Live data from Hacker News

How to make fancy road trip maps with R and OpenStreetMap

andrewheiss.com

1–10 of 102 posts

Re: How to make fancy road trip maps with R and OpenStreetMap

#5
Why is there such a movement for making maps with R? The python ecosystem has more and better packages for making maps already. Notwithstanding that there are indeed some nice results, this new R toolchain movement towards maps feels like a waste of open source energy to me.

Re: How to make fancy road trip maps with R and OpenStreetMap

#7

Why is there such a movement for making maps with R? The python ecosystem has more and better packages for making maps already. Notwithstanding that there are indeed some nice results, this new R toolchain movement towards maps feels like a waste of open source energy to me.

Can we, I don't know, let people enjoy programming languages they like without calling it a waste?

Re: How to make fancy road trip maps with R and OpenStreetMap

#9

Why is there such a movement for making maps with R? The python ecosystem has more and better packages for making maps already. Notwithstanding that there are indeed some nice results, this new R toolchain movement towards maps feels like a waste of open source energy to me.

As someone proficient with R and Python, anything data viz-wise is substantially easier to do in R/ggplot2, particularly something complicated like this post.

Most of the R packages in this post aren't that new either.

Re: How to make fancy road trip maps with R and OpenStreetMap

#10

Why is there such a movement for making maps with R? The python ecosystem has more and better packages for making maps already. Notwithstanding that there are indeed some nice results, this new R toolchain movement towards maps feels like a waste of open source energy to me.

I feel like the R ecosystem was there first; but perhaps two completely separate groups of people.

Ecologists, researchers working with geological or geospatial data use R and have been using R for a long, long time. The 'old 'standard library 'maps' is decades old by now, with maps v3 now being 8 years old. maps v2 goes back to 2003, about the time of Python 2.3?

I can't even find the sources of maps v1. https://cran.r-project.org/src/contrib/Archive/maps/ I believe that maps v1 was for R's predecessor, S, so from the late 90s, about the time Python 1.5 came out. Was anybody even using Python then?

OP's post uses the slightly fancier tidyverse-versions of these decades-old libraries. I think it's safe to say that map-making libraries are older in R than in Python.

Post reply on HN