Live data from Hacker News

Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

support.upwork.com

101–110 of 115 posts

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#101
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Lifetime, in theory. In practice, you can move the relationship off Upwork after 2 years. See https://support.upwork.com/hc/en-us/articles/360043210654-Mo...

> Taking a relationship outside of Upwork without first paying the Conversion Fee is a serious violation of the our Terms of Service. This sounds like something a pimp or a mob boss would say.

It's hard to find any important difference between the two.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#102
Coincidentally, I just became Top Rated Plus (as opposed to normal Top Rated) on Upwork thanks to finishing my first large contract! I'm going to have a mini-party with my wife to celebrate, haha. Upwork dramatically changed my life. I don't care much either way about the fee change, but I get why other people do.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#103
post #41

When I started out as a freelancer / independent contractor, I made the conscious decision to not use any of these platforms, out of fear for my client base or finances being tied up and taken away from me due to a simple ToS violation; the fees never sat with me either. Admittedly, it took so much longer to get a consistent base of clients (1-2 years), but it feels like a fresh of breath air over having to rely on a…

The advertisement of your service seems like the best part of Upwork though. If you already have clients, there's no point in using it.

Isn't it against the ToS? If you advertise yourself as an independent entity you basically lure people outside of the platform.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#104
post #83
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Has anyone paid this fee? I think when it gets to the point of dropping 12% of a freelancer's annual income to just talk outside of the platform it's simply not worth it.

If you wait two years per grandparent's post, the fee is only $1, which probably is worth it. If you want to convert sooner, it's a percentage of the income for that specific client/freelancer relationship, and not total work for the freelancer. So it is probably a more palatable amount, assuming the freelancer has multiple clients.

Yeah but the fee is calculated as a percentage of a full time (2080 hour) year. So it's only worthwhile if you're being hired fulltime, near full time, or at a much higher rate than your existing upwork rate.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#105

Why are they still afloat? Last time I checked you couldn't find any work there: - You could only find jobs if you were ready to underbid everyone else. - The disproportion between the amount of work and job-seekers was abysmal. - The platform did nothing to protect the workers from untruthful or exploitative clients (from anecdotal evidence). - Upwork attracts clients who can't find contractors any other way, mostly…

It was that way from day one.

It is like it's own career. You start off being underpaid to get a reputation, and work your way up.

Weird story: I started my career on odesk (before it was called upwork) and finished 50 or so contracts before I moved 3.5k miles to my first bay area job.

Which was across the street from the odesk office.

Weird world.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#106
post #92
post #78

How's Upwork nowadays? I tried getting some gigs there for 3+ years and got nothing. I had more success with r/forhire and Craigslist and the good thing is there's no middleman. Heck, I even spent for Freelancer Plus and I just lost my connects to people who didn't even consider to read my proposal and check my profile

I used it many years ago and it was decent, but not good. Tried again recently and it’s way worse than I remember. Pretty much every client expects you to enter a bidding war starting at $100 (and going down, obv) to build them a multiplatform app with backend and a mountain of features. What I don’t understand is who accepts these jobs? Scammers? I can’t imagine that Upwork has many happy clients.

$100 in US is INR8000 in India, if the job timeline is one week, and they took up 4 jobs in a month that is 32,000. Which is more than the entry level software job salary. Upwork is a global company, not just the US market, so thinking in local currency won't make sense. I was on Fiverr 7 years ago I explored it a lot, during my course of finding work there I came across interesting things. There were dedicated shops that took up 10-15 projects a week in the same bracket as u mention, the owner of one such shop bought a Harley Davidson in a year(Harley Davidson bikes cost a lot in India) his shop was 4 fresh out graduates who exclusively built WordPress websites. And there are many such groups. Also funny enough most of the logo/graphic design/video edit jobs a remixes of PSDs/templates found on envato, freelogogenerator etc. You rarely find quality in such sites, you get what you pay for.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#108
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I'm hiring an employee, I'm looking for you! A generalist who will apply their wealth of database experience to my problems and learn what they need for my specifics along the way. I expect to pay some on ramp time where I don't get much in return. When I'm hiring a contractor, I'm not really interested in paying them to learn, I'm interested in getting my need fulfilled as efficiently as possible. If the proble…

Makes sense, but I do not completely agree. In my 11 years of experience as a consultant, people hire me because they need a square zinc sink fixed, but as soon as they see that I know much more than that, they ask me to redo the living room wall and trim the topiary. Being an expert gets me through the door, being a generalist keeps me around. The problem is that the square sink expert filter is the biggest obstacle…

This makes total sense to me as both an employer and for hiring contractors. Sure, if it’s easy to find a square sink expert (it’s usually not), then select for that, generally though, my needs are more varied than that, even if that’s my immediate need and I’d prefer a targeted generalist to be able to solve my immediate problem with a short ramp up time and then hopefully go on to provide value in other areas.

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#109

Why are they still afloat? Last time I checked you couldn't find any work there: - You could only find jobs if you were ready to underbid everyone else. - The disproportion between the amount of work and job-seekers was abysmal. - The platform did nothing to protect the workers from untruthful or exploitative clients (from anecdotal evidence). - Upwork attracts clients who can't find contractors any other way, mostly…

> Upwork attracts clients who can't find contractors any other way

What is the best 'other way', though? Situation: Technical guy at a small company or nonprofit who needs _X_ more complicated technical task done. The choice is either to learn some new skill (lots of time) or find an expert. What other expert marketplaces are there that offer a substantially better environment or experience for all parties?

Re: Upwork removing 5% commission bracket and moving everyone to 10% bracket

#110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The advertisement of your service seems like the best part of Upwork though. If you already have clients, there's no point in using it.

Isn't it against the ToS? If you advertise yourself as an independent entity you basically lure people outside of the platform.

Yes it’s against the ToS of most service platforms.
Post reply on HN