Live data from Hacker News

Stories We’ve Seen Too Often

strangehorizons.com

1–10 of 104 posts

Re: Stories We’ve Seen Too Often

#2
If you liked this list, you may also find the Turkey City Lexicon interesting:

https://www.sfwa.org/2009/06/18/turkey-city-lexicon-a-primer...

It's also aimed directly at aspiring science fiction writers, but it's been referenced enough times on Charles Stross's blog (and other SF venues) that some of its terms have entered my vocabulary and that of other SF readers I know.

EDIT: this list does contain the story type lifefeed mentions in a sibling content.

- Adam and Eve Story

Nauseatingly common subset of the “Shaggy God Story” in which a terrible apocalypse, spaceship crash, etc., leaves two survivors, man and woman, who turn out to be Adam and Eve, parents of the human race!!

Re: Stories We’ve Seen Too Often

#3
My old least-favorite-trope isn't on here, maybe writers have finally stopped writing it.

> (Somehow, a man and a women end up alone on a planet. This is the last dialog.)

> Man: I never caught your name.

> Women: I'm Eve.

> Man: Hi Eve, I'm Adam.

Re: Stories We’ve Seen Too Often

#7
post #5

The amusing thing is how many of the items on their list bring to mind a great short story, or a great novel, or movie. Point being that many of them CAN be good, but usually aren't.

> is how many of the items on their list bring to mind a great short story

That may be how so many of these ended up on this list: someone wrote a great story with an original premise, and lots of other people are like "Oh, I like that idea, I'll write my own story using a similar idea", and then editors get sick of receiving them.

Re: Stories We’ve Seen Too Often

#10
post #3

My old least-favorite-trope isn't on here, maybe writers have finally stopped writing it. > (Somehow, a man and a women end up alone on a planet. This is the last dialog.) > Man: I never caught your name. > Women: I'm Eve. > Man: Hi Eve, I'm Adam.

Wow. Mind blown! /s
Post reply on HN