Live data from Hacker News

Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

futurism.com

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#11
post #4

Noam Chomsky is fascinating to read if you're a 14 year old anarcho socialist like I was. His self-contradictory and confused opinions about the future highlight the fact that he's basically an ancient malcontent who's eked out his living trying to form an unsuccessful apparatus to do exactly what he claims to despise, i.e. lay out thought patterns for a group of followers who in his case never seem to materialize an…

What generation of ChatGPT will generate ad hominem responses like this?

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#12
post #2

"The concept that these AIs will take over the world is, with that absolute lack of human-like understanding of how the world works, impossible." Noam Chomsky

Hmm. Thinking not like a human would help it avoid and exploit the mental traps humans have. We might not even know they've taken over.

It will have different taps, biases, errors. That much is already apparent.

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#13
post #3

And what does Noam think a human does from the moment his eyes open and the amniotic fluid is drained from his ears? Humans gorge on hundreds of terabytes of data until they reach around puberty. Oh. But it's squishy chemical signals, not gold scratchings on glass. Oh well that's different.

Every parent knows that human children learn to understand language and speak well before they’ve had time to get exposed to “hundreds of terabytes” of meaningful data. This obvious fact informs Chomsky’s work on language acquisition, which led him to posit an innate language capability.

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#14
post #11
post #4

Noam Chomsky is fascinating to read if you're a 14 year old anarcho socialist like I was. His self-contradictory and confused opinions about the future highlight the fact that he's basically an ancient malcontent who's eked out his living trying to form an unsuccessful apparatus to do exactly what he claims to despise, i.e. lay out thought patterns for a group of followers who in his case never seem to materialize an…

What generation of ChatGPT will generate ad hominem responses like this?

[flagged]

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#15
post #4

Noam Chomsky is fascinating to read if you're a 14 year old anarcho socialist like I was. His self-contradictory and confused opinions about the future highlight the fact that he's basically an ancient malcontent who's eked out his living trying to form an unsuccessful apparatus to do exactly what he claims to despise, i.e. lay out thought patterns for a group of followers who in his case never seem to materialize an…

[flagged]

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#16
post #3

And what does Noam think a human does from the moment his eyes open and the amniotic fluid is drained from his ears? Humans gorge on hundreds of terabytes of data until they reach around puberty. Oh. But it's squishy chemical signals, not gold scratchings on glass. Oh well that's different.

A human experiments, predicts, learns and understands. A baby shoves everything in its mouth. It discovers how its actions affect the world, extrapolates, and experiments. It learns metaphor, learns how metaphor is useful to predict similar systems, learns the limitations of metaphor. It isn't just gorging data, it is creating data. It fills in the blanks with guesses and superstition, and maybe even uses reasoning to confirm it's speculation. A baby doesn't just regurgitate, no matter what a sleep deprived parent might think.

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#18
post #3

And what does Noam think a human does from the moment his eyes open and the amniotic fluid is drained from his ears? Humans gorge on hundreds of terabytes of data until they reach around puberty. Oh. But it's squishy chemical signals, not gold scratchings on glass. Oh well that's different.

Please don't post flamewar-style comments to HN. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#19
post #4

Noam Chomsky is fascinating to read if you're a 14 year old anarcho socialist like I was. His self-contradictory and confused opinions about the future highlight the fact that he's basically an ancient malcontent who's eked out his living trying to form an unsuccessful apparatus to do exactly what he claims to despise, i.e. lay out thought patterns for a group of followers who in his case never seem to materialize an…

this sounds like the ego of a 13 years old, with no power nor wealth.

Re: Noam Chomsky: AI isn't coming for us all, you idiots

#20
post #2

"The concept that these AIs will take over the world is, with that absolute lack of human-like understanding of how the world works, impossible." Noam Chomsky

That's not what Chomsky said. It's the author interpretation of what he said. Chomsky said: "That day may come, but its dawn is not yet breaking."
Post reply on HN