Live data from Hacker News

Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

theverge.com

31–40 of 142 posts

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#31
post #3
post #2

This is the biggest benefit reddit provided to the user base. Google search has been lackluster and appending the word reddit allowed me to see plenty of good anecdotal and informative focused discussions without fluffing up the content for SEO.

Plenty of paid content on the mattress subs and I'm sure many others

Mattress subs?

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#32
post #24
post #20

Monopolization effects from social networks is so powerful. I really wish decentralization would take off again, but it's a vicious cycle. Search incentives SEO hacking. SEO hacking causes searches engines to stick to weigh reputation scores more. Reputation scores favor large social media platforms that have strong moderation practices. Quora, reddit, and other platforms become more valuable than SEO hacked blog spa…

> Quora This has to be one of these most useless sites on the Internet and it blows my mind how frequently the content from this site is exposed via Google search. Now that I think about it, I think I should probably just block it on my local DNS server.

I hate how easy it is to get confused about what content on the page is even related to the original question. I have to get into my “Quora mindset” where I’m constantly double-checking that I’m not reading the response to a different random question injected into the original page.

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#33
post #32
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Quora This has to be one of these most useless sites on the Internet and it blows my mind how frequently the content from this site is exposed via Google search. Now that I think about it, I think I should probably just block it on my local DNS server.

I hate how easy it is to get confused about what content on the page is even related to the original question. I have to get into my “Quora mindset” where I’m constantly double-checking that I’m not reading the response to a different random question injected into the original page.

I gave up on Quora! I don't even bother looking at all anymore. If Google gave me the ability to block certain sites from my search results, this would be at the top of my list.

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#34
post #24
post #20

Monopolization effects from social networks is so powerful. I really wish decentralization would take off again, but it's a vicious cycle. Search incentives SEO hacking. SEO hacking causes searches engines to stick to weigh reputation scores more. Reputation scores favor large social media platforms that have strong moderation practices. Quora, reddit, and other platforms become more valuable than SEO hacked blog spa…

> Quora This has to be one of these most useless sites on the Internet and it blows my mind how frequently the content from this site is exposed via Google search. Now that I think about it, I think I should probably just block it on my local DNS server.

Quora is often self-promotion now. The template I think of when replying to your comment is:

Great point you bring up on how useless is. As the CEO of , this is a problem we have put a lot of effort into addressing. You may consider the following as a solution: …

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#35
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really, Google cache works.

Don't tell the PE guys about archive.org and .is, either.

Neither Google cache nor archive.org/etc. covers all pages. I've been running into that problem a fair few times

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ouch a couple of people didn't like my straightforward observation. The thing is google is still working just as it was ... the fact the results are dead atm is beside the point. A person visiting old bookmarks to reddits that are unavailable at the moment could say the same, their bookmarks aren't working. I wouldn't author an article about bookmarks not working as such ...

The point of the article is that many people rely on Reddit being a major source in Google results (i.e., appending "reddit" to a search) because of how terrible Google's "organic" results have become with ad and SEO spam. Yes, Google is working as normal, but "normal" is terrible and posts on Reddit made Google results less terrible. If Google's results are so bad that I feel the need to limit the results to Reddit,…

It misses the point that many people don't use google, those search results from different search engines would similarly be impacted.

You should see the basic search page google hands me to use and has been that way the last 7 or so years. Then again, I used to be a very heavy user of google, multiple switches or operators for each advanced search, a habit from the times when that's all I did all day long. Before they made it hard for me, I bypassed their BS limit of f'all they eased in instead of the 100 results a page if one wanted and I crawled though multiple search pages and a few dozen results to land credible information to exclude echoes.

I know google results have dropped off the deep end, but framing reddit going dark as being of significant impact to search results is not honest. Yes, the result these people want is now inaccessible - it's not a new thing, results that are inaccessible are not unexpected. It's no different to the many deep searches I've done in the past and found what might have been useful results, were actually private unless one agrees to sell up their tracking data or the site was behind a pay wall.

I'd agree, Google and the like incentivised spam by shrugging for a start and then realising clutter gets more clicks and ads served.

I understand a lot of people are annoyed that many useful reddits are dark at the moment, a honest conversation would acknowledge that, rather than handing out prizes to those who the most upset about the protest.

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The point of the article is that many people rely on Reddit being a major source in Google results (i.e., appending "reddit" to a search) because of how terrible Google's "organic" results have become with ad and SEO spam. Yes, Google is working as normal, but "normal" is terrible and posts on Reddit made Google results less terrible. If Google's results are so bad that I feel the need to limit the results to Reddit,…

It misses the point that many people don't use google, those search results from different search engines would similarly be impacted. You should see the basic search page google hands me to use and has been that way the last 7 or so years. Then again, I used to be a very heavy user of google, multiple switches or operators for each advanced search, a habit from the times when that's all I did all day long. Before th…

[deleted]

Re: Google is getting a lot worse because of the Reddit blackouts

#40
post #2

This is the biggest benefit reddit provided to the user base. Google search has been lackluster and appending the word reddit allowed me to see plenty of good anecdotal and informative focused discussions without fluffing up the content for SEO.

yup. Without the 'reddit' suffix, the search quality is borderline garbage.
Post reply on HN