Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

github.com

131–140 of 141 posts

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#132
> I've always thought the ESP BOX[0] hardware is cool. I finally got around to starting a project to use the ESP BOX hardware

Is it actually for sale anywhere? Every single store I could find was sold out, and I checked within 5 minutes of this hitting the home page.

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#133
post #94

Perhaps I am missing something obvious. Where can I buy an ESP-BOX? The github makes no mention. I can't find any on aliexpress or amazon.

You can't. They were sold out everywhere the moment this article hit hackernews.

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Home Assistant would be a lot more convincing if every upgrade did not completely break my install. Flashed this on ESP I had laying around and did NOT have to upgrade HA (which would have made me not try the project).

HA would be a lot more convincing if basic layout itself alongside config wasn't YAML hell. Every time I want to create some new layout or add something new to my home screen, I dread it. I hate using it. Yet, I have no viable OSS alternatives.

openHAB is very nice and completely OSS.

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#136

Earlier quoted context omitted.

HA would be a lot more convincing if basic layout itself alongside config wasn't YAML hell. Every time I want to create some new layout or add something new to my home screen, I dread it. I hate using it. Yet, I have no viable OSS alternatives.

openHAB is very nice and completely OSS.

Hm, I forgot about openHAB. Does it have comparable number of integrations as HA does?

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#137
post #69

Ordered a box, can't wait to try this out! I've really been looking for something like this. My dream would be to have an LLM "agent" running locally, that knows who I am, etc, that can also double as a smart assistant for HA.

That's might closer than you think I guess. The thing is that the new Assist pipeline is fully customisable and can use other models as well. They already have a ChatGPT integration which does not able to control entities in HA but at least you can have a conversation with ChatGPT in speach trough HA.

So if you spin up somehow an LLM model locally and connect create a HA Assist pipeline with it and than you use Willow(s future release which should be able to leverage the new Assist featre) as a phisical interface than you are golden.

It may be hard or impossible today but I think within months HA and Willow will mature into a state where tha bigges problem will be the training and runing a good enough LLM model locally. But I bet a good amount of hackers are already hard working on that part anyway.

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#138

I never really considered getting a home assistant doodad because of the privacy issues around them. This sounds like a cool project

What kind of privacz issues are you reffering to? Legit qustion btw, I'm not aware of any but would like to read about it.

Re: Show HN: Willow – Open-source privacy-focused voice assistant hardware

#140
post #69

Ordered a box, can't wait to try this out! I've really been looking for something like this. My dream would be to have an LLM "agent" running locally, that knows who I am, etc, that can also double as a smart assistant for HA.

That's might closer than you think I guess. The thing is that the new Assist pipeline is fully customisable and can use other models as well. They already have a ChatGPT integration which does not able to control entities in HA but at least you can have a conversation with ChatGPT in speach trough HA. So if you spin up somehow an LLM model locally and connect create a HA Assist pipeline with it and than you use Willo…

Starting with this post:

https://community.home-assistant.io/t/using-gpt3-and-shorcut...

I've been trying to adapt it to an offline LLM model, probably a LLaMA-like one using the llm package for Rust, or a ggml-based C implementation like llama.c.

It could even be fine-tuned or trained to perform better and always output only the json.

This could be a good fit with open sourced tovera when that is released.

I like the idea of supporting natural language commands that feel more natural and don't have to follow a specific syntax.

It can also process general LLM requests, possibly using a third-party LLM like Bard for more up to date responses.

Post reply on HN