Live data from Hacker News

Regent – Electric coastal travel

regentcraft.com

331–333 of 333 posts

Re: Regent – Electric coastal travel

#332

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My sailboat uses radar, I can see things from a good distance away. Let's say 30NM. Surely the plane will do better. But let's say it's going 180mph, or ~160kts. That's 11min from first radar contact to collision. With all that forewarning, avoiding a yacht isn't a big deal. If they can't avoid it, they can stop with 11min warning. Let's say visual only. There will be restrictions on visibility for visual flight rule…

Just for others here, this is very misleading: 1) Sailboats (even moderately sized ones) often do not show on radar at all. 2) 30nm is probably way too optimistic, at a height of 50ft your line of sight is only about 8-9nm. Radar is LOS. 3) 11m is a terrifyingly short time, even if this was all correct 4) you can't identify things based on radar alone, and there's no way you can make out what something is even at 5nm…

> 11m is a terrifyingly short time, even if this was all correct

Is it? How much warning do you get when a car brakes in front of you on the highway?

In 11m you could write a report on how to avoid the collision prior to actually performing the maneuver

Re: Regent – Electric coastal travel

#333

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just for others here, this is very misleading: 1) Sailboats (even moderately sized ones) often do not show on radar at all. 2) 30nm is probably way too optimistic, at a height of 50ft your line of sight is only about 8-9nm. Radar is LOS. 3) 11m is a terrifyingly short time, even if this was all correct 4) you can't identify things based on radar alone, and there's no way you can make out what something is even at 5nm…

> 11m is a terrifyingly short time, even if this was all correct Is it? How much warning do you get when a car brakes in front of you on the highway? In 11m you could write a report on how to avoid the collision prior to actually performing the maneuver

Cars have lanes etc.. it's very different on the water. Hard to tell often if someone is going to hit you or not. Distances are nearly impossible to judge.
Post reply on HN