now redirects to homepage.

Not on my phone, click a link to something somebody shares, no way to get away from logging in.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#37

Bad move on Elon's part. Many people deleted their accounts when he took over, but some portion of them are still "addicted" to twitter and browse it anonymously. Thus still generating views and revenue for the company. Once the login wall comes up, most of them are leaving for good, as their egos will not allow them to create another account.

I hope you realize the login wall was something that came up before musk aquired twitter. one of the first things he did was remove it.

It never worked like this, though. You could always view a single linked tweet/thread; it was if you tried to view a timeline that you ran into difficulties.

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hope you realize the login wall was something that came up before musk aquired twitter. one of the first things he did was remove it.

I am not a prolific twitter user. I am one of the "anonymous lurkers" I mentioned in my original comment. But your observation makes sense, as I only started visiting Twitter after Elon's takeover. The removal of the login wall must have been the reason.

Yep it used to be you could view individual tweets but nothing else. Elon came in removed it and made everything free to view. A couple months ago I noticed they went back to the old system. And now you can't even view individual tweets. Embedded tweets still work I guess

Re: All Twitter content seems to be behind a login wall today

#40

Nitter is still working, although searching for users seems to have stopped working you can still use the tweet search tab or manually type a twitter username on the end of the URL. List of nitter instances: https://github.com/xnaas/nitter-instances They unpredictably say "This nitter instance has been rate limited", you can try a few from the above list to find one that is getting less traffic.

Does Nitter have the trending tab? I couldn't find any but found this elsewhere. https://twitter-trends.iamrohit.in/
Post reply on HN