Live data from Hacker News

The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

phys.org

21–30 of 159 posts

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#21

Any divider of 819 also aligns. > And 13 cycles of Saturn's 378-day synodic period adds up to 4,914 days, which is the same as six times 819. 6 * 819 = 6 * (3 * 273) = 18 * 273. All integers that divide 819: 1, 3, 7, 9, 13, 21, 39, 63, 91, 117, 273, 819 How this hypothesis explains why 819 was preferred over those other numbers?

Because they had found a prior mention of a 819 day period in relation to calendars, but didn't make the link at the time (from my understanding of the paper)

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#23
post #9
post #5

Sounds like a "guess" rather than a "solution". They have noticed a numerical coincidence and formed a hypothesis. Without additional evidence tying the 819-day count to astronomical observations its not particularly convincing.

Yeah, I'm all for investigating this line of thinking further, but all sorts of weird coincidences come up in numerology that no serious person would consider "science".

Is this science? This is a human made up calendar, not how many protons are in a gold atom.

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#24
post #19
post #15

Ok, so when is the actual end of the world if not 2012?

How do you know it wasn't 2012?

Seriously. Looking around, I would not be surprised to learn we have already passed the end of the world and have moved into hell.

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#25
TLDR: Researchers solved the Mayan 819-day count mystery by finding that 20 cycles of it align with the planets' recurring positions in the sky over a 45-year period, connecting it to the general Maya calendar, the Tzolk'in.

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#26
post #18
post #15

Ok, so when is the actual end of the world if not 2012?

A year after the supposed year of the end of the world has passed without incident. The goalposts must be kept moving.

it's only been a year since 2012? Man it feels longer, must be all the bad news

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#27
post #7
post #3

This implies that the Mayan must have been recording the positions of the planets with great accuracy over a rather long period of time, probably spanning several generations.

It seems incredibly clever - and I realise that I assumed they weren't aware of most planets since they're hard to see today, but I'm sure they were very noteworthy event in the pristine sky they were looking at.

it's like if we had the same TV show every night for our whole life, i think we would start to notice some patterns

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#28
post #5

Sounds like a "guess" rather than a "solution". They have noticed a numerical coincidence and formed a hypothesis. Without additional evidence tying the 819-day count to astronomical observations its not particularly convincing.

There's basically no surviving Mayan literature, thanks to the hard work of the Catholic church. So good luck finding more evidence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_civilization#Writing_and_...

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#29
post #9
post #5

Sounds like a "guess" rather than a "solution". They have noticed a numerical coincidence and formed a hypothesis. Without additional evidence tying the 819-day count to astronomical observations its not particularly convincing.

Yeah, I'm all for investigating this line of thinking further, but all sorts of weird coincidences come up in numerology that no serious person would consider "science".

Maybe. What becomes clear when visiting the archeological sites of Mayans and even predecessors to the Mayans is how absolutely serious they were about the calendar, the seasons, the pathways and timings of the sun and moon, the comings and goings of the animals in accordance with the calendar, etc. I wouldn't call the hypothesis in that paper numerology. It's entirely in line with what they devoted incredible amounts of energy to. Circumstantial, sure, but a bit more than coincidental.

Re: The Mayan calendar might represent a longer timescale than previously considered

#30
post #21

Any divider of 819 also aligns. > And 13 cycles of Saturn's 378-day synodic period adds up to 4,914 days, which is the same as six times 819. 6 * 819 = 6 * (3 * 273) = 18 * 273. All integers that divide 819: 1, 3, 7, 9, 13, 21, 39, 63, 91, 117, 273, 819 How this hypothesis explains why 819 was preferred over those other numbers?

Because they had found a prior mention of a 819 day period in relation to calendars, but didn't make the link at the time (from my understanding of the paper)

The researchers saw prior mention of 819. But Mayans, why did they choose 819?
Post reply on HN