Live data from Hacker News

The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

tedgioia.substack.com

61–70 of 139 posts

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#61
post #54

bzrp is doing a concert tour now, he just played here in buenos aires a couple weeks ago, i have the t-shirt also maybe lindsey stirling counts?

> also maybe lindsey stirling counts?

She does, and was the first instrumentalist that came to mind shortly followed by Yo-Yo Ma, and various classical guitarists like Pepe Romero (I'm not sure I have a personal "favorite" per-se).

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#62
El Ten Eleven is a great instrumental band that is kind of famous in the alternative scene.

Otherwise, popular instrumentals are all techno tracks that made it into the charts. Think of Fat Boy Slim, Jus†ice or Daft Punk. I’ve seen Jus†ice live and they perform something similar to a pop/rock concert. Pretty cool.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#63
Outside of musicians, the public and mainstream just have an easier time identifying with songs that feature lyrics. Most people need to possess some rudimentary ability to play an instrument to appreciate and to look closer into individual instrumentalists.

Of course an obvious exception is classically minded listeners, but they're sadly relatively rare as well.

As a pianist, it's easy for me to rattle off the names of my favorite pianists: Fats Waller, Thelonious Monk, Keith Jarrett, Sviatoslav Richter, etc.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#64
post #60

Carbon Based Lifeforms anyone? Solar Fields? Solar Fields did soundtrack for Mirror's Edge for example. So many good composers doing electro/synth instrumentals nowadays but aren't mainstream, which might be good thing

I adore those artists, transports my mind to another place like no other music. However I can’t help but feel a little disappointed this stuff didn’t catch on more, like they should have inspired 1000 followers to invent new sub-genres by now. Maybe they did and I just don’t know where to find it.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#65

> But if you asked a random person on the street to name a clarinet player, I suspect most people couldn’t come up with one, let alone one known for their good looks. The space of potential sources for inspiration has exploded. How many people had a favourite typographer or open source software contributor or racecar driver or whatever else a hundred years ago? Music is different, sure, as others have commented, but…

Downton Abbey suggests that people 100 years ago did sometimes have favorite racecar drivers. Wikipedia completely supports this by noting several races between 1887 and 1907. The course for the Indy 500 was built in 1905.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#66
post #60

Carbon Based Lifeforms anyone? Solar Fields? Solar Fields did soundtrack for Mirror's Edge for example. So many good composers doing electro/synth instrumentals nowadays but aren't mainstream, which might be good thing

Brian Eno.

Aphex Twin, The Orb, The Irresistible force, Lane 8, Ben Boehmer, Air, Marconi Union, The Free Association, Floating Points, Gas, 2814, Nala Sinephro, Loscil, Max Richter, Banco de Gaia, Skee Mask, The Future Sound of London, Jan Jelinek, Earl Grey, Bonobo, Susumu Yokata, Stars of the Lid, Detroit Escalator Co. Global Communication, Biosphere, Max Cooper.

I recommend them all. What you got?

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True enough. I'd like to be that good at guitar but it seems like he's somewhat of a savant. I can't say I envy his social life.

Between the prolific musicians I admire the most, like Allan Holdsworth, Devin Townsend, Zappa, Pat Metheny or him - he seems to be the most troubled but interesting character. It's like if the only, coherent and 'real' way he speaks is only though the guitar - any other way you'll get some gibberish our simple minds can comprehend. Heard the other day he has health issues and hope he's better now.

Hadn't heard of the health issues, hope he's doing well. He does speak sometimes, but only through a deranged puppet named Herbie. Apparently when Guns N Roses manager was working out the details of him recording and touring with them, he would only speak to the manager through Herbie.

It's all just a character though of course. He did some recordings with the LOTR actors, Dominic Monaghan and Billy Boyd (Merry and Pippin) spoke a little bit about it on their podcast. He had a strict rule about no cameras or cell phones when meeting him, and they were able to hang out with him sans bucket and Herbie.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#68
post #17

The article asks two different questions, one about the decline of the instrumental hit and one about the decline of the instrumentalist, and doesn't go far to answer either. I'd be interested to see a breakdown of the instrumental hits throughout the decades. Is the decline simply due to classical and jazz going out of fashion? How many are soundtracks? Surely most modern instrumental hits are EDM, yes? This data-dr…

> Surely most modern instrumental hits are EDM, yes?

More so, electronica. I feel kinda bad for a music expert who isn't aware of Four Tet, Nils Frahm, Orbital, Sasha, or Tipper.

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#69
post #8

Tigran Hamasyan, Animals as Leaders, and Plini are musicians I listen to almost everyday.

I was able to get a lesson and jam session with Tosin Abasi from AAL. He's so chill and ridiculously skilled. I distracted him at one point and made him drop his lasagna on the floor... He kept saying it wasn't my fault when I apologized but it kind of was :(

Re: The decline and fall of the hit instrumental song

#70
post #33
post #7

If I had to name one it would be the violinist Vanessa Mae, but I think DJ's have replaced bands and musicians in many ways and have certainly added value to the original work, which ironically is a copyright nightmare. I wouldnt listen to this original soundtrack/song, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_N_ucgihNzk&ab_channel=fdsvf... But I'd listen to these upgrades. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4vmbSXKNJ14&ab_chan…

> If I had to name one it would be the violinist Vanessa Mae Haven't heard any of her work, have skied with her though.

What a strange way to flex.
Post reply on HN