Live data from Hacker News

ELO Everything

eloeverything.co

21–30 of 106 posts

Re: ELO Everything

#21
See also Tom Scott's video "1,204,986 Votes Decided: What Is The Best Thing?" https://youtu.be/ALy6e7GbDRQ

In it he mentions that he kept the site up for only a short amount of time, in part to prevent anyone from writing a bot which could game it. Unfortunately, that has not been the case with Elo Everything, which has a clearly gamed leader board.

Re: ELO Everything

#22

Idea would be great for product recommendations, as long as the spam issue can be solved. Most people can make a reliable comparison between two products but maybe not among many.

> as long as the spam issue can be solved At the time of writing, Adolf Hitler is #1 on the leaderboard with Elo 1754.

6 minutes later -- my leaderboard shows oxygen at the top, and hitler is not in the top 100.

Re: ELO Everything

#23

Idea would be great for product recommendations, as long as the spam issue can be solved. Most people can make a reliable comparison between two products but maybe not among many.

Recommending the same popular things to everyone is a bad recommendation system.

Re: ELO Everything

#24
What’s the practical application of this? It makes sense in chess where you have two players using the same rules, so a comparison makes sense. But is Postgres a better database than Redis? Is The Godfather a better film than Lord of the Rings? These questions make no sense. Political candidates can’t get an increased value simply for being less popular.

So is the idea that you use this in a very technical space for, say, ranking jobs in a queue? Or is it intended for an e-commerce site to order by product ratings?

Re: ELO Everything

#26

Ruiners of all good things incoming... It's cool, but dealing with bad-faith participants is what is really difficult about these types of exercises. It works great until the hurt people find it, and then the hurt people hurt people -- perpetuating their sadness unto others by upvoting the bad things.

It's a silly web site that means nothing. If you attribute hurt or sadness to the result on it, that's not the fault of anyone else.

Re: ELO Everything

#29
Unironically, I want this, but for restaurants/stores/etc, essentially a replacement for Google Maps' helpful but deeply flawed one-to-five-star (but actually 4.0-4.9-star) rating system.
Post reply on HN