Live data from Hacker News

A rant on bus stops

walkingtheworld.substack.com

11–20 of 190 posts

Re: A rant on bus stops

#11
post #5

We used to have rent subsidies, mental hospitals, all night movie theaters. All gone.

I live in an apartment with neighbors who are subsidized, there’s a psychiatric hospital in every major city, and all night movie theaters would exist if there was a market for them. If you think there’s a market and money to be made - start your own

Re: A rant on bus stops

#13
post #8

Something I’ve always noticed across the US political landscape: people really don’t like spending money to directly help people (mental health care, institutions, public housing, addiction recovery programs) but are fine with wasting money in weird ways like having this non profit travel the world to learn how to put up a sun shade. It’s like the thing Americans dislike isn’t spending the money but the idea of helpi…

As the country gets more heterogeneous, people will want less to help others, as they know they won't be helping their own.

Re: A rant on bus stops

#14
Some points in the article are hit and miss, but mostly correct.

For example, Istanbul is flourishing because it's the Turkish capital, so it necessarily is the most dense and rich city in the country. The high trust is a positive factor, but plenty of more rural cities and towns in Turkey look quite dumpy (perhaps not as bad a Philly, though)

The pictures don't really support that either. They depict a fairly average state of urban infrastructure, nothing particularly inviting or welcoming. The people look friendly though, as the culture actively discourages drug use and vice.

Re: A rant on bus stops

#15
>A removal of resources for the majority, because of concerns over “misuse” of less than one percent of residents.

Ah yes, the American way. The same justification I have heard as to why bathroom stalls need to have gaps and be unpleasant, "What if someone were to have sex and/or do drugs in there?!" Let them do it, just let me have a minor moment of privacy while I am pooping.

Re: A rant on bus stops

#17
The TL;DR here is that California has a housing crisis, which caused homelessness, which caused people to look into a bus stop design which doesn’t serve as a proper shelter.

Here’s a data-driven argument that homelessness is a problem with lack of homes, more so than mental health or drugs or whatever else: https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/everything-you-think-you-know-...

Fixing housing will have a lot of great downstream effects.

Re: A rant on bus stops

#18
post #8

Something I’ve always noticed across the US political landscape: people really don’t like spending money to directly help people (mental health care, institutions, public housing, addiction recovery programs) but are fine with wasting money in weird ways like having this non profit travel the world to learn how to put up a sun shade. It’s like the thing Americans dislike isn’t spending the money but the idea of helpi…

Even for the pettiest shit.

https://daily.jstor.org/when-cities-closed-pools-to-avoid-in...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palmer_v._Thompson

Re: A rant on bus stops

#19

My write-up on the recent LA bus stop fiasco

Thanks for writing this, I like the trust/regulation mental model. I can also use it to explain my experiences as a European immigrant in the US. One of the biggest differences I feel is how belligerent and litigious American society is. Would you say this is one of the causes of this outcome? (i.e. when people are worried about being sued, they'd do the smallest and safest thing possible).

Anyway it'd be great to read more posts on this topic, and see examples of cultures you consider low trust/low regulation.

Re: A rant on bus stops

#20
post #5

We used to have rent subsidies, mental hospitals, all night movie theaters. All gone.

I live in an apartment with neighbors who are subsidized, there’s a psychiatric hospital in every major city, and all night movie theaters would exist if there was a market for them. If you think there’s a market and money to be made - start your own

> If you think there’s a market and money to be made - start your own

I'm genuinely unsure if this is a parody of the American Way here. "There's no problem here, but if there was, the free market will solve it!"

Post reply on HN