Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 33 posts

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#12
post #4

Book of Proof: https://www.people.vcu.edu/~rhammack/BookOfProof/ Art of Problem Solving for if you need/want to rebuild your pre-college foundations: https://artofproblemsolving.com/store Cal Newport has great tips on studying efficiently/effectively (and you can implement some of his strategies with Anki): https://calnewport.com/case-study-how-i-got-the-highest-grad...

> Art of Problem Solving for if you need/want to rebuild your pre-college foundations

AoPS will do more than that. It will show you how to think about proving things carefully, an on ramp to the "rigor" of introductory analysis texts.

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#15
I suggest you start out with a course or book on formal logic in computer science. In particular doing proofs in intuitionistic logic. You can use a simple proof assistant to verify your proofs and it will help you really understand how proofs are done and how they are just a kind of programs in a special programming language called mathematics (given some assumptions). Proofs in higher level books are all informal, so you can’t do them programmatically in most cases, but it really helps with understanding how proofs works. After that, follow what subjects finds your fancy.

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#16
Honestly the best bet is to just read the best books for a given subject. You can figure out which books are used in curriculums by checking syllabi. Seems reasonable that if they are using the books at Harvard/Yale/MIT/Caltech/Stanford that they are probably decent.

I personally like to read a few books on the same subject in a row. It might be helpful to use wolfram alpha, SAGE, or chatgpt to explain concepts or help answer questions. Also buy a solutions manual and use it to check your answers.

As someone who did a math degree at a decent institution, I can assure you learning on your own (assuming you have the discipline) is a lot less stress than taking a class and you’ll likely learn more.

If you’re really motivated, hire a TA in the subject you are studying (online meets are fine). If you need to, just walk into the math department at a local university and ask where you can find tutors for a specific class. Just tell them you’re planning to enroll but you can’t right now.

Or check out a multitude of mathematics communities on discord or slack and ask around.

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#17
> what is the best resource to get started with studying college level mathematics?

> Basically I want to learn how to read and write proofs.

> The main goal is to understand and work through higher math books like analysis, combinatorics, graph theory, abstract algebra, etc.

I feel like these are three somewhat distinct goals, and may need distinct approaches.

If you only have HS geometry and algebra, you may want to fill in some additional foundational knowledge first. If the algebra is what we refer to in the US as "Algebra 1", then definitely do "Algebra 2" / "Precalculus" and preferably calculus as well. Someone else recommended Khan Academy, which is a great resource for this level. Calculus is not strictly required for most of the upper-level topics you mentioned, with the exception of analysis, for which it is a strong prerequisite.

For proofs, check out one of the dedicated "how to write proofs" books recommended by others. You can probably dive right into these, as they rarely require calculus or other prerequisites, as they focus mainly on simple proofs in geometry, number theory, set theory, combinatorics, and other fairly "entry level" topics.

A discrete math textbook is another good way to get started with proofs. These often cover basic topics in logic, set theory, and proof methods (induction, proof by contradiction, etc.). They also typically cover basic graph theory, combinatorics, and sometimes even basic abstract algebra (groups, rings, etc.), which will give you a head start on some of the advanced topics. Rosen's discrete math book is a good choice, widely used in courses at respectable universities.

Once you've covered that material, you should be good to go on the advanced topics you mentioned.

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#18
post #11

https://github.com/TalalAlrawajfeh/mathematics-roadmap

So this is exactly the thing that I hated so much.

Click into the book list and you realize that there is at least 6 book on single topic and 90% of their coverage and explanation is literally the same. Then you have to dig every corner of those books to find out what you are missing.

You can never get a definitive edition of a math textbook that cover all topics and achieving teaching & show the formal proof simultaneously.

I can recognize 10~books on the list, and they are all not good. They just hide the most importance topics and proofs in exercises and of course no solution or guide provided. Good luck if you can learn any thing from math texts.

Re: Ask HN: Books or courses to understand college level mathematics?

#20
How about interactive books? Like Immersive Linear Algebra by J. Ström, K. Åström and T. Akenine-Möller; or http://immersivemath.com/ila/index.html or Interactive Linear Algebra by Dan Margalit and Joseph Rabinoff https://textbooks.math.gatech.edu/ila/index.html

I suppose they should work well for self-study, but I never tried learning by one myself.

Post reply on HN