Live data from Hacker News

The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

cedwards.xyz

11–20 of 403 posts

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#11

I don’t think this is a dark pattern per se. You don’t expect to walk into any restaurant and get free food. With meta products, you pay for content by being tracked. If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. It’s simple.

> If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content.

Ah, but this is not what is happening. They do show content! It's just that basically any interaction whatsoever with this content immediately triggers the login prompt.

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#12

I don’t think this is a dark pattern per se. You don’t expect to walk into any restaurant and get free food. With meta products, you pay for content by being tracked. If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. It’s simple.

>you pay for content by being tracked

Meta likes tracking you even outside their own walled jail-platforms, too.

https://www.theregister.com/2018/04/17/facebook_admits_to_tr...

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#13

I don’t think this is a dark pattern per se. You don’t expect to walk into any restaurant and get free food. With meta products, you pay for content by being tracked. If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. It’s simple.

I’d say its more like an art gallery where other people provide the content, but fuck you if you aren’t gonna give your privacy up

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#14

I don’t think this is a dark pattern per se. You don’t expect to walk into any restaurant and get free food. With meta products, you pay for content by being tracked. If you refuse to sign in, they refuse to show you content. It’s simple.

Except in a restaurant, the chef gets paid. In this platform, value is extracted from the chef, the waiter, the eater, the eaten, and their interaction, while tearing down societies. Not a fair comparison.

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#15

It's most annoying when businesses make IG their actual website, or restaurants have their menus there, etc. I've never been on IG and can't access the content, so they don't get my business.

You can still go to the restaurant to eat presumably they'll have some paper menus in there, or QR's or whatever

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#16
post #15

It's most annoying when businesses make IG their actual website, or restaurants have their menus there, etc. I've never been on IG and can't access the content, so they don't get my business.

You can still go to the restaurant to eat presumably they'll have some paper menus in there, or QR's or whatever

Or I can go to any of a hundred different places that don't lock their info behind Zuck's paywall.

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#17
post #15

It's most annoying when businesses make IG their actual website, or restaurants have their menus there, etc. I've never been on IG and can't access the content, so they don't get my business.

You can still go to the restaurant to eat presumably they'll have some paper menus in there, or QR's or whatever

Sure, you could also just go to a supermarket. If you don't know what to expect, why risk it?

Re: The 'fuck you' pattern (2021)

#19
post #15

It's most annoying when businesses make IG their actual website, or restaurants have their menus there, etc. I've never been on IG and can't access the content, so they don't get my business.

You can still go to the restaurant to eat presumably they'll have some paper menus in there, or QR's or whatever

I've actually stood up and left restaurants when their QR menu sends me to IG.
Post reply on HN