Live data from Hacker News

Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

sfgate.com

291–300 of 309 posts

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#291
Imagine Marlboro stopped selling cigarettes, would everyone be nostalgically swooning over them like the comments here?

There's absolutely no metabolic process that alcohol helps where at least cigarettes' increase your IQ:

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/will-a-nicotine-p...

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#292

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The skunky odor/flavor comes from light exposure to hops and it’s easily prevented with dark bottles or cans. Other herbs work well as preservatives and don’t get skunky at all. Beer can be shelf stable basically indefinitely if well kept, and often ages very well.

That's absolutely not true. IPAs cannot be shelf stable past a few months if unrefrigerated. They start to lose the hoppy aroma and taste and taste more muted. The longer you go the more skunky it tastes.

The entire style was an attempt to make beer that would not go bad while on long unrefrigerated journeys to India from England, using extra amounts of the alpha acids in hops as a preservative.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#293
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People get it in their heads that small and local means good or at least better than the stuff mass-produced by MegaCorp, but that's not always the case. I think beer is a case where it's hard to beat Big Beer. Heineken, the second-biggest brewery in the world, moved 231.2 million hectoliters of beer in 2021[0], or nearly 19,000 acre-feet of beer (!). How many locally-produced lagers actually taste better than Heinek…

I'm really confused at the general lack of knowledge about this topic on HN. Heineken is one of the worst beers made, and local beers, while mostly not great, are certainly better. Look at untappd for statistically significant ratings.

A fresh Heineken from the brewery is as good as a Pilsner Urquel of Budvar - very, very good. It’s not the same stuff you buy at any gas station.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#294

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any of Alchemist, Hill Farmstead, or Lawsons would be an uproar, and they’re all within like 60 miles of each other. Across New England there are many.

I've had all of them, other than being darlings of craft beer geeks, there is nothing really different about them. Parent is correct.

I think your average local brewery has trouble making a good tasting New England style IPA. If you found any NEIPA beers like Heady Topper or Sip of Sunshine, and are widely available, honestly let me know. Other beer styles are easier to recreate, but the NEIPA style is hard to get right.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just about every major metro in the US likely has a brewery making better tasting beer than Heineken. That’s not what Heineken is going for.

Which is why I was refuting OP's statement: > How many locally-produced lagers actually taste better than Heineken?

Yes, I was indeed agreeing with you.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#296
post #25

The article buried the lede. "Anchor, founded in 1896, was saved from bankruptcy in 1965 by longtime owner Fritz Maytag, and _sold to Sapporo in 2017_, Singer said." It ceased to be an independent local brewer almost a decade ago. The corporate overlords are doing what corporate overlords always do.

>sold to Sapporo in 2017 And suddenly a great mystery is solved! I had Anchor Steam in 2013 thereabouts and liked it quite a lot. When it became available locally I was happy to get it but it didn't quite taste as I remembered it. As time went on I quit buying it because it just wasn't as good as I remembered it to be. I wonder what they changed in the recipe?

Might not have had anything changed in the recipe itself. Beer (and cooking) scale weirdly and the flavors you associate with one size of batch change completely when you scale up to larger batches. For beer, it maybe isn't even that surprising given how much living yeast contributes to flavor and yeast is highly susceptible to environmental conditions including size of fermenting container or subtle things like location of fermenting container (even sometimes within the same building).

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#297
post #201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> t's trivial and cheap to make water harder, home brewers do it all the time to replicate specific styles I'm aware of this. I did it for my ribbon-winning brews. It is cheap at the home brewer scale, but at commercial scales, maybe not so much. > can be shipped Sure, it's possible to get genuine Saaz hops shipped from the Czech Republic to California. Again, A home brewer might be willing to shell out top dollar fo…

Adjusting the water for different styles or consistency across production facilities is a thing that is done at commercial scale. I had a professor in college who figured out how to do that for Bass' UK production facilities in the 1980s.

Sure, within limits. I don't think anyone is going to be brewing a traditional pilsner in Ireland, though. At least not profitably.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#298

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I have so many great, local breweries My city has a lot, but I personally can't share in them. I will instantly vomit if I drink any local brews (in any locale). Same with whiskey. I can drink nationally-distributed beers and vodka with no ill-effects. I have no idea why. I'm jumping on this comment because I imagine there are some HN readers that might have a theory and I would be very interested in hearing them.

I hate local beers. Local wine makes sense, there is terroir, a sense of place etc. Local beers are just some weird competition to see who can make the hopiest bitterest beer. I don't want to try a new lager every time I cross county lines, when I want beer I want something reliable.

Yeast has just as much "sense of place" and "terroir" as influences wine. Starting yeasts generally come prepackaged from just a few mass factories and the vast majority of brewers just rely on that. Not enough brewers appreciate "sourdough" styles of beer that rely on local wild forms of yeast (and to be fair, in many regions of the world the local wild yeasts are poorly adapted for brewing and need a lot of work to get there), but yeast is such a short-lived organism that it adapts quickly to the environments you give it and what you feed it even when you are using fresh packets directly from the national factory as a baseline every brewing session.

Local brewers with even the smallest bit of Belgian influence often have at least some small idea of this. Brewers that enjoy exploring styles known as "farmhouse" or "spontaneous" or "common" are generally exploring truly local beers in both flavor profiles and execution.

If brewing was as lucrative as fancy wines, you'd probably hear a lot more about breweries staffing local yeast experts and building yeast labs the way fancy vineyards hire soil experts. (I do know of at least a couple that do. New Glarus is a stand out for a number of reasons, including that their commitment to local also means that they never distribute beer outside of Wisconsin.)

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#299
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The skunky odor/flavor comes from light exposure to hops and it’s easily prevented with dark bottles or cans. Other herbs work well as preservatives and don’t get skunky at all. Beer can be shelf stable basically indefinitely if well kept, and often ages very well.

If it's easy to prevent, why is it so much more of a problem than for wine? Budweiser had a “born on date” and later switched it to a "freshest before" date. Other breweries insist on cold shipping--that's quite expensive.

Wines (generally) don't use hops. Hops are such a strange flower (or weed depending on your view of hops) that provide a lot of very complex molecules that break down in interesting ways over time. At their best those molecules are flowery and subtly bitter. At their worst they break down into skunky things, some of which at extreme worsts are poisonous. Grapes have some complex molecules, but not the same sorts of bitter sulfides that hops do.

Re: Anchor Brewing Company ends national distribution, kills Christmas Ale

#300

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are correct

I’m my defense I remembered the artwork then I bought their stout whenever I visited until I couldn’t find it anymore

I did not sigh at your mistake, I sighed at the over-prevalence of IPAs.
Post reply on HN