Live data from Hacker News

The Internet Made Me Sad Today

raganwald.posterous.com

11–20 of 186 posts

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#11

So who is the author blaming? He's not blaming the end user (the one that makes those ads worth the most to both google and content sites). - Is he blaming Google for maximizing ad revenue for the content site? - Is he blaming the content sites for wanting to maximize their own revenue on page views? (or, perhaps, for being too lazy to sell ads themselves?) - Is he blaming the people who spend the money to get their…

[deleted]

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#12
When I see misplaced advertising like this, I just remember that it's not Google's fault; they didn't consciously make the decision that dinosaurs are childish/recreational fantasies that should be associated with gaming. It's the fault of dinosaur's representation today across the entire internet. Google's bots picked up that correlation mechanically, so while it's unfortunate that they propagate stereotypes like this further, it's not the root cause.

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#13
post #9

What's the alternative ? Having content locked behind a pay-wall so even less people can access it ? Running ads which are more relevant but don't generate enough revenue to make the site viable in the long term ? Not having the content at all ?

How do you feel about the fact that certain farmers will starve if they can’t grow coca or poppies as a cash crop?

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#14
The text ad is the only one served on that page by Google, if you go and look at the actual page the rest are served by AdBlade or Tribal Fusion. I feel like it's pretty misleading to complain about those ads as if they all came from the same company.

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#17

The text ad is the only one served on that page by Google, if you go and look at the actual page the rest are served by AdBlade or Tribal Fusion. I feel like it's pretty misleading to complain about those ads as if they all came from the same company.

The article is quite clear on the fact that the other ads need not be coming from Google.

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#18
Maybe google knows that you are personally interested in social games? Or perhaps they're just trying to reach people who are on the internet right now.

Anyway, point is, the page isn't the only signal used for ad targeting; you (and your search history) are another, as is the current time. As well as a variety of other things, I'm sure (I have no direct knowledge of google's ad targeting).

I visited the page myself, and got an ad for the galaxy nexus.

I do agree that the placement of the ad, which makes it look like part of the content, is pretty crummy. As are the ads about e-cigarettes and penny stocks and car insurance.

Re: The Internet Made Me Sad Today

#19
post #8
post #5

Install AdBlock Plus. Solved. Not that big of a deal, huh?

Yeah, except that I'm fairly sure that a large percentage of web users don't even know their browser might support plugins, let alone that AdBlock exists.

Exactly. And those same users are the most likely to not be able to distinguish a targeted ad from actual content. You can say "this isn't a problem because it doesn't affect me". It's still a deceptive, slimey business practice that effectively tricks a certain percentage of people. But that's what makes a buck.

I'm not necessarily blaming any one company, profit would have inevitably led to this. I just agree with the author that this IS sad.

Post reply on HN