Live data from Hacker News

JP Morgan fined by SEC for deleting email records

theregister.com

11–20 of 254 posts

Re: JP Morgan fined by SEC for deleting email records

#12

> Worse still, the stuffup meant that it couldn't produce evidence that that the SEC and others subpoenaed in their investigations Oopsie, that's too bad. Totally accidental though I swear.

If an individual does that, they get held in contempt.

But with a corporation all they can do is fine, so it just becomes a cost of business :(

Re: JP Morgan fined by SEC for deleting email records

#15

> Worse still, the stuffup meant that it couldn't produce evidence that that the SEC and others subpoenaed in their investigations Oopsie, that's too bad. Totally accidental though I swear.

If an individual does that, they get held in contempt. But with a corporation all they can do is fine, so it just becomes a cost of business :(

Getting held in contempt of court is usually punished with a fine for individuals as well, so how is that different?

Re: JP Morgan fined by SEC for deleting email records

#17
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If an individual does that, they get held in contempt. But with a corporation all they can do is fine, so it just becomes a cost of business :(

Getting held in contempt of court is usually punished with a fine for individuals as well, so how is that different?

The difference is that if you were to be held in contempt of court, your fine would probably be higher than something like 0.01% of your annual earnings.

Re: JP Morgan fined by SEC for deleting email records

#18
post #2

I believe them

This, but unironically.

When a law requires data to be retained for X time, risk-averse companies interpret this as an instruction to immediately delete said data as soon as time X passes, and use automated tools to this end. Sadly, these tools tend to be ad-hoc software written and maintained by internal teams, and thus about as buggy as you'd expect.

I've worked in such places, and - in addition to all the other issues - the continuous collective loss of corporate knowledge makes life pretty miserable.

Post reply on HN