Live data from Hacker News

Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

mapbox.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#11
You should make the freeways a different color from the rest of the roads. I just tried to zoom into my house, and I discovered that when looking at the city-wide view, I use the freeways as a high-level roadmap. When everything's the same color (gray!) it's hard to locate yourself.

I hope you've all seen this article, about subtle design changes they made at google. Attention to detail is really critical:

http://google-latlong.blogspot.com/2009/10/evolving-look-of-...

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#12
post #8

There's not enough contrast between the street names and the rest of the map, making readability a problem. It's the kind of design mistake that young people with nice monitors make!

I know this guy's being downvoted here, but he's got a point. I find people on nice, big cinema displays tend to make choices on colors and labeling that people with shittier monitors wouldn't make. Eg, colors that are very close, tinier labels, etc.

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#13
post #10

Great news! Is this available at high zooms across the US and Canada yet?

It's z16 globally - as soon as this is solidly out in the wild, we'll be working hard on getting deeper zoom levels. Each zoom level is exponentially larger than the last, so it's a significant challenge.

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#14
post #8

There's not enough contrast between the street names and the rest of the map, making readability a problem. It's the kind of design mistake that young people with nice monitors make!

This was designed primarily on a MacBook Pro running Linux, so the colors were oddly calibrated. We tested it on several other calibrated monitors, and a few other devices (iPhone/Pad/Android).

Short story is that it could be much bolder and more colorful, at the cost of aesthetics. A growing number of users have good screens - sometimes excellent screens like most mobile devices.

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#15
post #14
post #8

There's not enough contrast between the street names and the rest of the map, making readability a problem. It's the kind of design mistake that young people with nice monitors make!

This was designed primarily on a MacBook Pro running Linux, so the colors were oddly calibrated. We tested it on several other calibrated monitors, and a few other devices (iPhone/Pad/Android). Short story is that it could be much bolder and more colorful, at the cost of aesthetics. A growing number of users have good screens - sometimes excellent screens like most mobile devices.

Ok, but have you tested it on the absolute worst your users will be using?

What does it look like on grandma's 17 inch crt from 2002?

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#16
still the same problem with the OSM renderer : http://a.tiles.mapbox.com/v3/mapbox.mapbox-streets.html#10.0... there are more than 6 cities in this area, why so few labels ? (look at gmaps: http://maps.google.fr/?ll=47.38834,6.678009&spn=0.65269,... ).

and I think there are not enough details for a medieval city : http://a.tiles.mapbox.com/v3/mapbox.mapbox-streets.html#16.0...

but I think the color scheme is pleasant.

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#17
Its good to see some decent visual rendering of OSM data. I appreciate your choice in not colouring the roads in, (for some reason people always do this - maybe they don't realise that users don't use online maps to drive a car!). Visually, it is quite clear in most cases, which is nice (despite, as always having some difficulty with overground/underground objects in the same location).

Have you considered doing different map renderings for different purposes? (this very brown-grey theme might not work well for dark-background websites, and some people might want extra data such as train stations added)?

Re: Announcing MapBox Streets: A Global Map with Street Level Detail

#20

Its good to see some decent visual rendering of OSM data. I appreciate your choice in not colouring the roads in, (for some reason people always do this - maybe they don't realise that users don't use online maps to drive a car!). Visually, it is quite clear in most cases, which is nice (despite, as always having some difficulty with overground/underground objects in the same location). Have you considered doing diff…

Yes. You can preview a desaturated version to be released soon here: http://mapbox.com/tour/#maps (click on MapBox Light). You can render your own layers for things like POIs and transit stations using TileMill, and we'll be adding those in as separate layers soon too.
Post reply on HN