Live data from Hacker News

Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

eff.org

61–70 of 162 posts

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#61
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've just done so, and I intend on keeping Web History turned off. I simply do not derive enough benefit from having this data around for myself (when's the last time you benefited from Web History), and unlike other permanent data such as G+ posts, comments etc I do not self-censor searches that I would like to conduct, so I find it very plausible that someone with more processing power than me could find out more a…

I was just about to and then realised that I had turned it off a while ago. The fact that I had completely forgotten it shows that I don't need this data. However, it's also not something I'm hugely concerned about; as others have said the main danger is from some unscrupulous individual gaining access to your account. In terms of Google having access to my data, I would imagine my data will never be seen by human ey…

You don't need it, but it makes search matching more efficient for the people that have it on.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#63
I'm not convinced this works as it should. I turned of history a while back and have since repeated "remove all history". But I still get these ads related to searches and email that is too obscure to be co-incidence - e.g. Lately I get shown ads (sometimes multiple times daily) for "Foreign SIM cards" as I googled this about a month ago. Especially on Youtube. Anyone else notice this who has turned off their web history?

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, I haven't seen a load of claims about how this is "insane" or "horrible" within the context of this article. It just provides a useful instruction as to how those that wish to opt-out, may do so. It's fine that you don't see how this matters but it does matter to some and having the choice and understanding how to exercise that choice is essential.

Apologies. I wasn't referring to this article in particular, but the hype in general over Google's changing privacy policies.

Downvotes for apologizing? Really?

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, I haven't seen a load of claims about how this is "insane" or "horrible" within the context of this article. It just provides a useful instruction as to how those that wish to opt-out, may do so. It's fine that you don't see how this matters but it does matter to some and having the choice and understanding how to exercise that choice is essential.

Apologies. I wasn't referring to this article in particular, but the hype in general over Google's changing privacy policies.

Downvotes for apologizing? Really?

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#67
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

http://www.googlesharing.net/

It sounds good in concept, but I'm concerned that somebody searching for child pornography or similar could be associated with myself. I have the same fear of running a TOR exit node.

It gives you plausible deniability, which is the point. Nobody can prove you really did those searches (though you can't prove the converse either).

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#68
post #9
post #6

I'm confused. What does this actually mean? "You can delete information from Web History using the remove feature, and it will be removed from the service. However, as is common practice in the industry, and as outlined in the Google Privacy Policy, Google maintains a separate logs system for auditing purposes and to help us improve the quality of our services for users." So.... why would I delete this information if…

I see two reasons why one might want to do it: 1) If someone breaks into your account, that person can steal all your search history. This is why I disabled search history recording a long time ago. 2) It was uncovered that Google passess some of its data about users to third parties, especially ads agencies. Now, with the new policy, you can't be sure that search data leakage will not occur. Moreover, ads agencies u…

"It was uncovered that Google passess some of its data about users to third parties, especially ads agencies." Can you provide a source to back this statement? (I am not challenging you, just interested to learn about this)

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#69

I'm not convinced this works as it should. I turned of history a while back and have since repeated "remove all history". But I still get these ads related to searches and email that is too obscure to be co-incidence - e.g. Lately I get shown ads (sometimes multiple times daily) for "Foreign SIM cards" as I googled this about a month ago. Especially on Youtube. Anyone else notice this who has turned off their web his…

Perhaps they removed the web history itself, but kept whatever inferences they made, which are associated with your Google account. Which is about as bad as keeping the history, but it's probably completely separate system, which just uses the history for training purposes.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#70
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds good in concept, but I'm concerned that somebody searching for child pornography or similar could be associated with myself. I have the same fear of running a TOR exit node.

It gives you plausible deniability, which is the point. Nobody can prove you really did those searches (though you can't prove the converse either).

[deleted]
Post reply on HN