Live data from Hacker News

Update on Sharing

about.netflix.com

11–20 of 325 posts

Re: Update on Sharing

#11

So if they are allowing you to use on devices and networks outside of your home or ones you don't normally use, how are they identifying unique individuals or "households?"

The idea that was floated was that they identify a device that defines the household (e.g. a TV), for example based on being always on the same SSID, or being on a wired connection, or the IP address. Then other devices need to be in the same network as that stable device at least say once a month.

Re: Update on Sharing

#12

So if they are allowing you to use on devices and networks outside of your home or ones you don't normally use, how are they identifying unique individuals or "households?"

[deleted]

Re: Update on Sharing

#13
Honestly, I wouldn't have minded something like "buy an extra member" if it were introduced years ago. Introducing it now just seems to be a trigger to re-evaluate "is Netflix really worth that much" at a time their content selection doesn't look as amazing as it once did. I'm coming from a background of having recently cancelled my account though, and may be biased in thinking along those lines as a result.

Overall it'll be interesting to see how much impact this actually has or doesn't have for subscription volume. My guess is maybe not as much as the usual uproared comments would have you think.

Re: Update on Sharing

#14
This is a US rollout of a restriction that they have already deployed in Latin America and Spain among other countries [1], that they restrict your account to a single household. So, no password sharing with friends.

I am honestly surprised they keep pushing this. In Spain, Netflix is among the most expensive options, and the most expensive if you consider the features you get (the 7,99 euro option just gives you HD, not full HD, and only one concurrent device); and the content quality has been going downhill and has lost a lot of staple shows. Most people I know that had Netflix just canceled their subscription once the deadline hit, because the price for extra members is ridiculous (basically a full subscription cost) and without password sharing it's not worth it compared to the other options.

I guess that the move didn't have as much effect as people thought it did, and that's why they're continuing the rollout.

1: https://about.netflix.com/en/news/update-on-sharing-may-us

Re: Update on Sharing

#15
So in which countries have they rolled out this policy so far? I remember enough from some prior announcement to know that the US is not the first or only such country, and that it's not yet worldwide, but I don't remember where else it's in place.

Re: Update on Sharing

#16
post #4

Here's an update: I'm canceling my account. The amount of entertainment I and the three people I share with get out of Netflix isn't worth the 4x cost increase. Maybe the other guys will get accounts, I don't know. I'm sure for some people it's worth it.

Yup. Especially given their propensity to cancel shows on a whim.

Re: Update on Sharing

#17
post #9

I'm probably in the minority, but I wish Netflix offered a profile transfer function that allowed me to transfer my profile to another existing account.

They do. It's mentioned in the link.

The link mentions a profile transfer to a new membership, not to another existing membership.

Re: Update on Sharing

#18
In Canada, I had the full pickle 4K account and my girls in another city used my account. When the new rules kicked in, I cut my plan and pay half now. And I'll cancel it this month. The service is just not worth it with all the crappy content.

Re: Update on Sharing

#19
post #11

So if they are allowing you to use on devices and networks outside of your home or ones you don't normally use, how are they identifying unique individuals or "households?"

The idea that was floated was that they identify a device that defines the household (e.g. a TV), for example based on being always on the same SSID, or being on a wired connection, or the IP address. Then other devices need to be in the same network as that stable device at least say once a month.

Can I have my other households VPN to my local network to bypass this?

Re: Update on Sharing

#20

I'm probably in the minority, but I wish Netflix offered a profile transfer function that allowed me to transfer my profile to another existing account.

I really like the Spotify model, where everyone just has their own account. Then a Family Plan owner invites others to join the plan via their email address.
Post reply on HN