Live data from Hacker News

Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

wbtv.com

131–140 of 302 posts

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#131

It's cool how they wait as long as they can before gently placing the nose on the runway. So much smoother and quieter than I anticipated. Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink!

> Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink!

Fun fact: Pilots can have a non-zero BAC (I think .04). So they could have it while on duty too if it’s not a double!

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#132
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Repainting them between flights is a real pain.

This wouldn't be a hull-loss or a major rebuild? I'd think the runway is keeping some of the aluminum from the nose for itself. Plus that's a lot of vibration near sensitive radome.

Not even close to a hull loss. Delta's Tech Ops will have this plane back in service very quickly.

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not saying this should be an alternative , but having read a lot of transcripts and video of things like this, I wonder why there aren't outside cameras that would potentially give pilots a visual indication of plane conditions outside? Is it just the cost of supporting resilient cameras? A lot of incident reports have flight attendants or copilots leaving to try to make visual confirmation of things that it seems wo…

You'd gain nothing, they can already see it with their eyeballs, and they don't require anything else like faster response or a different viewpoint. You'd lose in terms of putting another hole in the aircraft and maintaining another system, and you'd still need the manual procedure in case the camera didn't work.

>and you'd still need the manual procedure in case the camera didn't work.

And presumably if the camera doesn't work as part of the pre-flight checklist for whatever reason, you're not going anywhere until it's fixed/replaced.

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#134
post #131

It's cool how they wait as long as they can before gently placing the nose on the runway. So much smoother and quieter than I anticipated. Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink!

> Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink! Fun fact: Pilots can have a non-zero BAC (I think .04). So they could have it while on duty too if it’s not a double!

You are technically correct about the BAC, but they definitely cannot have one while "on duty", there's an 8 hour limit between your last drink and flying and some airlines have longer time windows by policy

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/14/91.17

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#135
post #131

It's cool how they wait as long as they can before gently placing the nose on the runway. So much smoother and quieter than I anticipated. Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink!

> Delta owes these pilots an off-duty drink! Fun fact: Pilots can have a non-zero BAC (I think .04). So they could have it while on duty too if it’s not a double!

Not quite, there's also a rule that you can't operate an aircraft within 8 hours of consuming alcohol, aka. "8 hours bottle to throttle".

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#136

First, pilots should be commended. 101 (or 104) souls were saved. This is an almost 23 year old plane. Even with checks and maintenance, was age a factor?

This is kind of patronizing to the pilots. There’s nothing particularly difficult about what they did, which has been practiced many times. They ran their checklists, and then landed the plane, and they did it well, just like any other qualified pilot should have. People need to stop conflating basic competence with heroics. Age is always a factor in mechanical failure, but I’m sure this failure will be inspected in…

An expert successfully doing the thing they trained for can still be praiseworthy.

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#137
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The specific plane (1), N955AT, is 22.6 years old. So not young, but not completely geriatric either. Delta seems to be the only major operator of the plane type, so don't think there'd be too many buyers. Delta also seems to have a fair few in storage(2) so a fair guess would be that they'd scrap it but keep the parts that they could still use on other planes as spares. 1) https://www.airfleets.net/ficheapp/plane-b7…

Delta and Hawaiian are the two US operators. Hawaiian loves it, and is struggling to replace it. They use them for island-hopping. Modern airliners don't do well in this use case — modern engines have been engineered to tight tolerances to extract fuel economy, and their thermal designs rely on the cold air at cruise altitude to keep them healthy. Island hops are too short and too low for that to hold. The engines on…

> The engines on the 717 handle it just fine, but anything else on the market will require the planes to sit on the tarmac for a significant length of time between landing and takeoff for them to cool enough

Is it just a matter of the brakes and tires/wheels needing to cool down or other parts need the cooldown period as well?

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#138

What's with them putting "a hold" on all of the passengers possessions? Like, that's leaving people without their wallets (aka id, money) and so on. Sounds like they may not get it back for an unknown period of time (weeks, months?) either.

They probably want to make sure the plane is undisturbed before it can be examined by crash investigators and so on? There's probably a bit of a safety and practicality aspect of accessing a plane with a collapsed gear.

Sure, they can "want" whatever they err... want.

Doesn't seem like they should get their way when it comes to people's id and other personal docs, if that's what's really going on.

Potentially stranding international passengers without their passport (etc) is really not on.

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#139
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The specific plane (1), N955AT, is 22.6 years old. So not young, but not completely geriatric either. Delta seems to be the only major operator of the plane type, so don't think there'd be too many buyers. Delta also seems to have a fair few in storage(2) so a fair guess would be that they'd scrap it but keep the parts that they could still use on other planes as spares. 1) https://www.airfleets.net/ficheapp/plane-b7…

Delta and Hawaiian are the two US operators. Hawaiian loves it, and is struggling to replace it. They use them for island-hopping. Modern airliners don't do well in this use case — modern engines have been engineered to tight tolerances to extract fuel economy, and their thermal designs rely on the cold air at cruise altitude to keep them healthy. Island hops are too short and too low for that to hold. The engines on…

The Hawaiian Islands are sort of an interesting case. Island hopping is short for jets (and a lot of people don't really like flying small props). But they're really too far apart for a ferry service between the major islands; it was tried at one point but went out of business.

Re: Delta flight lands in Charlotte without front landing gear

#140

What's with them putting "a hold" on all of the passengers possessions? Like, that's leaving people without their wallets (aka id, money) and so on. Sounds like they may not get it back for an unknown period of time (weeks, months?) either.

You guys have wallets? Seems like the only possession you’d really need to do anything useful is your phone.
Post reply on HN