Live data from Hacker News

Spotify-Qt

github.com

11–20 of 45 posts

Re: Spotify-Qt

#11
post #10

Spotify client has interesting history, originally it was very tight, raw win32 I believe, than iirc they transitioned to Qt and finally few iterations of the "modern" web based stack. Fun fact, the original client was developed by the same person as ScummVM, OpenTTD, and original uTorrent.

That is a fun fact. Scumm games were a big part of my childhood.

Re: Spotify-Qt

#12
post #6

Spotify web client with Adblock works best imo. No shuffle playing of albums. Or “shuffled” radio playlists. Don’t even need premium.

Walmart with reused bags and a getaway car works best IMO. Don't even need to pay.

Re: Spotify-Qt

#13
post #6

Spotify web client with Adblock works best imo. No shuffle playing of albums. Or “shuffled” radio playlists. Don’t even need premium.

Your playback quality is still (I consider, severely) restricted[1], among other features I might not be aware of. They might also start injecting ads into the audio stream soon, if they realise ad blocking methods are popular (Twitch has done this for example).

[1]: https://support.spotify.com/us/article/audio-quality

Re: Spotify-Qt

#14

on macOS, unfortunately, this was a painful experience. on startup, after setting up the Spotify app keys, the app froze while refreshing (audio) devices. it slowed down, stopped working, and had to be force quit. I was looking forward to a snazzy spotify desktop ui!

That's also my experience with the official clients after their recent big update. It constantly crashed and did all sorts of weird stuff so I uninstalled it and have started using their web client for playback + a quick and dirty GUI for their API to fill in some of the missing features like playing a playlist sorted by last added, proper random shuffle, actually stop playing when queue ends, etc.

This project looks good though, will have to try it later and see if it works any better for me.

Re: Spotify-Qt

#15
post #10

Spotify client has interesting history, originally it was very tight, raw win32 I believe, than iirc they transitioned to Qt and finally few iterations of the "modern" web based stack. Fun fact, the original client was developed by the same person as ScummVM, OpenTTD, and original uTorrent.

I think they used P2P networking to serve the audio files before they switched to centralized server hosting?

Re: Spotify-Qt

#16
post #6

Spotify web client with Adblock works best imo. No shuffle playing of albums. Or “shuffled” radio playlists. Don’t even need premium.

Your playback quality is still (I consider, severely) restricted[1], among other features I might not be aware of. They might also start injecting ads into the audio stream soon, if they realise ad blocking methods are popular (Twitch has done this for example). [1]: https://support.spotify.com/us/article/audio-quality

You can use the spotifyd lightweight daemon client to play the audio, but control it from a browser session.

Re: Spotify-Qt

#17
post #10

Spotify client has interesting history, originally it was very tight, raw win32 I believe, than iirc they transitioned to Qt and finally few iterations of the "modern" web based stack. Fun fact, the original client was developed by the same person as ScummVM, OpenTTD, and original uTorrent.

I think they used P2P networking to serve the audio files before they switched to centralized server hosting?

Indeed: https://torrentfreak.com/spotify-starts-shutting-down-its-ma...

Re: Spotify-Qt

#18
post #9
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://github.com/xou816/spot Also this one, which I've come around to quite like :) ncspot is another amazing option if you're comfortable with the terminal.

This is new to me and I'm digging it. It says something about spotify that so many people seem to want to reinvent the wheel.

Spotify is in a weird spot where we have an absolutely fantastic open-source implementation of its client api in Librespot, but exactly 0 upstream support for that api...

Re: Spotify-Qt

#19
I quit Spotify when I found out they don't have a "block song" feature on the desktop app. They have it on their mobile app, but it only applies locally to that device.

Realized I was paying for YouTube premium, which comes with Music included. Better deal IMO.

Post reply on HN