Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

news.ycombinator.com

171–180 of 194 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#171

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pretty much every company has been shown to have fake status pages at this point.

Status pages are updated by humans and the humans need to (1) realize there's a problem and (2) understand the magnitude of the problem and (3) put that on the status page. It's not fake, it's just a human process. And automating this would be error prone just the same.

Also (2b) convince their boss that the “optics” are better to update sooner than later.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#172
post #168
post #56

https://www.githubstatus.com/ Just flipped to red. See here: https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/gqx5l06jjxhp >Investigating - We are currently experiencing an outage of GitHub products and are investigating. >Jun 29, 2023 - 17:52 UTC

As the person in charge of one such page, I’d like to take the opportunity to remind folks that many— if not most—of these status pages are hand-updated, and most bosses absolutely hate anyone having to update them to anything but green.

Sounds like an anti-pattern or SLA dodge to me.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#173

Everytime github goes down, and my push/pull is rejected, I immediately assume they’ve discovered I’m incompetent and fired me. And I’m the head of engineering at my company.

thats not very healthy given how unreliable github has become in recent years. E.g. just yesterday for a short time frame of a few hours maybe half a day or so they had a bug where some closed PRs where shown in the personal which show created _not closed_ PRs. Or github CI having spurious job cancellations or sometimes on a job failing waits until some (quite long) timeout is reached before reporting it. Or it tempo…

Something internal must be going on at Microsoft. My company's PowerBI service has had some major performance issues over the past week

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#174

Everytime github goes down, and my push/pull is rejected, I immediately assume they’ve discovered I’m incompetent and fired me. And I’m the head of engineering at my company.

At a friend's company, the CEO had a calendar invite of "Fire Dan", for April 1. Dan went to confirm it was an April Fools' joke. It wasn't!

wtf. that's pretty cold.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#175

Everytime github goes down, and my push/pull is rejected, I immediately assume they’ve discovered I’m incompetent and fired me. And I’m the head of engineering at my company.

I get this feeling when I get kicked out of Google services at a different time than my usual 7 days (Monday) log out. I'm an admin of the Google services we use, and I still get that stomach dropping feeling.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#176

Everytime github goes down, and my push/pull is rejected, I immediately assume they’ve discovered I’m incompetent and fired me. And I’m the head of engineering at my company.

At a friend's company, the CEO had a calendar invite of "Fire Dan", for April 1. Dan went to confirm it was an April Fools' joke. It wasn't!

This is something my boss would post in his calendar publicly without even thinking of it. I guess it helps me to get ahead of it, if it were to ever happen to me, but having the rest of the company able to see it is pretty cold and unfeeling.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#177
post #108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the same thing every time my credentials to our issue tracker expires and I have to log in again. I am the lead dev on two projects.

Is there a name for firing trauma? I'm like this ever since I was scapegoated.

Borderline imposter syndrome?

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very good points. Meanwhile I have clients asking me why they can't have a status page to which I reply: you can, but ultimately to be completely fail proof it will be a human updating it slowly. To which they reply: but GitHub or X does it... Very infuriating, that.

There's some nice tooling these days for this. E.g. https://firehydrant.com/ and https://incident.io both make this a faster, more embedded process.

And Jeli.io for this! With the Statuspage integration, you can set the status, impact, write a message for customers, and select impacted components all without leaving Slack. Statuspage gets updated with a click of a button.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#179
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a name for firing trauma? I'm like this ever since I was scapegoated.

I’m no mental health professional, but that sounds like literal PTSD, to me.

There’s a long list of signals that can trigger folks into layoff panic.

Re: Ask HN: Is GitHub down?

#180
post #83
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Strange stuff, as it works completely fine for me in the EU? I just posted comments to several issues. Edit: Front page still loads and I am logged in. Everything is as normal. Status page shows everything is down. Lol.

yes, seems to be a network issue, not a service issue

That was my guess. Something on the frontend like a load balancer or proxy blocking traffic, but everything behind that was doing fine.
Post reply on HN