Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

news.ycombinator.com

141–148 of 148 posts

Re: Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

#141
I hope so.

I love the variety of content on Reddit. But many of the subreddits are so toxic and fully of cry-bullies that it's nearly intolerable. I can't wait for the next generation of Reddit to come along, one that will welcome more participation from civil-minded people. (Kudos to Hacker News for somehow achieving that, btw.)

Re: Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

#142

I am. I've been working on it for 3.5 years. It's open source and it's called Comment Castles [0]. I am currently in the process of changing the name to Comment Castles, the main instance is currently at the old name [1]. All the features work with front-end JavaScript turned off. I am currently wrapping up the OAuth 2 server implementation so that we can have third party apps (no API fees!). After I wrap up some rem…

ok... I have to ask about the old name. It really sounds like it should be chock full of NSFW images. Is there some other way to read it?

Re: Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How exactly is Reddit a "porn filled shit hole"? I don't see any porn in the vast majority of subreddits. Nobody forces you to visit the rest, and they are typically even marked adult-only. Besides, are porn and racism really the only questionable things in social media? What about extreme violence, videos where real people get shot or blown up? Somehow messed up American society thinks that violence is quite okay th…

> How exactly is Reddit a "porn filled shit hole"? I don't see any porn in the vast majority of subreddits. Nobody forces you to visit the rest, and they are typically even marked adult-only. My bad, I should have said "reddit is a porn spammer filled shit hole" on top of really being a "porn filled shit hole" /s The fact that you feign being oblivious to all the CSAM, depraved porn and revenge porn hosted on reddit…

> feign being oblivious to all the CSAM, depraved porn and revenge porn hosted on reddit

And that is the point where you out yourself as a troll.

Re: Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

#146

Communities.win exists, but they allow free speech that would get people instantly banned from HN.

The racism is horrendous

Everything is racist in today's world. You cannot hold a decent discussion of anything even remotely dealing with race. I have been kicked off 8 different subs for 'hate speech'.

Moderation on many sites starts with the question "Is this person conservative" If the answer is yes, literally anything he posts is 'hate speech' and he is banned. Some mods look up the poster's past posts I believe and ban people based on that. There seems to be an effort on Reddit not to ban 'hate speech' but to stomp conservative minded people into the ground.

Have rules, certainly. But who will honestly apply those rules without bias? That is Reddit's problem in many cases. There are lots of good reddits with intelligent discussions going on. Just have to look for them and not post anything, even if it adds to the discussion.

Re: Ask HN: Anyone Building a Competitor to Reddit?

#147

I am. I've been working on it for 3.5 years. It's open source and it's called Comment Castles [0]. I am currently in the process of changing the name to Comment Castles, the main instance is currently at the old name [1]. All the features work with front-end JavaScript turned off. I am currently wrapping up the OAuth 2 server implementation so that we can have third party apps (no API fees!). After I wrap up some rem…

ok... I have to ask about the old name. It really sounds like it should be chock full of NSFW images. Is there some other way to read it?

It was simply a poor name choice by me, didn't realize peaches meant butt (lol). Not to worry though, I will launch the new site/name ASAP.
Post reply on HN