Live data from Hacker News

Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

euractiv.com

1–10 of 55 posts

Re: Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

#6
post #3

It's sad that "think of the children" is still argument that works on some dumbasses.

I tend to ignore "think of the children" pleas from people who outsource the education and supervision of their children to the state or other "non-parent providers."

Re: Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

#7
post #2

Do any of the EU countries have a legal history of having the right to privacy enshrined in law and custom?

Not that I'm aware of, although East Germany still has Stasi in living memory, which gives mass surveillance a tangibley sour aftertaste.

Re: Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

#8
post #2

Do any of the EU countries have a legal history of having the right to privacy enshrined in law and custom?

You might be interested in Aritcle 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_8_of_the_European_Conv...). It was recently used to declare the UK's mass surveillance unlawful (https://dpglaw.co.uk/european-court-of-human-rights-declares...)

Re: Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

#9
post #4

What could possibly go wrong?

> What could possibly go wrong?

This could have normally be considered an idle comment.

Unfortunately, in today's world it has become part of a rule: "when any trend emerges, ask yourself: what could possibly go wrong".

Re: Majority of EU countries support scanning of audio communications

#10
This is a terrible headline. It gives impression that the majority of electorate supports this. Or maybe majority of their respective parliaments does.

But it's just the executive branch of the EU itself- "A majority of the EU Council of Ministers". More or less, each government selects a minister to represent them in this council.

The article should really be reporting on how this bill is progressing. I am no legal expert, but I believe the EU parliament, which is actually elected, could reject it. I am not sure what happens if it is found unconstitutional in some of the countries concerned.

Post reply on HN