Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

news.ycombinator.com

81–90 of 112 posts

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are some good reasons to (as a matter of policy) not lie. IMHO it's better to cast around for the best possible honest framing of the issue.

It's not a lie, because this advice came from a number of HRs I interacted with for a number of years; it was suggested as their personal advice and not their professional one. One of them even codenamed it "the cloth of protection" lol.

How does an HR person saying something isn’t a lie make it not a lie? If you’re saying something happened which didn’t happen, that’s a lie. A HR person saying it’s okay might indicate that it’s not a lie people would look askance at, but it doesn’t mean it isn’t a lie.

As others have said, the correct thing to do here is to just not even list the job on the resume in the first place. No reasonable person expects every single short stint be listed on a resume. I’ve heard three and six months suggested as guidelines for the minimum lengths of jobs one should list. Anything shorter than that probably isn’t worth going into, as you’re still onboarding at that point. Also, people get sick, have sudden illnesses in the family, or otherwise can’t work for a couple months for loads of reasons.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#82

Well, that's your interpretation of what they told you. Reading between the lines there might have been a bit more going on. They told you you don't know how to use your tools. In other words that you were not being professional. Not that you are not allowed to use other tools. There's a subtle difference. You might think you know best (can't judge that) but your failure is actually convincing others of those amazing…

> Anyway, you wouldn't be the first opinionated junior developer that gets a reality check this way.

hahajahha!!! This guy just called me a junior dev. I guess that is possible. To work 17 years in the same profession, being payed, mostly as a temp contractor, having to prove your chops over and over again every year or so, but still somehow never learning anything. Thanks bro. From today on, I'll consider myself a junior web dev. You showed me the truth with your wise words.

> but your failure is actually convincing others of those amazing abilities and skills you have.

In three weeks, I got one ticket. T had to insist on being given a ticket. Ticket said fix the CSS for the login page, I fixed the CSS for ALL pages. Did you get that? All pages. You are starting to sound like my boss, asking me over and over again if the CSS was fixed even after the scrum board said so, the git history said so, I said so in daily stand-ups, and I DMed him so in slack. Wow! I guess am a failure then. Maybe I should have jumped on top of my table and repeatedly screamed "I did it! I did it! I did it!". Is that how you think I should have "convinced others of those amazing abilities". Honest question. Please let me know what else I should have done.

> They told you you don't know how to use your tools. In other words that you were not being professional.

Firefox, or even Chrome for that matter, is not a web dev tool. It is a browser. You use it to browse. Whatever you choose to browse, is your choice. Can you show me one, even just one job ad, from anywhere in this world that says "must professionally only use chrome as their web browser"?

> The fact that you are on HN complaining about this, tells me a lot. It's a bit immature behavior and you are burning a few bridges like that. That combined with a few things that maybe didn't go that well in your work in the first weeks would be a gigantic red flag for a manager.

Honestly, I don't care about your opinion. The fact that you are complaining about me complaining tells me a lot about you. Very immature, combined with some other petty arguments you have raised.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#83
post #79

To me, it's clear this was not "because you used Firefox", albeit that was the written pretext given by the company. It's also not because they changed their mind about the React rewrite. It's far more likely they thought you were going to be a bad culture fit. I could be wrong, as I have very limited context, so here's my justification for making that claim. You're giving a very one-sided view in the intro, and then…

> It's also not because they changed their mind about the React rewrite. It's far more likely they thought you were going to be a bad culture fit.

So, that is a valid argument. But looking at my termination letter, it says "did not met the performance expectations and standards".

This is after I know, that the only ticket they gave me, which I insisted on being given, did not only meet the requirements, but exceeded them. They wanted me to fix the CSS of the login page, I fixed the CSS of ALL pages. Could you be wrong, or do you need more context?

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#84

Well, that's your interpretation of what they told you. Reading between the lines there might have been a bit more going on. They told you you don't know how to use your tools. In other words that you were not being professional. Not that you are not allowed to use other tools. There's a subtle difference. You might think you know best (can't judge that) but your failure is actually convincing others of those amazing…

> Anyway, you wouldn't be the first opinionated junior developer that gets a reality check this way. hahajahha!!! This guy just called me a junior dev. I guess that is possible. To work 17 years in the same profession, being payed, mostly as a temp contractor, having to prove your chops over and over again every year or so, but still somehow never learning anything. Thanks bro. From today on, I'll consider myself a j…

> Firefox, or even Chrome for that matter, is not a web dev tool. It is a browser.

That's an odd thing to say. Firefox, Chrome and Safari are absolutely web dev tools - they're the most powerful such tools I've ever used.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You received an inheritance and decided to travel.

Yes, lying is a much better option and couldn't possibly be uncovered and give [legitimate] grounds for dismissal.

I agree with you. I have never lied, but saying the truth here will make it really hard to find my next gig, even though I did nothing wrong.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#86
post #79

To me, it's clear this was not "because you used Firefox", albeit that was the written pretext given by the company. It's also not because they changed their mind about the React rewrite. It's far more likely they thought you were going to be a bad culture fit. I could be wrong, as I have very limited context, so here's my justification for making that claim. You're giving a very one-sided view in the intro, and then…

> It's also not because they changed their mind about the React rewrite. It's far more likely they thought you were going to be a bad culture fit. So, that is a valid argument. But looking at my termination letter, it says "did not met the performance expectations and standards". This is after I know, that the only ticket they gave me, which I insisted on being given, did not only meet the requirements, but exceeded…

I absolutely could be wrong. Even if I spent 2 hours listening to both sides, I could still be wrong. This is my best guess, based on my own experience of being a manager.

My guess is that you gave them what you thought was honest and helpful feedback, but the way you delivered it made you come across as arrogant and abrasive. I say that because I get the same feeling talking to you on here.

Imagine a story that runs like this. You off-handedly made a negative judgment in public about their existing code, which was written by their longest-serving and most senior engineer, who overhears your criticism. They then criticise you in private Slack channels of which you are not a member. Now your manager has a conflict to deal with. On one side, there's a long-standing engineer who knows the existing tech stack in great depth and has delivered much value for the company. On the other is you, somebody who started three weeks ago, and doesn't know much about the tech stack. The easiest way of resolving the conflict is to get rid of you. While they could be patient and see if things improve, your somewhat abrasive reaction to your manager's request to work more in the office makes their mind up that the pain in managing you is not the worth the potential technical skills you offer. HR advises that the lack of knowledge with Angular and browser dev tools gives sufficient justification, no need to muddy the water by mentioning the personal conflicts, as that's much more subjective. Thanks tamarind8, but your work duration probation "did not met the performance expectations and standards" so we're terminating the contract, here's 2 weeks notice as per your contract.

You arrive here, and tell us that last sentence, and you're asking if it's fair. The rest of that paragraph gives context to the decision.

Now I'm not suggesting I've got all or even any of the details right there, it's simply a generic story I've seen play out quite frequently. But without knowing that kind of detailed context, it's impossible to say what happened.

You can't control the decision to fire you. It's done. Whatever the reason.

But you can now control your response to it. You can be defensive, blame everything on them, and think about taking legal action that will almost certainly fail. Or you can learn from mistakes you made and do things differently next time.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#87
post #77

You say “preferred” alot in your post. Did a leader in your organization ask you to switch tooling and you declined? I work in an organization where we cut deployment bugs in angular by a shocking 40% by consolidating our teams tooling into a consistent set of standards. If a developer started with us who after hearing this wouldnt agree to conform to those standards we would terminate them as quickly as possible.

No. No one asked me that. In fact, they are pretty easy going in terms of what tools a developer chooses.

Which is why its so crushing that he said "we have to let you go, because I do not believe you will handle the tooling we choose six months down the line"

I mean.... are this future toolings going to be brought down from aliens???

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#88
tamarind8, if it's any comfort for you I think a similar situation is quite common in the industry. It's just that not may developers talk about it when it happens, rather they are sort of shamed into thinking that somehow they are inadequate. The _only_ measure of your output is the results you deliver and the time it takes. What tools you use is irrelevant. If indeed you were talking too long to deliver, reasonable colleagues would have asked you to try a different tool set. The situation that you are probably facing is that they do not like you (for what ever reason, even if you are not responsible for it, for example you don't fit in to their old boy's club), and when people do not like you they will dig up anything and everything that they perceive is a drawback in you.

From what you have said you are certainly not a junior dev. Where I see you being somewhat naive is exposure to toxic work environments. A large number of devs and their managers are just immature and nitpicky. Somehow a technology stack is a religion for them. I personally do not know anything that will satisfy such people. And then people can be unimaginably evil, something that often escapes the typical naive engineer/dev who often do not discover it even after having worked up until retirement. Like others have mentioned you have probably dodged a bullet. And your 3 weeks gap is barely anything. Often people can have larger gaps between jobs. Sometimes you can even cover up these gaps by lying on your resume. So point being, relax, do what you can and move on....

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#89
post #65

Based on what you've told us here , that's a bit weird. Thing is, we only have half the story. We don't know what else happened in the meeting you were terminated, or got said or happened in the 3 weeks, we don't know what you did and didn't ask your mentor, we don't know how many roadblocks you hit because you're using Firefox and VS Code, we weren't there for the conversation there was about you using Chrome and Vi…

> Thing is, we only have half the story.

Yes. And what is wrong with that? If this was a court of law, then not only would you have to hear both sides, you would also have to determine which side is true. When I asked for advice, part of that request was to put yourself in my shoes, then give me some advice. Not to decide who is legally and ultimately right or wrong. That is not what I asked. I told my story, FROM MY POINT OF VIEW, AND ASKED FOR ADVICE. If I want advice from all points of view, I will, and have decided to consult a lawyer. It does not mean I do not value your advice, but please, never give someone advice by questioning WHY they are asking for advice. If you have to do that, then your advice is useless, as far as am concerned. Let's not waste each others time.

Re: Ask HN: Fired for Using Firefox

#90
post #65

Based on what you've told us here , that's a bit weird. Thing is, we only have half the story. We don't know what else happened in the meeting you were terminated, or got said or happened in the 3 weeks, we don't know what you did and didn't ask your mentor, we don't know how many roadblocks you hit because you're using Firefox and VS Code, we weren't there for the conversation there was about you using Chrome and Vi…

> Why is fair relevant? Fair is for board games with your family.

Why are you even responding to my questions, if you have no intent to help? I asked a question. I did not ask whether I should, or have the right to ask the questions. The answers you are giving, are irrelevant. Next time, please understand the question, before giving a so called answer.

Post reply on HN