Live data from Hacker News

Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

theguardian.com

51–60 of 239 posts

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#51
post #19
post #3

They look cool and I would love to be able to buy one but the sustainability tax seems too high to be a successful product to me.

WH-1000XM5 => $400 Bose QC45 => $279 Fairbuds XL => 249€ ($272 if I convert right now) It's cheaper than two of the most popular headphones, how is there a "too high sustainability tax" ?!?

But what's the sound quality like? If they're in the price range of $300-400 premium headphones, but perform like $100 headphones, that's still a "tax".

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#52
I certainly appreciate this idea. My WH-1000XM4s developed an issue where the NC has a feedback loop that sends a deafening shriek as soon as you place them on your ears and it lasts until you turn off the NC. I have to go through this (quite embarrassing in public) ordeal every time I turn them on. I'd just upgrade if they weren't so absurdly expensive in the first place.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#54
I love this concept! When I got tired of replacing headphones in the past I got some beyerdynamic dt770 modded by jfunk.org. They are repairable and durable. Though they are not natively bluetooth, can use a short cable + qudelix 5k to make them wireless. No noise cancelling.

Would be very nice to have durable / repairable noise cancelling headphones. These headphones from fairbuds look great overall, but I'm skeptical of the durability of the hinges.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#55

I’ve got a set of 6 year old $60 taotronics headphones that I just replaced the earpads on. Took 5 minutes and they use generic earpads available from AE or Amazon. The battery is soldered in, but is a generic lipo foil pouch accesible behind a screwed together earcup so I won’t need to find a specific form factor or break any glued together stuff to get at it. I don’t see this product as more “repairable” than other…

The classic first reply to the Show HN: Dropbox thread lives on in this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29178442

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#56
post #47

I used to swear by V-Moda for portable headphones. They were highly repairable (you could replace the pads, band, cables, and even the driver if you really wanted). That was, until their Bluetooth enabled line. It had no parts available, and even at that was non trivial to fix with 3rd party parts. These days, I love my beyerdynamic headphones. I've replaced the drivers, cables, pads, etc over their 10 year life. Onl…

Same path for me, I like the v-moda headphones a lot, but the hinge mechanism is way too fragile, and the charge port broke, so the bluetooth pair was my last v-moda headphone. I also switched to beyerdynamic and have been very happy with them. Only downside of this durability is that they are not foldable - would be great to have headphones with a high durability folding mechanism

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#57
post #25
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

WH-1000XM5 => $400 Bose QC45 => $279 Fairbuds XL => 249€ ($272 if I convert right now) It's cheaper than two of the most popular headphones, how is there a "too high sustainability tax" ?!?

I can really recommend the WH-1000XM5 btw. They are quite light and work surprisingly well even with iDevices. I tried to call my dad while I mowed the lawn (electric mower, but pretty loud one) and he understood me well. Audio pass through sounds like the real thing, I’d just like to be able to turn it louder.

That's a change then because the WH-1000XM3 microphone is really crap.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#59
post #37

I’ve got a set of 6 year old $60 taotronics headphones that I just replaced the earpads on. Took 5 minutes and they use generic earpads available from AE or Amazon. The battery is soldered in, but is a generic lipo foil pouch accesible behind a screwed together earcup so I won’t need to find a specific form factor or break any glued together stuff to get at it. I don’t see this product as more “repairable” than other…

Do you think Bose actually repair anything? I always assumed they just replace it and recycle/destroy the old one.

I would assume they act similarly to Apple: quickly send you a refurbished replacement, and then go refurbish the one you sent in. For the small percentage of devices they receive that aren't able to be refurbished, they recycle/destroy.

Re: Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> And most over-ear headphones are already pretty fixable. Most brands provide spare parts for like 20 years. Please, point me to the bluetooth/wireless noise-cancelling over-ear headphones that are pretty fixable at a level comparable to that of the Fairbuds here? Note, it must meat ALL the criteria I listed. Missing anything makes answer worthless. e.g. If it offers everything except for bluetooth or noise-cancelli…

Bose has repair service. It isn't self-service, so it depends if your goal is throwing less shit away, or being able to service your own devices.

I'm familiar with Bose's repair service. This is not the same as Fairbuds, and does not meet the minimum requirements stipulated.
Post reply on HN