Live data from Hacker News

Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

neowin.net

11–20 of 517 posts

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#11

So how can we remove this and other Microsoft spyware from our systems?

You can't (assuming you want to keep Windows), or if you can it makes the OS unusable. There are plenty of custom 'builds' on the net of Windows 10, 11, etc.

Microsoft will continue down this path until it becomes unprofitable.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#12

So how can we remove this and other Microsoft spyware from our systems?

Use a different OS.

You can try to disable each new instance but it will keep coming. These "features" will get harder to disable as time goes on.

Microsoft's goal is to make as much money as possible. Your data is worth money. They will attempt to make use of that. Will this harm Windows use long-term? Likely. But it definitely makes money in the short term.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#13
post #3
post #2

It's such a dumb feature too, i don't think there's a single person who wants all the photos on the web "enhanced" it's adding features for the sake of adding features. What people actually want from edge is ads and tabloids not being plastered everywhere, but apparently that's asking too much.

I simply already dislike it because this means when creating a website you can't even rely anymore on the browser showing the image you as website designer intended. What if I'm deliberately showing a comparison of compression artifacts, or a screenshot of bad vs good game textures, or comparing photos of different cameras? Now the browser will alter the intended good vs bad quality comparison.

I've played around with having images being intentionally low-res or full of artifacts, for artistic reasons. This is a bit like "hey Vincent, your paintings are really low-res, let me make them more realistic for you like Rembrandt did!"

The feature as such seems okay, and I can even see myself using this on occasion. But it really should be a button in the image or something, for usability and privacy concerns.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#14
Brave --- the easy way to fix this and lots of other privacy related issues affecting the most popular web browsers.

As this article shows, you can fiddle with Edge and other browsers to try and make them more privacy respecting --- but why bother trying to hit a constantly moving target?

Clearly, your privacy is not in their best interests and they will only continue to circumvent it.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#15

This is just bananas to me that a browser would perform "super resolution" at all, much less by default . Couldn't this wreak havoc on doing things like viewing medical images, inserting false detail that isn't there? As well as on text in images, e.g. inventing a cleanly readable but hallucinated license plate number on a car, or financial figure, where the original is blurry? Not only does this seem like a terribly…

Indeed, this sounds like a bad idea not just for the user but for the image host as well. If I post a picture, I post it the way I want it to be seen. I don't want the browser to arbitrarily reinterpret it.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#16
post #5

That's nothing. This is on by default: "Allow Microsoft to save your browsing activity including history, usage, favorites, web content, and other browsing data to personalize Microsoft Edge and Microsoft services like ads, search, shopping and news."

If you are not paying for your browser with your wallet, somebody else is paying for you. It has all sorts of implications.

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#18

So how can we remove this and other Microsoft spyware from our systems?

"Debian GNU/Linux Installation Guide"

https://www.debian.org/releases/bookworm/amd64/index.en.html

"Free Software, Free Society: Selected Essays of Richard M. Stallman"

https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf

Re: Edge sends images you view online to Microsoft

#19

Sounds like a feature a product manager thought, "Hey this is so cool! look what it did with this narrow set of test cases. We should ship it to everyone and claim impact!" Second order effects are rarely considered, and bad actors ignored.

That's the thing. The feature is kinda cool, but it really should be done based on user input and not automatic ( or at least not default unless user explicitly opts-in ). For me it is mildly more annoying, because at work Edge is the browser and I cannot change anything in it ( mildly, because it is only an issue in principle for me; I don't browse anything non-work related on that PC ). Still, one would think my company does not want to have some stuff uploaded to a third party willy nilly.
Post reply on HN