Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

puzzlemoji.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

71–79 of 79 posts

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#71

Post by nom »

sunnyba wrote: post #25
nom wrote: post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Got superbad with (police officer, clinking beer mugs, girl) Haven't seen the movie, I skimmed the plot for a second and picked what stood out. Didn't expect it to work, i wanted to input a lot more. No idea how there aren't any other movies that match better. Feels like the search space doesn't contain all movies.

nice! I don't limit the search space in the system prompt to GPT, though each daily puzzle is using popular movies. I think for the top ~100 movies it'll probably do a fine job. If this game goes on for a full year though, I imagine it's going to really struggle unless the movie is about something really unique.

Ah, I see! You of course pick puzzles from the most popular movies first, and GPT of course lands on the most popular ones too. Interesting dynamic, makes it much easier in the beginning. I was wondering how it can work so well with only three emojis.

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#73

Post by PufPufPuf »

sunnyba wrote: post #67

Some technical notes. Even for something like this, the OpenAI API can be expensive - there's a few decisions I made that keep costs lower. 1. I cache guesses and responses in Redis when I first see them, so I don't need to hit the API for duplicate guesses (which are common when lots of people are guessing the same movies). 2. Emoji order doesn't matter (I apply a sorting to guesses). 3. Guesses are not path depende…

Would it be possible to make past days replayable, like https://twofergoofer.com/ does?

Also, do you have stats of the guesses? Would be interesting to see how many people managed to guess correctly within 1/2/3 attempts, and what were the most common emoji combinations for both correct and incorrect guesses.

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#74

Post by 16bitvoid »

sunnyba wrote: post #58
ioseph wrote: post #54

I failed on the dark knight because chatgpt guessed Batman: the dark knight. Really cool game though!

Ah that's annoying! I've swapped it out -- thanks for catching it.

For The Wolf of Wall Street, the following result using wolf + money bag + roadway was considered wrong:

> The guess is: The Wolf of Wall Street Reason: The movie is about the rise and fall of Jordan Belfort, a stockbroker who defrauded investors out of hundreds of millions of dollars, earning him a lot of money in the process. The road emoji may represent the stock market, which is a symbol of the financial industry. Additionally, the wolf emoji can be seen as a reference to the word "wolf" in the title of the movie, while the emoji...

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#75

Post by sunnyba »

16bitvoid wrote: post #74
sunnyba wrote: post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah that's annoying! I've swapped it out -- thanks for catching it.

For The Wolf of Wall Street, the following result using wolf + money bag + roadway was considered wrong: > The guess is: The Wolf of Wall Street Reason: The movie is about the rise and fall of Jordan Belfort, a stockbroker who defrauded investors out of hundreds of millions of dollars, earning him a lot of money in the process. The road emoji may represent the stock market, which is a symbol of the financial industry…

interesting, thanks for flagging -- this looks to be a parsing issue when ChatGPT occasionally returns guesses in a format different than the one instructed to. I'll give this some more thought on how to fix...

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#76

Post by sunnyba »

PufPufPuf wrote: post #73
sunnyba wrote: post #67

Some technical notes. Even for something like this, the OpenAI API can be expensive - there's a few decisions I made that keep costs lower. 1. I cache guesses and responses in Redis when I first see them, so I don't need to hit the API for duplicate guesses (which are common when lots of people are guessing the same movies). 2. Emoji order doesn't matter (I apply a sorting to guesses). 3. Guesses are not path depende…

Would it be possible to make past days replayable, like https://twofergoofer.com/ does? Also, do you have stats of the guesses? Would be interesting to see how many people managed to guess correctly within 1/2/3 attempts, and what were the most common emoji combinations for both correct and incorrect guesses.

Both great ideas. I'll look at the calendar-like feature.

Stats would be cool, I don't currently collect them but will think about adding them. Thanks!

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#77

Post by sunnyba »

yreg wrote: post #72

It would be cool if we could copy the game recap along with our unsuccessful attempts (and their results). We are sending each other reports like these with our friends: https://i.imgur.com/P30a4FF.png

this is a great idea, let me see if I can make that easier!

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#78

Post by sunnyba »

yreg wrote: post #72

It would be cool if we could copy the game recap along with our unsuccessful attempts (and their results). We are sending each other reports like these with our friends: https://i.imgur.com/P30a4FF.png

Implemented a history button after completing the game that should make it easier for you to share!

Re: Show HN: PuzzleMoji, a daily emoji pictionary challenge against ChatGPT

#79

Post by yreg »

sunnyba wrote: post #78
yreg wrote: post #72

It would be cool if we could copy the game recap along with our unsuccessful attempts (and their results). We are sending each other reports like these with our friends: https://i.imgur.com/P30a4FF.png

Implemented a history button after completing the game that should make it easier for you to share!

Neat! I like your game, hope the API doesn't cost you too much.
Post reply on HN