Live data from Hacker News

Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

blog.waymo.com

141–150 of 520 posts

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#141
post #122

I live inside the original area in Phoenix where they did their training. I have to give kudos where it's due. I originally _hated_ their cars constantly driving around our neighborhood, but I was persuaded to try one a few weeks back. It completely changed my mind. They are now my favorite way to get around. I am a very happy, frequent customer and hope they keep adding coverage and more cars. This is absolutely the…

I live downtown PHX (Roosevelt Row) and beyond riding in them I MUCH prefer them driving around on the streets than actual human drivers. There isn't a day goes by that I don't see drivers make up 4-way stops, disregard the 4-way stops, flip a youey in the middle of an intersection, etc. Contrast that to the ever predictable Weymo, just quietly going about their little self-driving existence. Only problem I've seen w…

>they will cross it will stop and wait until the heat-death of the universe for them to cross.

There's something adorable and HHGTG about that whole thing! Reminds me of the robotic Star Liner that refused to take off because of the peanuts hadn't been delivered thus its checklist was incomplete. It had waited eons as its passengers withered to corpses securely locked into the cabin only stating that it was 'statistically likely a new civilisation with peanut packages will arise on this planet'.

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, at least in this instance, the traditional vehicles were all stopped in the appropriate place.

Human vehicles also eventually fix problems by bending or breaking the law if necessary.

I wonder what happens when a police officer tries to pull one over.

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#143
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The baby steps makes sense, but you gotta admit Phoenix has to be thr easiest metro area to test with: Little inclement weather, little terrain change, newer infrastructure, streets mostly laid out in an east-west, north-south grid with consistent naming and numbering.

Waymo and Cruise have also been operating in San Francisco for a while, which is quite the opposite.

Most of Waymo's hours are in simulation anyway, and that can be as hard as they want it to be. Waymo's meatspace test track is also nothing but edge cases.

I understand that Tesla also learns in simulation.

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#144

I've had access in SF for the past few months and have been really impressed! The Waymo rides I've taken have been confident + a bit conservative (e.g. driving at the speed limit when traffic is flowing more quickly), but overall the team's done a great job with the experience. It's free for now so I've been using it regularly during commuting/rush hour and casual drives. Some quick thoughts: Advantages over Uber/Lyf…

How is pricing?

It's free for now.

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The difference is that the variable costs are much lower - just recharging the EV + any other incidentals, as opposed to having to pay a driver for every ride. That's why Uber never became profitable, because they had to share the fare. Waymo has higher up front costs, but if the cars are there, they have much more profitable fares.

Maybe - Waymo has to recharge, clean and maintain a fleet of cars that they own (and which are depreciating and likely have no resale value, at least at the moment) - Uber's drivers effectively use their wages to cover all of those costs. I'm curious how Waymo is handling all of the fleet maintenance, recharging, cleaning, etc, and how they plan to scale that infrastructure. I also wonder how Waymo plans to handle 's…

EVs need very little complicated maintenance. At this point, batteries and electric motors are a rock-solid technology.

So you're left with occasional minor maintenance for mechanical issues like broken door handles or jammed windows, and also with interior cleaning.

Even this can in future be minimized by building a taxi-only car model. You can get rid of the steering wheel, instrument cluster, central console, and all the complicated plastic parts that go with all of this. You can just replace everything with durable and easily washable hard plastic, like seats on public transit.

Then make seats easily removable, and the interior becomes straightforward to clean (heck, you can even automate it).

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#146
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why did you hate them at first? What about the experience of using the service changed your opinion?

> Why did you hate them at first? I walk my dogs twice a day and the cars are constantly driving by with their array of sensors. Made me feel like I was being constantly filmed and recorded... which as I understand them to work I certainly was/am. Outside of that, I resented being involuntarily part of a science experiment that is objectively pretty dangerous all things considered. For example, I would never cross th…

Yeah I hope Waymo expands soon out to Mesa/Gilbert area where I am. My wife has never driven in the 20 years we’ve been together. Fortunately we live within a 5-10 minute walk of an intersection with multiple grocery stores, lots of restaurants and medical offices but it would be nice for her to be able to go beyond that bubble without my help. She feels bad about using Uber for 2 mile drives (even though she tips well) but wouldn’t feel bad about using a self driving for those purposes.

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#147
post #122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I live downtown PHX (Roosevelt Row) and beyond riding in them I MUCH prefer them driving around on the streets than actual human drivers. There isn't a day goes by that I don't see drivers make up 4-way stops, disregard the 4-way stops, flip a youey in the middle of an intersection, etc. Contrast that to the ever predictable Weymo, just quietly going about their little self-driving existence. Only problem I've seen w…

>they will cross it will stop and wait until the heat-death of the universe for them to cross. There's something adorable and HHGTG about that whole thing! Reminds me of the robotic Star Liner that refused to take off because of the peanuts hadn't been delivered thus its checklist was incomplete. It had waited eons as its passengers withered to corpses securely locked into the cabin only stating that it was 'statisti…

Lemon-scented paper napkins, IIRC (I hadn't recalled corrected, so I updated it). Also Marvin spent ~millions of years in the car park for the Restaurant at the End of the Universe: ""The first ten-million years were the worst. And the second ten-million - they were the worst too… The third ten-million, I didn’t enjoy at all. After that I went into a bit of a decline. "

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#148
post #32

I know they started testing a while back in LA, has anyone been in one there? I haven’t seen them around town like I have in SF.

LA is employee only for now ( https://twitter.com/Waymo/status/1630326911648841730?cxt=HHw... ). We often do smaller announcements / updates only via Twitter, rather than a blog post on blog.waymo.com.

Please consider adding Mastodon!

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Imagine sinking all that money that's being blown on self-driving cars into pedestrian and bicycle infrastructure This does jack squat for getting across San Francisco or from corner to corner of Phoenix.

You can already bike from one part of SF to another, investment in bicycle infrastructure would make that easier and safer. Or, you know, public transit. Individual vehicles suffer from massive inefficiency compared to nearly any other form of transportation – look at Elon's fully autonomous tunnel.

SF is not really a great bikeable city; almost any location to any location involves hills, some of them really significant. The streets are also not laid out in a reasonable pattern in many locations.

Getting from outer sunset to market by bike daily isn't really practical, especially during Weather.,

Re: Waymo One doubles service area in Phoenix, continues growing in SF

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s not really when you consider their burn rate. Say each of those trips gross 10$. That’s just 100k/week or $5.2 million/year. They’d need to likely 10,000x the ride volume to even be close to profitability. Uber does 7.64 billion rides per year. And they are not profitable. The waymo cars sure ain’t cheap, and scale of operations will take a ton of cash. I wonder if waymo would ever be profitable.

1. It's impossible! 2. It's possible but it's going to take forever 3. It's real and happening now but it's dangerous 4. It's not dangerous but it's annoying and blocking an intersection sometimes 5. It's not annoying but maybe they won't make money we are here. 6. It makes money but what about drivers 7. It works in cities but what about suburbs 8. It works in suburbs but what about rural areas 9. This city in Turkm…

hopefully we get to 8 before waymo.com posts "An Update on Waymo self-driving cars" and kills the project. That said, this is one project that google really seems to have invested for the long-term.
Post reply on HN