Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 186 posts

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#11

Mine has infinite scroll, but not infinite scroll of results. At a certain point it switches to boxes of recommended articles based on what it considers similar searches, which are literally never useful to me

I stopped using Google on mobile about a year ago as a result.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#12
It’s comical how they finally get around to infinite scroll after destroying the quality and quantity of the results. I very regularly get to the end of the results 20-30 in.

I used to utilize the vaguely related deep-dive results, especially in image searches, to go on tours of nostalgia or just wandering. But Google can’t offer that anymore.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#15
post #8
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ugh :( I really liked having individual pages

Out of interest, why? I find infinite scroll a pareto improvement (an improvement with no downsides)

Because I can skip tons of pages, I can go back to the same page later.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#16
Infinite scrolling needs to die in a fire. I'm sure it increases some fallacious "engagement" metric like time spent on the page or something, but it's an utterly horrible experience. Scroll down one and a half pages, watch a spinning circle as the next few results load, then watch the spinning circles as the result images load, repeat until you can't take it anymore and give up.

On the whole this assertion of always-available javascript has basically destroyed the usability of the web as every small minded manager/designer thinks that inserting themselves in the way of the user makes for some endearing "experience". It doesn't.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#17

Yes, you can disable it. It's right there at the top of the Search Settings page. However, the selection of individual pages is gone, and replaced by a single "More results" arrow at the bottom of the page. So it does appear that they've gutted the functionality, and it's only continuous scrolling whether you choose manual or automatic style.

> However, the selection of individual pages is gone Are you logged in? I have disabled infinite scrolling, and I still have selection of individual pages. But if I open an incognito window and disable infinite scrolling, I get the same "More results" as you, so I'm wondering if it's related to being logged in or not.

A/B testing, I have different behaviour between my work Google account and personal account. Hadn't really noticed until this thread though.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#18
Despite all the hate Google and infinite scroll gets, it seems to be good decision doesn't it?

You rarely go to even the second page, I'm almost always improving/changing the query instead of going to next pages, so even in those edge cases where I have to go to next pages, then auto loading next results when I'm at the bottom of the page seems viable solution

Infinite scroll is annoying because e.g you cannot link to thing

but that's not the case with Google - you do not link Google results to people, you send them the result itself - desired website.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#19
post #8
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ugh :( I really liked having individual pages

Out of interest, why? I find infinite scroll a pareto improvement (an improvement with no downsides)

On mobile it might be. On Desktop it (1) devalues the scrollbar, since you can no longer use its size in proportion to its container to judge how large the page is compared with your view of it, and (2) adds jank while the next set of results is loaded (the pause while loading feels random rather than an expected event in response to your changing page).

The other thing that's annoying me is the overriding of cursor keys, making each scrolling step much larger than it would normally be. Yes, it might be more logical for a keypress to step to the next result, but that's not how the cursor keys are expected to behave in the browser, so it's jarring.

Re: Ask HN: Has Google search switched to infinite scrolling for you too now?

#20

Despite all the hate Google and infinite scroll gets, it seems to be good decision doesn't it? You rarely go to even the second page, I'm almost always improving/changing the query instead of going to next pages, so even in those edge cases where I have to go to next pages, then auto loading next results when I'm at the bottom of the page seems viable solution Infinite scroll is annoying because e.g you cannot link t…

> You rarely go to even the second page

You might not, I do, I do a lot, I even go further. I personally don't like the change at all

Post reply on HN