Earlier quoted context omitted.
Actually, ״to be״ in Hebrew translates to להיות (l’hyot), depending on the context. “I want to be at home” “אני רוצה להיות בבית״
Sure, but in most cases its conjugations are just left out entirely, as in "קר לי"; literally "cold to me" (I am cold). "אני רעב" -> "I hungry" (leaving out the "am" English speakers would put it there), etc.
Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
81–89 of 89 posts
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#82Earlier quoted context omitted.
You may be interested in this newer paper, reconciling the work of Killingsworth and Kahneman & Deaton. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2208661120
I work in this area and I really dislike it when happiness is plotted against income only on a log scale, as is done here. The log scale effectively conceals the flattening-out of the relationship, which is the thing that shows you how progressive taxation + redistribution make the average person better off. Whether it's a straight line up to $75K followed by a flat line from there on, or a curved (log) relationship…
Would “Income and emotional well-being: It doesn’t really matter” be a better title for the study? Or do I miss something?
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#83Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#84Earlier quoted context omitted.
Can you expand on why you think this is a batshit crazy garbage?
Evolutionary psychology is psuedoscience.
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#85I think "content" is the English word the author is looking for - the first definition I see on Google from Oxford is "in a state of peaceful happiness" which seems like the intended long-term meaning - "a state", not a moment, and "peaceful", not surprise-driven. Beyond that, I'm a bit lost by where this is going - like the segue into confidence and building confidence by e.g. learning about roof building techniques…
"Content" is still a bit different, because it feels more layed back. The funny part is that "gelukkig" (same word but in Dutch) litteraly means "lucky". I'm sure it's the same for German. But lucky and gelukkig have completely different meanings. I would say "happiness" still comes closer. Now that I think about it, I don't think we have a word for "lucky".
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#86Interesting way to put it, but is it particularly insightful? You're happy when you're doing things you think you should be doing, and what you think you should be doing is of course determined by evolution, modulo random mutations. I don't see how this helps me in any constructive way though. It is an intriguing thought exercise though.
many people aren't happy. and the problem is figuring out why. are they not doing what they think they should be doing? if so, why aren't they? is something getting in the way? is their idea of what they should be doing different from what society thinks they should be doing?
as a society i think we don't have the right idea of what makes people happy. we think we can tell them what they should be doing, but i think part of the answer is selfdetermination. we need to give people the freedom (and the ability to exercise that freedom) to make their own choices, and not force them to conform to our ideas and standards.
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#87The title: > Happiness is a reward from our ancestors Followed by the subtitle: > Long-term happiness only comes to those who emulate their successful ancestors Did anyone else get a severe case of mental whiplash from that? I pretty strongly agree with the title in many ways (the now is built on the shoulders of the past), but holy cow I do not agree with that subtitle at all . The rest of this reads like a pile of…
>Happiness is a reward from our ancestors >Long-term happiness only comes to those who emulate their successful ancestors The title made sense to me in terms of the subtitle when I read it. Our ancestors figured out how to survive and encoded it into happiness and passed it on as a gift. It's a sort of embedded encoding they've figured out and left for us in how to survive. Conversely I've begun thinking depression i…
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#88> In Swedish... someone happy in the moment is called glad... Someone happy in the longer-term is called lycklig. And we are not just some millions of weirdos in the northernmost of Europe. The Germans are froh when they are happy in the short term and glücklich when they are happy in the long term... Just because you don't have a dedicated word for something, doesn't mean that it is a foreign concept. In Arabic and…
Yet other times the lack of that word denotes a different perspective on that subject. Short term or long term happiness isn’t differentiated in the untied states. I don’t think of happiness in terms of long or short term. Just as a temporary state that hopefully last a long time. Think of all the words we use to express love in English. In Chinese a word technically exists for love but it’s not used between people m…
Re: Happiness is a reward from our ancestors
#89The most interesting sentence is the title of the piece. Happiness is a reward. Chasing happiness is a fundamentally mistaken project because if you just want to be in a mental state of happiness, do drugs, it's that easy. We got plenty of pharmaceuticals that short circuit all the annoying steps you have to do to be happy. Roger Scruton in "On Beauty" made a related point about erotic art and porn. What distinguishe…
Drugs don't work like that. Over time, your body gets used to them, and you need drugs just to feel normal - and without them, you feel terrible. Just like with less dangerous addictions, e.g. to coffee.