Live data from Hacker News

Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

github.com

161–170 of 232 posts

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#161
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

aws s3 sync + image snapshot

all that costs time :-/ When you're finished working, you got to wait for the syncs to finish (or I guess run them all the time?). For home computer setups, you can simply walk away when you need a break.

Dont forget you can play computer games on it too!

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#162

This looks huge. Anyone know how this compares with Whisper in terms of quality and speed?

according to their blog post[1], MMS achieves ~half the error rate on words, while supporting 11x more languages. pretty impressive. [1] https://ai.facebook.com/blog/multilingual-model-speech-recog...

lack of labels on graph axes should be a crime

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#163
post #126
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You "spend hours messing around" with everything you don't know or understand at first. One could say the same about writing the software itself. At its core Dockerfiles are just shell scripts with worse syntax, so it's not really that much more to learn. Once you get it done once, you don't have to screw around with it anymore, and you have it on any box you want in seconds. In either case you have to spend hours sc…

I'm having trouble imagining what data I would store in a database as opposed to a filesystem if my goal is to experiment with large models like Stable Diffusion.

I would take GP's kind of dogmatic jibber jabber with a grain of salt. There is an unspoken and timeless elegance to the simplicity of running a program from a folder with files as state

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#164
post #124
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can finetune whisper, stable diffusion, and LLM up to about 15B parameters with 24GB VRAM. Which leads you to what hardware to get. Best bang for the $ right now is definitely a used 3090 at ~$700. If you want more than 24GB vram just rent the hardware as it will be cheaper. If you're not willing to drop $700 don't buy anything just rent. I have had decent luck with vast.ai

There is the world of used Nvidia Teslas, like the M40. Very cheap, but some assembly required.

What do you mean by assembly needed? I looked them up and they look like normal gfx cards. Am I missing something?

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#165
post #159

Why is Meta open sourcing their AI work like this? Is it because they don't have a great reputation even among tech companies?

Meta has had a culture of open source, even before their reputation got bad (React, RocksDB, Thrift, folly, etc). They open source a lot of their AI models (instead of just source) because they don't have an enterprise cloud to sell these things, unlike Amazon/Google/Microsoft's offerings (which all offer speech transcription and text to speech as services).

This is an underrated point for Meta. They are good at opensourcing.

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#166
post #124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is the world of used Nvidia Teslas, like the M40. Very cheap, but some assembly required.

What is their advantages?

apparently there are a group of folks finetuning with these cards.

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wonder what the performance is on English specifically. Edit: Just checked the paper, it seems to be worse[1][2] but feel free to correct me. I feel like they should've just taken the Whipser architecture, scaled it, and scaled the dataset as they did. [1] Page: https://i.imgur.com/bq15Tno.png [2] Paper: https://scontent.fcai19-5.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t39.8562-6/3488279...

It's worse on English and a lot of other common languages (see Appendix C of the paper). It does better on less common languages like Latvian or Tajik, though.

Which implies, Whisper just hasn't focused on those languages? Seems disingenuous to make the claim that the error rate has halved, when it's worse in the apex language

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#168
post #124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is the world of used Nvidia Teslas, like the M40. Very cheap, but some assembly required.

What do you mean by assembly needed? I looked them up and they look like normal gfx cards. Am I missing something?

They're datacenter GPUs so you need special power supplies and an adapter to connect it to a regular motherboard.

Re: Meta AI announces Massive Multilingual Speech code, models for 1000+ languages

#170
post #54

Imagine if we used these types of models for like 500 years and it locked their vocabulary in time, disallowing any further language blending; then somehow the servers turned off and nobody could communicate across language barriers anymore. Someone should write that down in some sort of short-story involving a really tall structure.

Imagine if we used them everyday for 500 years but tune all the languages to be ever so slightly similar each day until there is one language.
Post reply on HN